In-Law Vent

OP I know just what your feeling. A former friend of mine would only give you a present if you opened it in front of her and thanked her then and there. Also she expected a written thank you note mailed to her and would mention the gift in front of other people for months. I think it's beyond rude to demand a thank you for anything.
 
I'm going to be the voice of dissent.
Okay I get that he didn't call on Sunday. But there are many days between Sunday and Friday. Why couldn't you have dialed the phoned and handed it to him on Monday? Sorry, while I don't believe in guilt calls I do believe in having my DD thank her grandparents and her great-grandmother asap.
My ILs live out of state. When the gift arrives we pick up the phone, she chats for 60 seconds and hands the phone over to one of us. Obligation done, ILs know she received the gift. They're happy, DD is happy and we're happy. Simple and end of story.

Not quite sure why you are so bent out of shape about it. Should have had him call earlier in the week.

Unless I'm confused, the party was yesterday.
 
I'd just have him call this afternoon and then be done with the issue.

My view: My kids have 2 great-grandma's left. My paternal paw paw died last month and my maternal paw paw and dh's paw paw both died last year. DD got to visit great-great-grandma (dh's side) as a baby before she died and great-great-grandma (my side) was knitting dd an afgan and died before she was born, both were long done before ds was born. Kids are lucky to spend any amount of years with the greats and some great-grans lives only revolve around their grandkids (like dh's), so that phone call could be more important to her. They may get on your nerves sometimes, but with age comes certain exceptions :). If I get asked or my kids ask to do something, its as good as done.
 

I don't understand to begin with why his parents thought they needed to tell you when to call the great grandmother to thank her. I think some people forget just how complicated things get when you have younger children...let alone trying to get through a birthday celebration. There are a lot of things that get forgotten about until the next day or so later. But, if she's like my grandmother (she's 94) she's not really awake at 8:30 or 9.

Handing the card over should have been sufficient involvement on their part.

Something I think that is more likely...maybe the great grandmother gave them the card earlier in the week and hadn't heard that they passed it along. She might have called to check that. So it might actually be your husband's parents trying to pass along their guilt onto you.
 
I have a different spin on it. Yes, it is annoying having people tell you when and how you should call etc. However, would it really have been a big deal to take 2 minutes that night and make the call? The child in question is 8. I would think you could just simply say "Let's give grandma a quick call so you can tell her you like her gift. I bet she would love to hear that." No meltdowns etc. It would literally have taken 2 minutes. I know it is very frustrating but sometimes you have to decide if it is worth the aggravation or not. You know the dynamic of the family. It is not going to change. Is this something that you want to cut off contact with them over? If not then I personally would have just made the call that night and it would have been done with.

Yeah, I know...here come the flames.:upsidedow
 
YOu don't dont ggmil! She does expect bow and scrape and IMMEDIATE satisfaction, which is why in-laws said to have him call last night since they didn't wnat to deal with the phone call they knew they would get today. It is just the way she operates. Now, my fil should have just not called us, and we would have had him call today (no he hasn't yet..he has school, and that comes before phone calls).

My fil brings out the worst in me..he drives me nuts!! Especially where my DS is concerned. He is really an idiot, and doesn't know when to keep his mouth shut! The fact that they live 5 mintues away doesn't help at times either! I am ok with my mil (well most of the time), she is a really nice women but there are things she does that really makes me want to move really really far away!!
So ... kind of an in-law issue on way more levels than just a thank-you phone call. Although, if a quick call had been made -- say, prior to ice cream or prior to playing with brother -- it would have taken five minutes and you'd be spared from all the nutiness. If ggmil has been doing this forever, and if your FIL has been driving you nuts all this time, then you had to have known (or at least suspected) this was going to happen. I'm a big believer that five minutes of annoyance is far preferable to two days of raging frustration! :goodvibes

:earsboy:
 
I'm with you, Mouse House Mama. I get being annoyed at having to call immediately... but I see both sides of the coin too. A lonely eldery lady that probably has thought about the card and gift way too much. My DH's grandma gets very nervy about giving money. She's really into making sure you got it ok, it didn't get boosted in the mail, etc.

