I love credit cards so much! v2.0 (see first page for add'l details)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh man - people on that news thread would FREAK OUT about how off topic we get here. I understand in one respect why they handle that thread the way they do. BUT the fact that we fly off topic is what makes this a community. Knowing that @Haley R is now in Japan, her husband just got a new job in Florida, they have cats, they played in a band, she recently rekindled her love of volleyball, etc. is what makes this place great! (Ok...so apparently I know A LOT about @Haley R and nothing about the rest of you...)

Well wait, that's a lie... @amalone1013 has a husband who used to drive a creeper van! So I know something else at least :P

Now @Lain - that dude be crazy with the spreadsheet. If you broke a law in your college years he knows about it...he knows things about me that I don't even know about myself!!! At any rate...our thread is the best...that is all.
I know you are not a woman and you are not old! You are a 35'ish yo man who lives in your parent's basement and "works" (aka: naps...) in your recliner. See, I know things too 😆
 

So I shared the other day about that terrible blog page that was all about "free travel to Disney" that popped up on a random r/churning comment. So cool update on that story:

I reached out to that reddit user and shared a few comments in a PM about why they might want to do a little more research. They shared with me that they just had a newborn (2nd child) the day prior. Apparently they were passing time in the hospital planning a potential Disney trip a year or so from now. This sparked me to ask some more questions and now we're in a full-fledged discussion about planning their Disney World trip. I'm covering both the "Disney" piece of planning AND the "Points" piece. Instead of offering just 2 Marriott hotel options, I'm actually allowing them to give me some detail on their preferences and provide actual customized advice. AND instead of being blindly led by affiliate links (a sort of support link available to bloggers) I'm providing advice completely irregardless of "what's in it for me".

This coming on the tails of helping a co-worker IRL with some initial Disney planning (i.e. park days, dining, etc.) for a trip later this year they are taking. I had noticed they were getting some downright TERRIBLE advice on Facebook (no surprise there!).

I said something to that coworker that also resonates with my recent reddit interaction... IF somebody giving you advice IS NOT asking lots of questions - they likely ARE NOT giving you good advice. It drives me crazy when people assume there is a right way to do Disney or a right way to churn, etc. Some funny observations:
  • I literally saw somebody give my coworker the advice "You have to do evening EMH - they are a must". My coworker has 2 children under the age of 6 who get up at 6am every morning and go to bed at 8pm. Did anybody think to ask about that...NO, because their way is the only way and must be the right way.
  • I saw another comment where somebody said "Skip Animal Kingdom - it's just a zoo..." How can you make that broad of an assumption about an entire park...oh and I'd also bet this person hasn't been to Disney in 5+ years...
  • Of course I also enjoy the conflicting advice that comes back to back: Don't do table service, you have to do table service; Get the dining plan, the dining plan is a waste; You have to do Chef Mickey's, Chef Mickey's will literally kill you; and so on...
I told my coworker that anybody who isn't asking you questions is not helping you. There are no right or wrong answers, there are options, and some of these options have benefits but also have consequences. I'd say that it's the same thing in churning. So I shared that same comment with my new reddit friend. I said you don't have to listen to me but just know that IF somebody giving you advice IS NOT asking lots of questions - they likely ARE NOT giving you good advice. Personalized and customized advice can ONLY come through asking questions and not making assumptions that somebody is exactly like you. You can even see that here where the easy go-to advice is CIP - and yes CIP is a great card and easily the most lucrative bonus in almost all cases BUT it is possible that given somebody's specific scenario and timing that another card could be the answer!
 
You can even see that here where the easy go-to advice is CIP - and yes CIP is a great card and easily the most lucrative bonus in almost all cases BUT it is possible that given somebody's specific scenario and timing that another card could be the answer!

Good for you!

And just want to 'amen' your last bit here. The CIP is such a great card to start with and for many, it is absolutely the best choice but there are definitely exceptions where other cards make more sense. Suggesting a CIP to every single person who asks for churning how-to advice is irresponsible and potentially setting them up for a churning fail. It's entirely possible there is a better path depending on their travel goals.
 
