I signed up for the Disney Visa before I started credit card churning. I don’t think it’s worth a 5/24 slot but since you and your husband are at 0/24 you can probably take the hit if you want the card. It will get you discounts in the parks and special meet and greets but IMO that’s the only reason to get it. If I were you I would try for the Citi Premier. The bonus is 80,000 points for $4,000 spend in three months. It has a $95 annual fee but has a good amount of 3x spend categories. When I got the card most of my spend was for Disney tickets for my trip in May 2022. That earned me 3x points for the travel purchase.
Another option is the Capital One Venture X. It’s new and very popular. The high annual fee can easily be made up by the perks. Check out the link below for more details.
(link removed from quote because I think it's keeping me from posting since I'm a noob!)
So if I have an annual passholder in my party (my mom, who is local and not in the hotel, but will be with us most of the time otherwise), then it sounds like there is very little reason to get the Disney Visa at this point, since I think a lot of the discounts overlap, don't they?
Thanks for clarifying, and for pointing out some AF cards we might consider. The AMEX Blue Cash Pref is our only AF card right now, and we easily max 6% on groceries each year which has it pay for itself and then some. Well, I guess our Costco Citi has a fee that goes with our membership, but that also easily pays for itself just on 4% gas with my 100 miles of daily commuting...
I'm kind of over the "keeping track of rotating categories" thing that I used to do, so I will look at some solid rewards cards we can use for regular spending. We dine out a lot, so I should probably go look at Savor again, as well.
Given that we are staying CL (Poly and AK) for 8 total nights, I see no issues hitting minimum spend for most offers, but in the past when I was paying down debt, I was all about that 0AF 0%BT rewards life, but now that we have knocked it all out, I never really restrategized my card selection to consider cards with an AF.
Glad I posted - thanks for the advice!