See, this whole recovery deal is somewhat frustrating. Since we chose to not cancel our AP's, we are now forced to choose between renewal in May despite no trips planned again until December, or potentially giving up access to AP's for an unknown period of time. However, someone who chose to cancel for a refund, is now able to purchase a new AP and sit on it for years if they so choose, meaning they have guaranteed access to an AP, when they are ready to start travel again, with a full year attached. Personally I feel the ability to buy another pass at any time should be available to all passholders who were active during the shutdown, not just those who chose to cash out. I would rather spend extra for new vouchers that I can choose the start date, rather than save the money on renewal, but since we held onto our passes we don't get that option. Seems an odd way to treat "loyal passholders."
ETA: Nothing against people who chose to cancel for the refund - everyone has to do what is right/best for them in these situations. I just find it upsetting that Disney doesn't offer the same offer to those who chose not to cancel.