So I shared the other day about that terrible blog page that was all about "free travel to Disney" that popped up on a random r/churning comment. So cool update on that story:

I reached out to that reddit user and shared a few comments in a PM about why they might want to do a little more research. They shared with me that they just had a newborn (2nd child) the day prior. Apparently they were passing time in the hospital planning a potential Disney trip a year or so from now. This sparked me to ask some more questions and now we're in a full-fledged discussion about planning their Disney World trip. I'm covering both the "Disney" piece of planning AND the "Points" piece. Instead of offering just 2 Marriott hotel options, I'm actually allowing them to give me some detail on their preferences and provide actual customized advice. AND instead of being blindly led by affiliate links (a sort of support link available to bloggers) I'm providing advice completely irregardless of "what's in it for me".

This coming on the tails of helping a co-worker IRL with some initial Disney planning (i.e. park days, dining, etc.) for a trip later this year they are taking. I had noticed they were getting some downright TERRIBLE advice on Facebook (no surprise there!).

I said something to that coworker that also resonates with my recent reddit interaction... IF somebody giving you advice IS NOT asking lots of questions - they likely ARE NOT giving you good advice. It drives me crazy when people assume there is a right way to do Disney or a right way to churn, etc. Some funny observations:
  • I literally saw somebody give my coworker the advice "You have to do evening EMH - they are a must". My coworker has 2 children under the age of 6 who get up at 6am every morning and go to bed at 8pm. Did anybody think to ask about that...NO, because their way is the only way and must be the right way.
  • I saw another comment where somebody said "Skip Animal Kingdom - it's just a zoo..." How can you make that broad of an assumption about an entire park...oh and I'd also bet this person hasn't been to Disney in 5+ years...
  • Of course I also enjoy the conflicting advice that comes back to back: Don't do table service, you have to do table service; Get the dining plan, the dining plan is a waste; You have to do Chef Mickey's, Chef Mickey's will literally kill you; and so on...
I told my coworker that anybody who isn't asking you questions is not helping you. There are no right or wrong answers, there are options, and some of these options have benefits but also have consequences. I'd say that it's the same thing in churning. So I shared that same comment with my new reddit friend. I said you don't have to listen to me but just know that IF somebody giving you advice IS NOT asking lots of questions - they likely ARE NOT giving you good advice. Personalized and customized advice can ONLY come through asking questions and not making assumptions that somebody is exactly like you. You can even see that here where the easy go-to advice is CIP - and yes CIP is a great card and easily the most lucrative bonus in almost all cases BUT it is possible that given somebody's specific scenario and timing that another card could be the answer!

If one of my fb friends posts a status asking for wdw help I just point them to wdw prep school and am done with it. I have a friend that's a TA as a side gig, been doing it less time than I've been here on the dis and DL is her home resort. Last year before my trip she asked me what fp's I was getting because we were talking the day before. I told her and she's trying to tell me what I need to do. Umm...no I don't because I won't get fop on day 2 of my trip, my friend has been on it and is fine if we only do navi river. Yes I know about SDD and mine train etc. She was up here on a business trip last month and we met up and it happened to be the day the new ap and summer rates dropped. I'd already rebooked everything but let her think I was still under the group rate. Though she does know I already have a TA. But I would never have a friend do my trip for me regardless anyway, especially her since it's clear she thinks she knows it all and wouldn't take into account how I park tour. Oh and I also totally judged her credit card choices when we were together too. One was ok but the other meh, especially for someone with more than one side hustle that travels a ton consulting/teaching for her job. Now maybe the ok one was work issued and if that's the case it's even worse. But she seems to be more about being the top sales in her side hustles to get the free trips. :confused3
 
Good for you!