Also, part of me thinks that whatever her issues or demands, she's elderly, so you suck it up and pay her the respect of the phone call.

I can understand the exasperation, but I don't find it that annoying. I think teaching your kids to say thanks is never remiss, so nothing is lost by thanking her on her time table.
 
I have a different spin on it. Yes, it is annoying having people tell you when and how you should call etc. However, would it really have been a big deal to take 2 minutes that night and make the call? The child in question is 8. I would think you could just simply say "Let's give grandma a quick call so you can tell her you like her gift. I bet she would love to hear that." No meltdowns etc. It would literally have taken 2 minutes. I know it is very frustrating but sometimes you have to decide if it is worth the aggravation or not. You know the dynamic of the family. It is not going to change. Is this something that you want to cut off contact with them over? If not then I personally would have just made the call that night and it would have been done with.

Yeah, I know...here come the flames.:upsidedow

No flames from me, because I was going to post the same thing you just beat me to it. :)

I guess I don't understand all the drama. The OP knows how the g-grandma is, and this kid is 8, not 2, so I'm not sure I understand the whole meltdown thing.

It would have taken 2 minutes to have your 8 yo say thank you to a nice old lady who thought of him on his day. Sorry , thats how I see it.
 
I am so annoyed at FIL and his mother. OMG!! DS turned 8 yesterday. e on Sunday since they are taking us for Dim Sum (I so want to stay home)!!!
Listen to what they have to say, nod your head in agreement, and then you and DS should do things your own ways.

Family hints: http://www.cockam.com/family.htm

Common dilemma of mine put to the tune of the OP's:

"Poll question: I look at the clock and it's 11 PM and I forgot to phone and say 'thank you'. Should I do so now or tomorrow?"
 
I'm going to be the voice of dissent.
Okay I get that he didn't call on Sunday. But there are many days between Sunday and Friday. Why couldn't you have dialed the phoned and handed it to him on Monday? Sorry, while I don't believe in guilt calls I do believe in having my DD thank her grandparents and her great-grandmother asap.
My ILs live out of state. When the gift arrives we pick up the phone, she chats for 60 seconds and hands the phone over to one of us. Obligation done, ILs know she received the gift. They're happy, DD is happy and we're happy. Simple and end of story.

Not quite sure why you are so bent out of shape about it. Should have had him call earlier in the week.


Where did Sunday and Friday come it?? His birthday was Thursday. He got the check at 6:45 PM...his bed time is 8 PM. He call his great grandmother on Friday at 3:45 pm, this was 5 minutes after he got home from school. The gripe was that he didn't call within the 2 hour window he had on Thursday night. I think a call within 24 hours is very acceptable. The problem is the great grandmother.

I am entitled to vent thank you very much, which is what I did.
 
I'd just have him call this afternoon and then be done with the issue.

My view: My kids have 2 great-grandma's left. My paternal paw paw died last month and my maternal paw paw and dh's paw paw both died last year. DD got to visit great-great-grandma (dh's side) as a baby before she died and great-great-grandma (my side) was knitting dd an afgan and died before she was born, both were long done before ds was born. Kids are lucky to spend any amount of years with the greats and some great-grans lives only revolve around their grandkids (like dh's), so that phone call could be more important to her. They may get on your nerves sometimes, but with age comes certain exceptions :). If I get asked or my kids ask to do something, its as good as done.


Believe me..this women's life does not revolve around my kids..or her 2 grandsons (DH and BIL), it revolves around her!!
 
I don't understand to begin with why his parents thought they needed to tell you when to call the great grandmother to thank her. I think some people forget just how complicated things get when you have younger children...let alone trying to get through a birthday celebration. There are a lot of things that get forgotten about until the next day or so later. But, if she's like my grandmother (she's 94) she's not really awake at 8:30 or 9.

Handing the card over should have been sufficient involvement on their part.

Something I think that is more likely...maybe the great grandmother gave them the card earlier in the week and hadn't heard that they passed it along. She might have called to check that. So it might actually be your husband's parents trying to pass along their guilt onto you.


