MikeandReneePlus5
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2010
- Messages
- 2,136
I don't think Disney has gone downhill the last few years.
Never said the thread represented any portion of Disney visitors. I didn't even call it ironic. It's an observation.
Nice job diminishing the comments of those 25 people, however. I didn't realize people needed a public mandate to discuss these things.![]()
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?
![]()
DING DING DING DING!!! That is true of most any public forum. Those being negative will come back again and again to argue. Those not being negative will make their point and move on.
Well, yeah ... there is that.Yes. Because people on both sides of any debate on the Dis are so well known for calling it quits.
Never said the thread represented any portion of Disney visitors. I didn't even call it ironic. It's an observation.
Nice job diminishing the comments of those 25 people, however. I didn't realize people needed a public mandate to discuss these things.![]()
Of course it's still relevant. It will always be relevant. Disney could fix every single thing you want them to fix, from the CEO on down, and there would still be a relevant complaint thread. Because even if all YOUR complaints were taken care of, that doesn't mean EVERYONE'S complaints would have been taken care of. You'd be thinking Disney was 100%, but someone else would be grousing about something you didn't even think was broken. There will always be a Disney complaint thread because everyone has different expectations.You know the funny thing is this thread stays relevant because of alot of bad decisions by management lately,IMO.I do enjoy chatting with alot of the poster on this thread,but disney management I think has been the real catalyst in this thread.It is just like the prediction about the monorail threads to.Someone said they would go away as people got used to the new hours,still ain't gone yet and won't be until that situation changes!
Just forgot to add that I never intended to diminish the views of the Top 25. I even specifically defended the views of the top poster in this thread. Plus, a handful of the remaining Top 25 seem to post here just to keep the debate honest.
I think until the last few days, WDSearcher was correct. This had turned more into a conversational thread vs a debate thread. Not sure why you had to bring up the uphill thread other than toYet, if anyone disagrees.....
Of course it's still relevant. It will always be relevant. Disney could fix every single thing you want them to fix, from the CEO on down, and there would still be a relevant complaint thread. Because even if all YOUR complaints were taken care of, that doesn't mean EVERYONE'S complaints would have been taken care of. You'd be thinking Disney was 100%, but someone else would be grousing about something you didn't even think was broken. There will always be a Disney complaint thread because everyone has different expectations.
As for the monorail threads ... I think they will go away as people get used to the new operating pattern. But it'll take longer than a few weeks -- which is really all it's been. Any major change takes a while to cycle through. People complained for months about PI closing, about LOW going away, about no more appetizers or tips on FD, etc etc etc. Eventually, whatever changed becomes part of the "new normal" and the specific complaint threads move to the back of the pack. And the people who remain end up in more generalized complaint threads like this one.
This thread is also still here because you're not just complaining. You're discussing ways that Disney has slipped, sure, but you're also discussing things you still like about the parks. You're chatting about methodology of how certain facts or stats were arrived at. You're complimenting each other on finding good deals and offering suggestions on how to get better ones. There's more going on than just the complaints, which is why it stays interesting to both the people posting regularly and the people stopping by from time to time to see what's being discussed.
If this thread were all complaints all the time, it would have gotten tiresome for everyone and ended a long time ago, don't you think?
![]()
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?
![]()
DING DING DING DING!!! That is true of most any public forum. Those being negative will come back again and again to argue. Those not being negative will make their point and move on.
Are you both serious? Just because we are still discussing, does not mean we are being negative and can't move on. On the contrary, if there are still things to discuss, why not continue to discuss them in a friendly and informative manner? I am very far from a negative person, but I love to discuss, especially when it's about Disney.
And sorry, people move on because they get easily bored and move on to other things.Many people on the DIS seem to have short attention spans, as so many of them don't even read through the thread before posting in it.
Thanks for the discussion, Tiger![]()
Constructive criticism is an important part of the experience and I always learn more from the negative experiences than the positive ones. That's why I value these threads.
I look on them the way I do a restaurant review on the restaurants board. Some match my experience, others don't -- but they all help inform my own expectations as well as alert me to things I should watch for.
This may come as a shock, but I actually agree with this post. Personally, I am with you in that I would not pay the prices asked, but yet these resorts still get quite a few bookings each night.When I tried to add a night on to our BLT stay last June, many of the lower categories of the Delxue resorts were sold out. Sure, I could still get a room with a water or theme park view or even CL, but if I was hesitant to pay $300, I was definitely not going to pay $500+. We ended up off-site at the Vistana for a couple of nights. Even the family suites (which are horrible IMO compared to DVC) often go for more than $200 per night and they are harder to find discounts.
