Yeah - to compare two elite level travelers carrying the most prestigious credit card:
Hilton (the SouthFayetteFan valuation of these is 0.6cpp)
Diamond Elite - has a Hilton Aspire card (this card gives you auto Diamond status, but our hypothetical regular traveler can earn this through stays anyways)
They have a $1,000 hotel bill
- Earn 10x points on the $1,000 = 10,000 pts
- Earn double points as diamond = 10,000 pts
- Pays with Aspire = earns 14x points = 14,000 pts
- TOTAL STAY = 34,000 pts worth ~$204
Marriott (the SouthFayetteFan valuation of these is 0.8cpp)
Platinum Premier Elite - has an SPG Luxury Card (this card does not give you Plat status - you have to earn that on your own with stays)
They also have a $1,000 hotel bill
- Earn 10x points on the $1,000 = 10,000 pts
- 75% bump on points as Plat Prem = 7,500 pts
- Pays with SPG Luxury = earns 6x points = 6,000 pts
- TOTAL STAY = 23,500 pts = $188
Conclusion
So the traveler with
Hilton earned 10,500 more points (which to the uneducated eye sounds awesome) BUT
it's just $16 more worth of points because of the different valuations. Of course you could argue with my valuations (but I feel strongly that Marriott is worth slightly more than Hilton). Still - if you are a business traveler who is regularly generating a $1,000 hotel bill
that $16 could add up very quickly. I didn't include any promotional points because both chains run promotions and it's really hard to value what they're worth as they're usually super complex promotions requiring multiple stays.