His parents do it all the time, because they know his mom is going to call first thing when/if she didn't get a call in time, and they don't want the call. They are also afraid DH is going to forget, where as I won't. But I put my DS's needs to enjoy spending time with is older brother and trying to get him wound down above the unrealistic needs/wants of his great-grandmother.

My kids are very generous in their thank yous and showing appreciation. If she had been there she would have been phsically knocked over when he grabbed her to hug her!
 
So ... kind of an in-law issue on way more levels than just a thank-you phone call. Although, if a quick call had been made -- say, prior to ice cream or prior to playing with brother -- it would have taken five minutes and you'd be spared from all the nutiness. If ggmil has been doing this forever, and if your FIL has been driving you nuts all this time, then you had to have known (or at least suspected) this was going to happen. I'm a big believer that five minutes of annoyance is far preferable to two days of raging frustration! :goodvibes

:earsboy:


Well yes, many in-law issues as most people have. I don't give in to them, but will vent :). The second my DS woke up he was in super hyper mode, it being hsi birthday. The only calm part of his day was when he was sleeping. My main goal of the day was hoping he would be calm enough to finish his hw before his activity that afternoon. Thursday's are hectic enough without birthday's. It wasn't worth the aggravation to me or to him to make the call that would have waited till the next day. My priorties are to my son, not my inlaws. I won't even start on the tone of my mil voice when she asked when we were having DS's cake and she found out we were doing it ON his birthday!! But that is besides the point. There is nothing wrong with him calling her the next day. I have learned as a mom of four to pick my battles. I know my son, my battles that night were homework and bedtime..I wasn't going to add a phone call to it. And yes, to have him stop what he was doing to get his attention switched to make that phone call that night would have been a battle.
 
I'm with you, Mouse House Mama. I get being annoyed at having to call immediately... but I see both sides of the coin too. A lonely eldery lady that probably has thought about the card and gift way too much. My DH's grandma gets very nervy about giving money. She's really into making sure you got it ok, it didn't get boosted in the mail, etc.

Also, part of me thinks that whatever her issues or demands, she's elderly, so you suck it up and pay her the respect of the phone call.

I can understand the exasperation, but I don't find it that annoying. I think teaching your kids to say thanks is never remiss, so nothing is lost by thanking her on her time table.


I would call this women alot of thngs...but elderly isn't one of them. From the stories I have been told she has been this way all her life. Very demanding and controlling. I will not give her what she watns just because she wants it. My DS called the next day, and that is acceptable in all forms of polite society. Her demands are not. If she wants to stop giving my kids checks..I am fine with that.

There is NOTHING that this women will not complain about, and it has nothing to do with her age, believe me. She is not a nice sweet little old lady in any way shape or form!!

Respect is soemthing that is earned by how one treats others, not because of your age. If you are respectful to others they in turn should be respectful to you.
 
Listen to what they have to say, nod your head in agreement, and then you and DS should do things your own ways.

Family hints: http://www.cockam.com/family.htm

Common dilemma of mine put to the tune of the OP's:

"Poll question: I look at the clock and it's 11 PM and I forgot to phone and say 'thank you'. Should I do so now or tomorrow?"


LOL..thanks, and that is what DH and I did. It is acutally how we do most things with his parents. I think he would like to move away more then me!!
 
I hope this doesn't come off sounding snarky because I'm really not being snarky about it. But after having read the entire thread, including the rationalizations/explanations of why a call wasn't made the night of receiving the gift, I think if this happens again in the future the proper thing to do would be to simply refuse the gift.

Because that's what we're really talking about here: a gift, not an obligation.

Of course, the GGMIL may decide not to gift again which will solve everyone's problem in the future.
 
I hope this doesn't come off sounding snarky because I'm really not being snarky about it. But after having read the entire thread, including the rationalizations/explanations of why a call wasn't made the night of receiving the gift, I think if this happens again in the future the proper thing to do would be to simply refuse the gift.

Because that's what we're really talking about here: a gift, not an obligation.

Of course, the GGMIL may decide not to gift again which will solve everyone's problem in the future.

Yup it would!! DH and I are both ready to give it back now, and just give DS the moeny, he wouldn't know the difference! But..I don't have to think about it until next year when he is 9, or if she is still around!!
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom