I’ve done Artist Point on the Sunday night after Dopey. This was about 5 years ago, I think it was the first year after Artist Point made the transition to its current offering. It was one of our least favorite character experiences at WDW.
To start, we waited about 45 minutes to be seated which was over 30 minutes after our reservation time. The reasons for this are somewhat self-evident but will come even more into focus as the story goes along.
The meal was…fine, I guess. It was typical Disney prix fixe meal stuff. The appetizers and dessert presentation were kind of cool and I’d say the better parts of the meal; the main courses weren’t terrible, but it felt mass-produced in the most obvious way. Probably the worst prime rib I’ve had at Disney.
The big problem, though, was the characters. Obviously, Dopey is in demand as a character that night even beyond what would happen at a normal character dinner. But we streeeeeetttttttcccccchhhhhhheeeeeeed our meal out as much as we could (spent over an hour there, which is a long time for us) and still never got visits by Dopey or Snow White. Despite this, it became very clear that our presence was no longer appreciated even though staff knew from the moment we arrived at the restaurant that we had Dopey finishers and getting character pictures was our primary goal. They were clearly getting even further backed up out front because tables weren’t leaving on the schedule they had booked for (almost certainly for the same reason we extended our stay).
We do have pictures with Grumpy and the Evil Queen (who meets at a predetermined spot as diners exit after finishing their meal). Grumpy was really making the rounds that night as it seems like they tried to pass off multiple visits with Grumpy as equivalent to seeing all 3 characters. EQ face actor on the night was outstanding and we had a great experience with her on our way out. We spent about 5 minutes with the EQ and there was no one with her before us and no one waiting on us. I can only imagine how much time Dopey and Snow White must’ve been spending at individual tables that night to have never made it to ours.
Of course, disclaimer of all disclaimers, our experience was our own. It may be greatly changed since that night. They may have a much better idea of how to keep things moving on obvious Dopey Challenge celebration nights (and food quality is both in the eye of the beholder and could easily have been improved in the intervening years). It was not a great night for us, but I didn’t view it as irredeemable. If we had the same time with Dopey and Snow White as we had with Grumpy and the EQ it probably would’ve been an awesome experience.
ETA: Hopefully there are some more opinions out there to give a more balanced look at things. It was somewhat tough to evaluate the overall experience when we were, essentially, there to visit with Dopey; and we never got to visit with Dopey.