And just want to 'amen' your last bit here. The CIP is such a great card to start with and for many, it is absolutely the best choice but there are definitely exceptions where other cards make more sense. Suggesting a CIP to every single person who asks for churning how-to advice is irresponsible and potentially setting them up for a churning fail. It's entirely possible there is a better path depending on their travel goals.
I can’t recall who it was but we had that recently happen here on the thread where somebody new to the game needed Delta miles and the offers were at an all time high. A Delta biz card was the no brainer right answer for that person. CIP will still be there tomorrow but those Delta offers were about to go away. And of course, that advice came out of asking some questions and digging deeper. :)

So to all who are lurking, speak up and come out of lurkdom sometimes :) Don’t act on other people’s advice, we can give you your own customized advice. :thumbsup2
 
If one of my fb friends posts a status asking for wdw help I just point them to wdw prep school and am done with it. I have a friend that's a TA as a side gig, been doing it less time than I've been here on the dis and DL is her home resort. Last year before my trip she asked me what fp's I was getting because we were talking the day before. I told her and she's trying to tell me what I need to do. Umm...no I don't because I won't get fop on day 2 of my trip, my friend has been on it and is fine if we only do navi river. Yes I know about SDD and mine train etc. She was up here on a business trip last month and we met up and it happened to be the day the new ap and summer rates dropped. I'd already rebooked everything but let her think I was still under the group rate. Though she does know I already have a TA. But I would never have a friend do my trip for me regardless anyway, especially her since it's clear she thinks she knows it all and wouldn't take into account how I park tour. Oh and I also totally judged her credit card choices when we were together too. One was ok but the other meh, especially for someone with more than one side hustle that travels a ton consulting/teaching for her job. Now maybe the ok one was work issued and if that's the case it's even worse. But she seems to be more about being the top sales in her side hustles to get the free trips. :confused3
I've been working a side gig as a TA for about 9 mos. I planned many friend's trips for years before taking this on. I still do some friend's trips (but now as their TA) and some stranger's trips. The thing is I treat my client's trips like they are my own. If they are not interested in a package (and I'm not into 'upsells' which the Disney training highly encourages), I will go buy their tickets from whatever place has the best deal using their cc. Nothing whatsoever in it for me but again, it's how I would do my own trip. I encourage them to, at minimum, buy GC's from target at 5% off and then I will pay towards their trips with those. If they are not interested, I immediately drop it.

If they want me to book their FP's, I will, and I get up at 5am my time to do so. Regular agencies will only book you during business hours. Again, it's all about treating their trip like it's my own. I'd honestly love to have me be my TA lol! I also prepare touring plans for those who want them. Having said all that, I'm always careful to ask how the clients wants to tour, how early to start their park days, bedtimes for kids that they'd like to stick to when younger kiddos are there, etc. I never assume or push my (commando) version of touring on anyone.
 
Hi! I'm new here. I've been enjoying the thread. In the next year or two, I am interested in a family trip to Europe as inexpensively as possible! I just don't know where to start. Which are the best cards to start with?? I have a few active cards but only one opened in the last 24 months.
01/19 Capital One Venture
We normally put $1500-2000/month on CCs. We pay them off every month.
Does anyone have any words of wisdom for this newbie?:flower3:

Welcome! I'm not the right person to advise you on cards, but I do have a few questions. Are you looking to book air on points? And if so, economy or business or first? And for how many people? Or are you looking for free hotel nights? Or both?

Knowing this will help people here advise you on which cards to get, which points to chase, etc. Depending on what you are looking for and how many points you need can determine which cards are the ones to get.

im not sure what city your in but i know only 2 airlines fly direct to NZ. United and Air NZ.
Air NZ are notoriously hard to find awardspace, your alternate would be to stop somewhere in asia before flying down south, ie Japan, Taiwan, etc.

Albort, do you have any idea whether or not it's easier to get flights to SYD instead of AUK? I've sort of given up since I keep hearing it's super had to get lie flat seats to NZ, but if SYD isn't impossible I think I could make it work. Honestly I struggle with this one since my one trip there was almost 6 weeks and there's no way DH can be gone from work for that long in one stretch (even if he has the vacation days). It would have to be a shortened version I guess.
 
Albort, do you have any idea whether or not it's easier to get flights to SYD instead of AUK? I've sort of given up since I keep hearing it's super had to get lie flat seats to NZ, but if SYD isn't impossible I think I could make it work. Honestly I struggle with this one since my one trip there was almost 6 weeks and there's no way DH can be gone from work for that long in one stretch (even if he has the vacation days). It would have to be a shortened version I guess.

havent really looked... haha. its always possible imo.
 