I have read many posts from those who say that FD is the only way they can afford Disney. They stay in the Values during value season with FD. They claim that there is no off-site resort that is less expensive unless you pack your own food. Not sure how valid their claims are as we never do FD as we generally cannot go during those times of year.
The top 25 posters on this thread have generated over 72% of the posts. The DIS is such a tiny fraction of those who visit WDW and to say that a miniscule 25 people keeping a thread alive by debating this topic is representative of the larger population is unrealistic.
Plus, I'm not sure how ironic it really is. The only way to keep a thread alive is to have those who want to debate or if there is a true disagreement. That is why negative threads stay alive and positive threads die quickly IMHO.
At least Brunette adds that Disney has done many positive things over the years in addition to the cutbacks and price increases. I respect that and wish more posters were like her. We can respectfully disagree on whether the positives outweigh the negatives or vice versa. These threads are mildly entertaining, but I doubt if they change too many minds. JMTC
When Brunette first posted this thread, some angry Diser made a competing "Do you think Disney has gone UP HILL" thread to "fight the negativity."
It's funny how that thread vanished... and this one is still going strong.
Nytimez:
I believe I have your context clearly in my mind, so I'm going to go with it. I have been a contributor on this thread and sworn off it some months ago... yet, I still return.
Why?
Maybe because I am so in it for Disney. Maybe because I could live there and practically do. Yet, I am disappointed frequently by many things.
Starting off with this thread, and how it has gone so long...
Somewhere in my own mind, I am hoping that folks at Disney read through some of this stuff and see areas where improvement is needed. Or, where things have "slipped" a bit. A thread like this, can serve to expose areas where Disney fails or has allowed their image to tarnish.
As a continuous Disney customer, allow me to say that I am not so much inhibited by the rising costs. Not at all. It is the combined lack of value and rising cost that draws my ire.
As an example:
I could get a steak at Ponderosa for less than $16.00. Yet, at Ruth's Chris, I couldn't get an appetizer for that cost! Yet, I would take Ruth's Chris over Ponderosa any day. Why? Quality.
Plain and simple.
We could go to Angel's Seafood Buffet on 192 and have at it for under $15.00 or, we could go to BOMA for about $38.00. I'll take BOMA any day but that decisiveness has lengthened over the last few years.
I don't mind paying more for a great thing. I tip well when I am treated well and I will pay a big price for a great meal. Period.
If Disney was sticking to simply raising prices, I wouldn't have one single issue as the "Disney Experience" is phenomenal.
But, there is a caveat. BOMA no longer serves smoked Prime Rib. They have a (very good) Sirloin Roast. While it is very tasty, it is not the Prime Rib they used to have. I would rather they had raised the price than to reduce the quality of what they served.
This is simply one example of what is taking place all over Disney.
It is still an experience for all. And for one timers, it probably has all the magic promised. But as stated so many times before, us long timers have come to realize, that things have changed and corners have been cut.
It isn't the same.
Yet, it's still "awesome". Even after thousands of trips there, we still love going.
We don't mind paying more for the experience. What we do mind, is that we're used to Ruth's Chris and now all we can expect sometimes, is McDonald's. Ironically, you won't find a McDonald's fry anywhere on site as even that has changed.
For better? For worse? I don't know.
What I do know, is I miss the Skyway to Tomorrowland. I miss the lunch buffet at Ft. Wilderness. I miss the exceptional food at O'Hana, not to mention the hot towels. And most of all, I miss riding in the front of the monorail.
Through it all is one mouse and "One Man's Dream". My biggest lament, is that WED and his legacy is taking a back seat to profit.
Then again, maybe I'm a hypocrite. As I will once again up my AP and continue to stay on property. Which makes me believe, that my own personal dream, would be to have Disney remain the standard of quality and family experience that can be offered anywhere.
They don't have to build a new Fantasyland Addition for that. All they have to do, is remember what got them there to begin with.
That's what Walt wanted. If it costs more, so be it. Then charge more. But at the end of the day, people want to be absorbed in the magic of Disney and they should receive nothing less than an exceptional performance by all involved.
Off my soapbox now.....
