My parents and I hated this program. You got a certain list of books, all with a set number of points you can earn. I would go to my library, after reasearching and finding a book I was *really* interested in, and then find it's not on the list.

You'd have to read the book in addition to your AR books. And earning points was annoying. You have to figure out what books will get you where you need to be, point-wise, and if you answer a couple incorrect questions, you have to get another book (and let me tell you, beware on some of the questions. They can be about itty-bitty details that you normally wouldn't remember, yet you had still REALLY read the book). I was glad this was ditched by the time I was in middle school. I could finally read the books I was interested in. But by then, I hated reading. AR made me loathe the "chore" called reading. Still, to this day, this once active reader can't get herself into reading thanks to AR.
And that was all 5 years ago.
I miss what my old elementary school did (before I moved, to a school with AR). We just kept track with the number of pages read, and award kids on reading more.
I still shudder though, being in 5th grade and suffering through Johnny Tremain just to get 16 points.