OK, wow you are all amazing. I figure I should jump in and get advice....

Hopefully I do this right.

I have only one credit card applied for/approved in the last 24 months:

09/18 - Capital One Quicksilver (opened solely for the "no foreign transaction fees" benefit- it's sitting at a zero balance right now because I am irate with Capital One's apparent inability to process my payments in a timely manner.)

My "regular" card that I've had for years is a Chase Freedom (since 2011). No other cards at this time.

I am specifically looking at planning a trip to Japan in either late 2020 or 2021, which is why miles/hotel are of interest to me; however, I would PREFER to fly Japan Airlines so I am not sure how much that will limit me. (My typical "travel" consists of driving to Southern California; sometimes this results in a hotel stay and sometimes not, depending on whether we stay with friends.)

  • I typically spend between $1500-$2500 a month on the Chase Freedom (non-Target groceries (I use the Red Card at Target and do most of my shopping there), Amazon, fuel; internet bill; pest control; inconsistent hotel stays; fast food; restaurants).
  • I pay it off in full every month
  • I don't fly much but if I did it would be out of PHX
  • No preference on a frequent flyer program (I have Southwest and possibly still Alaska... maybe)
  • Yes, Southwest flies here and would get me as far as LAX for that trip to Japan
  • I am so-called "Diamond" status with Best Western but for Japan I would definitely look at Hilton (have an unused account with Hilton)
  • No travel points at this time.
  • My specific goal would be the Japan trip but I would also like to visit WDW some day
  • Japan would be just me and my husband. Not sure about WDW yet.
Thanks for any advice!
 
For those considering New Zealand/Australia trips:

We traveled there last summer for a month. We spent 3 weeks in New Zealand and 10 days in Australia.

I would highly, highly recommend New Zealand over Australia. Nothing in particular against Australia, but it just felt a lot like America/Europe, especially against New Zealand. I’d recommend NZ over anywhere I’ve been - Israel, Egypt, Europe - it’s breathtaking.

I’d be happy to give recommendations/a run-through of our trip if anyone would be interested.

We booked (very) last minute (less than a month before), so we didn’t book with points (well, we used our URs at 1.5x). We stayed in Airbnbs the whole trip, as that allowed us a lot more flexibility in where we traveled to.

If we ever go back (which I’d love to do), there is no way I’m enduring that plane ride in economy. We had bulkhead seats and I was still miserable (alas, the pains of paying with “cash”). I’d definitely recommend you find a way to fly there in style - preferably, Plane Princess style! (@calypso726)
I’ve always wanted to go to New Zealand. It looks so pretty!
 
Oh man - people on that news thread would FREAK OUT about how off topic we get here. I understand in one respect why they handle that thread the way they do. BUT the fact that we fly off topic is what makes this a community. Knowing that @Haley R is now in Japan, her husband just got a new job in Florida, they have cats, they played in a band, she recently rekindled her love of volleyball, etc. is what makes this place great! (Ok...so apparently I know A LOT about @Haley R and nothing about the rest of you...)

Well wait, that's a lie... @amalone1013 has a husband who used to drive a creeper van! So I know something else at least :P

Now @Lain - that dude be crazy with the spreadsheet. If you broke a law in your college years he knows about it...he knows things about me that I don't even know about myself!!! At any rate...our thread is the best...that is all.
Lol I feel honored that you’ve paid that much attention to me :lovestruc It’s probably because most of it is so recent
 
OK, wow you are all amazing. I figure I should jump in and get advice....

Hopefully I do this right.

I have only one credit card applied for/approved in the last 24 months:

09/18 - Capital One Quicksilver (opened solely for the "no foreign transaction fees" benefit- it's sitting at a zero balance right now because I am irate with Capital One's apparent inability to process my payments in a timely manner.)

My "regular" card that I've had for years is a Chase Freedom (since 2011). No other cards at this time.