*
This! Nice post Tiger, I think most people feel the same way!!!![]()
Nytimez:
I believe I have your context clearly in my mind, so I'm going to go with it. I have been a contributor on this thread and sworn off it some months ago... yet, I still return.
Why?
Maybe because I am so in it for Disney. Maybe because I could live there and practically do. Yet, I am disappointed frequently by many things.
Starting off with this thread, and how it has gone so long...
Somewhere in my own mind, I am hoping that folks at Disney read through some of this stuff and see areas where improvement is needed. Or, where things have "slipped" a bit. A thread like this, can serve to expose areas where Disney fails or has allowed their image to tarnish.
As a continuous Disney customer, allow me to say that I am not so much inhibited by the rising costs. Not at all. It is the combined lack of value and rising cost that draws my ire.
As an example:
I could get a steak at Ponderosa for less than $16.00. Yet, at Ruth's Chris, I couldn't get an appetizer for that cost! Yet, I would take Ruth's Chris over Ponderosa any day. Why? Quality.
Plain and simple.
We could go to Angel's Seafood Buffet on 192 and have at it for under $15.00 or, we could go to BOMA for about $38.00. I'll take BOMA any day but that decisiveness has lengthened over the last few years.
I don't mind paying more for a great thing. I tip well when I am treated well and I will pay a big price for a great meal. Period.
If Disney was sticking to simply raising prices, I wouldn't have one single issue as the "Disney Experience" is phenomenal.
But, there is a caveat. BOMA no longer serves smoked Prime Rib. They have a (very good) Sirloin Roast. While it is very tasty, it is not the Prime Rib they used to have. I would rather they had raised the price than to reduce the quality of what they served.
This is simply one example of what is taking place all over Disney.
It is still an experience for all. And for one timers, it probably has all the magic promised. But as stated so many times before, us long timers have come to realize, that things have changed and corners have been cut.
It isn't the same.
Yet, it's still "awesome". Even after thousands of trips there, we still love going.
We don't mind paying more for the experience. What we do mind, is that we're used to Ruth's Chris and now all we can expect sometimes, is McDonald's. Ironically, you won't find a McDonald's fry anywhere on site as even that has changed.
For better? For worse? I don't know.
What I do know, is I miss the Skyway to Tomorrowland. I miss the lunch buffet at Ft. Wilderness. I miss the exceptional food at O'Hana, not to mention the hot towels. And most of all, I miss riding in the front of the monorail.
Through it all is one mouse and "One Man's Dream". My biggest lament, is that WED and his legacy is taking a back seat to profit.
Then again, maybe I'm a hypocrite. As I will once again up my AP and continue to stay on property. Which makes me believe, that my own personal dream, would be to have Disney remain the standard of quality and family experience that can be offered anywhere.
They don't have to build a new Fantasyland Addition for that. All they have to do, is remember what got them there to begin with.
That's what Walt wanted. If it costs more, so be it. Then charge more. But at the end of the day, people want to be absorbed in the magic of Disney and they should receive nothing less than an exceptional performance by all involved.
Off my soapbox now.....
No -- by all means, stay on that soap box.
This sums up how I feel so perfectly it feels like your broke inside my head and stole it. The only evidence you didn't is that you wrote it out far better than I ever have.
Agreeing with absolutely everything you've said, I feel like there have been some minor and *possibly* hopeful signs for the future. The Avatar commitment, regardless of how you feel about Avatar, shows a new willingness to spend big in the Florida and shoot for the moon instead of taking the cheap/easy/safe route. The $10 no-show fee for dining shows a small recognition of the problem they created with the dining plan/free dining - namely, folks like us who go all the time and aren't inclined to do either free dining or the dining plan are now having a hard time getting reservations. The long-term closure of BTMM, while overdue, shows they're actually -- hopefully -- going to restore the ride to its glory. And the slow-but-steady queue improvements show a trend toward improving the least pleasant part of the park experience: the wait.
Promise me I won't have to book ride times 180 days out and I may start being a little optimistic about things.
Might.
The merch still stinks, food quality is still not even close to what it was (and menu options remain more limited) and there's still an overall sense of paying more and getting less. But so far, I keep going back just the same... and have had such an enjoyable experience at Universal in recent years that I may start alternating instead of hitting Disney every time and Universal some of the time.
Now, I'll relinquish the soapbox.