I am specifically looking at planning a trip to Japan in either late 2020 or 2021, which is why miles/hotel are of interest to me; however, I would PREFER to fly Japan Airlines so I am not sure how much that will limit me. (My typical "travel" consists of driving to Southern California; sometimes this results in a hotel stay and sometimes not, depending on whether we stay with friends.)

  • I typically spend between $1500-$2500 a month on the Chase Freedom (non-Target groceries (I use the Red Card at Target and do most of my shopping there), Amazon, fuel; internet bill; pest control; inconsistent hotel stays; fast food; restaurants).
  • I pay it off in full every month
  • I don't fly much but if I did it would be out of PHX
  • No preference on a frequent flyer program (I have Southwest and possibly still Alaska... maybe)
  • Yes, Southwest flies here and would get me as far as LAX for that trip to Japan
  • I am so-called "Diamond" status with Best Western but for Japan I would definitely look at Hilton (have an unused account with Hilton)
  • No travel points at this time.
  • My specific goal would be the Japan trip but I would also like to visit WDW some day
  • Japan would be just me and my husband. Not sure about WDW yet.
Thanks for any advice!

You’re in luck, because several of us are planning Japan trips in 2020 and 2021. This thread helped @Haley R, who is in Japan right now, accumulate enough points for business class flights on ANA from LAX to Tokyo and a stay at the Hilton Tokyo Bay for her visit to Tokyo Disneyland within a few months time starting just over a year ago.

However, the game is constantly changing, what cards and bonuses available today may not be tomorrow, everyone earns points at different rates, and the availability of certain redemptions may go up in price. For your best shot at getting the flights and hotels you want, we usually suggest having your points in place a year before your travel dates. For late 2020 or 2021, you’re in good shape. But if you’re eyeing sakura season in late March through early April, know that’s the most popular time for travel to Japan and that may make finding award space on flights and hotels more challenging.

• How many people will be in your travel party?

• What parts of Japan are you planning to visit?

• Do you have a spouse or some other partner who is willing to sign up for credit cards and work on bonuses too?

• Do you have a business or any side gigs (e.g., selling stuff online, selling crafts or baked goods, babysitting, pet sitting or dog walking, tutoring, consulting, independent contracting, driving for a ride share, etc.) that might qualify you for a business credit card? If not, did you have one in the past or could you say you have any plans to start one?

• Would you and any partner be willing to open up business credit cards?

• Would you be interested in joining DISchurners, our private Reddit group, where we share more in depth tips, links to credit card offers, and recap the news and discussion to help you keep up with this fast moving thread?

To open up your options, you may need to take a positioning flight from PHX to LAX, but it sounds like you’re ok with that.

There are lots of points “currencies” (or programs) you can work on to earn miles for your trip. Two of the big ones with lots of points on the table for you to earn are Chase’s Ultimate Rewards (“UR”) and Amex’s Membership Rewards (“MR”). Both are flexible points currencies that can be cashed out, redeemed for travel on their respective travel portals, and most importantly in your case transferred points to points/miles to various other airline and hotel travel partners. Chase URs transfer to United (UA), which flies from LAX to NRT/HND, and Virgin Atlantic (VS), which you can use to book partner awards on ANA that’ll take you to Tokyo. With United’s recent announcement that they’re moving to dynamic award pricing later this year, the VS -> ANA route is a better value in that it’ll require you to earn and spend fewer points. @Haley R actually focused on earning oodles of UR, transferred them to VS to book her business class flights on ANA. Amex’s Membership Rewards similarly transfers to Virgin Atlantic, which you can use to book partner awards on ANA, and there’s a transfer bonus going on through 7/1/19, which means for every 1,000 points you transfer from MR, you’ll get 1,300 miles with VS (instead of the usual 1,000). Unfortunately, you may not be able to take advantage of this transfer bonus given the short time frame, but these bonuses come around periodically. Amex MR also transfers to ANA directly, and as I mentioned before it is a good value in itself. You did mention you’d like to fly JAL. Neither Chase nor Amex transfer to JAL, but an alternative is to earn American Airline (AA) miles to redeem for partner awards with JAL. @DisneyMandC is doing this for her flights to Tokyo for next year’s Summer Olympics.

As you can see, you have a lot of options. But where to start? If you saw my post from last night about developing a strategy early on, then you need to play your cards very carefully. You said you’re 1/24 with a Cap1 card. You’ve got 4 slots to play with. If you’re open to business cards, you can get much more than 4 cards and still be in the game with Chase. As you might have read, Chase has some of the most lucrative signup bonuses (SUBs) with their Ultimate Rewards earning cards. But they also have one of the most stringent rules to prevent people from getting their cards if they’ve gotten too many other cards from them or other issuers. That’s the “5/24 rule” — Chase will deny you for any of their cards if they see from your credit report that you’ve gotten 5 or more cards from any issuer in the past 24 months. However, if you’re willing to sign up for business cards, the good news is most issuers don’t report business cards to your personal credit report so Chase doesn’t see them on your credit report and won’t add the business cards against your */24 count. This gives you a lot of room to play your cards right! Chase’s 5/24 rule is why we suggest prioritizing Chase’s cards first, while you’re still under 5/24, because going willy nilly and getting personal cards from other issuers (e.g., Amex, Citi, Barclays, BofA, Cap1) will blow your */24 status in no time and lock you out of Chase for at least two years. (You can still, generally, get business cards from other issuers, as long as they don’t report their business cards to your personal credit report. And we can tell you which ones are safe.) It’s important to consider both the short and long term in developing a strategy because this Japan trip hopefully won’t be your last travel hack; you said you’d like to go to WDW too. Points can take you there and elsewhere for significantly reduced out of pocket costs.

You already have the Chase Freedom (“CF”) which is a good start. Are you maximizing the 5% category this quarter by activating the category and using the CF at grocery and home improvement stores? The CF actually earns its cash back in the form of UR points that can be cashed out. So you may already have UR points that you don’t even know about. However, a better use for them would be to get one of Chase’s more premium travel cards, like the Chase Sapphire Reserve (“CSR”), Chase Sapphire Preferred (“CSP”), and the Chase Ink Preferred (“CIP”) so you have the ability to combine your URs from spending and SUBs and transfer them to one of Chase’s travel partners, like Virgin Atlantic.

Another Chase travel partner that should be on your radar is Hyatt, which has several ah-mazing properties in Tokyo and often is an incredible value when you transfer UR -> World of Hyatt points. Just for example, during sakura season, when you’ll see some peak cash pricing, the Andaz Tokyo Toranomon Hills runs ~$650/night and the Park Hyatt Tokyo, made famous by Lost In Translation, runs ~$900/night, but both are bookable for “only” 30,000 Hyatt points per night (and that’s for Hyatt’s high end categories; lower tier properties will cost less). UR points transfer to Hyatt 1:1, so that’s 30,000 UR, or only $300 if you had cashed out the UR for cash. Chase also has a Hyatt credit card that can earn you (currently) a 50,000 Hyatt points SUB and hotel loyalty status (but again, you need to be under 5/24 to be eligible).

I know some of these numbers may not make much sense to you right now, and I’ve tried not to overwhelm you with too many numbers right off the bat. But just look at the SUBs for some of Chase’s cards: the CSR has a 50,000 UR SUB; the CSP has a 60,000 UR SUB; the CIP has an 80,000 UR SUB; two other Chase business cards, the Chase Ink Cash (“CIC”) and the Chase Ink Unlimited (“CIU”) each have 50,000 UR SUBs. You can run up a lot of points by getting all of these cards! But keep in mind there are rules to applying for these cards, but if you’re willing to listen and learn, we can walk you through how to get all of them, maybe even more than once, while you’re still under 5/24. And if you get a partner involved, you two can double up on these cards, and refer each other for more “support” bonuses, then combine your URs to make some big redemptions.

I’ll leave it here for now. Get back to me with answers to some of my questions and we can better help you. And please please please “watch” this thread, ask a lot of questions and we’ll answer the best we can, stay involved and just chat with us so we can learn a little more about you and we can better tailor our advice, use us as a sounding board for your plans, read and learn from other people’s posts whether they’re about Japan or addressed directly to you or not.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top