A pleasant good evening to you miss brunette! Not talked to you in a while hope everything in your world is good.See all the trouble you started on here with this thread!LOLFLICX
Nytimez:
I believe I have your context clearly in my mind, so I'm going to go with it. I have been a contributor on this thread and sworn off it some months ago... yet, I still return.
Why?
Maybe because I am so in it for Disney. Maybe because I could live there and practically do. Yet, I am disappointed frequently by many things.
Starting off with this thread, and how it has gone so long...
Somewhere in my own mind, I am hoping that folks at Disney read through some of this stuff and see areas where improvement is needed. Or, where things have "slipped" a bit. A thread like this, can serve to expose areas where Disney fails or has allowed their image to tarnish.
As a continuous Disney customer, allow me to say that I am not so much inhibited by the rising costs. Not at all. It is the combined lack of value and rising cost that draws my ire.
As an example:
I could get a steak at Ponderosa for less than $16.00. Yet, at Ruth's Chris, I couldn't get an appetizer for that cost! Yet, I would take Ruth's Chris over Ponderosa any day. Why? Quality.
Plain and simple.
We could go to Angel's Seafood Buffet on 192 and have at it for under $15.00 or, we could go to BOMA for about $38.00. I'll take BOMA any day but that decisiveness has lengthened over the last few years.
I don't mind paying more for a great thing. I tip well when I am treated well and I will pay a big price for a great meal. Period.
If Disney was sticking to simply raising prices, I wouldn't have one single issue as the "Disney Experience" is phenomenal.
But, there is a caveat. BOMA no longer serves smoked Prime Rib. They have a (very good) Sirloin Roast. While it is very tasty, it is not the Prime Rib they used to have. I would rather they had raised the price than to reduce the quality of what they served.
This is simply one example of what is taking place all over Disney.
It is still an experience for all. And for one timers, it probably has all the magic promised. But as stated so many times before, us long timers have come to realize, that things have changed and corners have been cut.
It isn't the same.
Yet, it's still "awesome". Even after thousands of trips there, we still love going.
We don't mind paying more for the experience. What we do mind, is that we're used to Ruth's Chris and now all we can expect sometimes, is McDonald's. Ironically, you won't find a McDonald's fry anywhere on site as even that has changed.
For better? For worse? I don't know.
What I do know, is I miss the Skyway to Tomorrowland. I miss the lunch buffet at Ft. Wilderness. I miss the exceptional food at O'Hana, not to mention the hot towels. And most of all, I miss riding in the front of the monorail.
Through it all is one mouse and "One Man's Dream". My biggest lament, is that WED and his legacy is taking a back seat to profit.
Then again, maybe I'm a hypocrite. As I will once again up my AP and continue to stay on property. Which makes me believe, that my own personal dream, would be to have Disney remain the standard of quality and family experience that can be offered anywhere.
They don't have to build a new Fantasyland Addition for that. All they have to do, is remember what got them there to begin with.
That's what Walt wanted. If it costs more, so be it. Then charge more. But at the end of the day, people want to be absorbed in the magic of Disney and they should receive nothing less than an exceptional performance by all involved.
Off my soapbox now.....
No -- by all means, stay on that soap box.
This sums up how I feel so perfectly it feels like your broke inside my head and stole it. The only evidence you didn't is that you wrote it out far better than I ever have.
Agreeing with absolutely everything you've said, I feel like there have been some minor and *possibly* hopeful signs for the future. The Avatar commitment, regardless of how you feel about Avatar, shows a new willingness to spend big in the Florida and shoot for the moon instead of taking the cheap/easy/safe route. The $10 no-show fee for dining shows a small recognition of the problem they created with the dining plan/free dining - namely, folks like us who go all the time and aren't inclined to do either free dining or the dining plan are now having a hard time getting reservations. The long-term closure of BTMM, while overdue, shows they're actually -- hopefully -- going to restore the ride to its glory. And the slow-but-steady queue improvements show a trend toward improving the least pleasant part of the park experience: the wait.
Promise me I won't have to book ride times 180 days out and I may start being a little optimistic about things.
Might.
The merch still stinks, food quality is still not even close to what it was (and menu options remain more limited) and there's still an overall sense of paying more and getting less. But so far, I keep going back just the same... and have had such an enjoyable experience at Universal in recent years that I may start alternating instead of hitting Disney every time and Universal some of the time.
Now, I'll relinquish the soapbox.