Do You think DISNEY has gone down hlll the last few years?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry, I didn't say Disney was cheaper than Vegas in all cases, but of course that would depend on a lot of things, as for locals as Kelly pointed out, Disney would be cheaper. Granted, going to Atlantis Bahamas will be more than Disney (I've priced it out many times), and Vegas more than likely will be cheaper, but that depends upon where you live. But I still stand by my statement though that if you go to Disney during a low season when promos are in effect, it's reasonable compared to other family destinations. You are correct that Vegas is a lower priced destination, but the people I know who have gone have spent almost as much or more than Disney as they still had to pay for lodging, food, alcohol and entertainment, so in that respect, it could compare to Disney. We don't drink, so that isn't a big factor for us, so our Vegas cost was pretty reasonable.


Been to Vegas, and I totally disagree that rooms and food are free - that is only for high rollers who get comped. Granted they are pretty cheap prices, like right now, 2 adults could stay at one of the lower vegas hotels with air included for approx. $400-$450/person for 3 nights, plus fees, and that does not include food (this is from my city). I will agree that food is much cheaper and very good, but entertainment can be very costly (Cirque, singers, etc.).

Remember though, Vegas prices are supplemented by the casinos - gambling and alcohol basically pay for your cheaper rooms and buffets. I probably shouldn't have used Vegas as it I know people who have spent way more than Disney, and those who have spent less, as Vegas offers lots of choices.

Hope that clears it up, Tiger :)

Tiger if you aren't getting comped rooms or food in vegas you don't know how to use the promos.My wife and I are low rollers ,trust me we gamble no more than what a 3 day ticket to disney would cost for our 3 day stays.We get offers for free stays at MGM resorts frequently.If you join the casinos clubs on joint accounts you get alot of freebies.I have stayed at the luxor several times for three nights for free and various other properties too.It reminds me so much of the contemporary inside it is almost scary.The food out there is also cheap too.I mean you can eat fast food and pay what you pay normally everywhere.A place out there that sold 9.00 dollar hotdogs like disney does would go out of business in a hurry.I live in PA so vegas is alot further than disney and I can go on three or four vegas trips for the price of one disney trip.Funny you mention alcohol in your post,but if you are a drinker which by the way I am a casual one at best,drinks are free if you gamble in vegas! My last trip to vegas cost me 450 in air fare 0 for room and less than 50 bucks a day for food for three people.Thats 200 a person for three days food included.I can't get a comparable room alone for that price at disney anymore!
 
Wow! When did you get Grande Lakes for $99.00/night? I just checked for off-peak (first few days of Nov) and peak (July), and the nightly prices range from close to $300.00/night - $400.00 plus resort fee and taxes.

Surely less than Disney Deluxes, but pretty on par with the other Orlando Deluxe hotels.

We have stayed at pretty much all Disney Deluxes except for GF and BLT (but have stayed at Contemporary 2x), and I will agree that Disney's categorization of Deluxe is not the same as other hotels/resorts. But, I have also stayed in Deluxe Resorts in Hawaii, and they don't compare to Disney, nor other Deluxe Orlando hotels we've stayed at either.

It's good there is lots of competition in Orlando, as that is exactly why these other hotels have to slash their rates, whereas Disney does not necessarily need to do that.
Glad you had a great stay there - looks lovely!


Tiger :)

*
Hi! I wrote about this very subject on this thread back in the summer. They were offering Government/Military and AAA rates for $99.00 a day.

Personally, I "DO" think that Disney needs to either A. Cut their prices a bit, or B. Offer the buy 4 get 3 days free offer. As KELLYNY stated a lot of their hotels were wide open. I also think that is why they are offering Free Dining, to force people to fill their resort rooms. I think in this economy they are having problems filling rooms.

Brunette
 
*
Hi! I wrote about this very subject on this thread back in the summer. They were offering Government/Military and AAA rates for $99.00 a day.

Personally, I "DO" think that Disney needs to either A. Cut their prices a bit, or B. Offer the buy 4 get 3 days free offer. As KELLYNY stated a lot of their hotels were wide open. I also think that is why they are offering Free Dining, to force people to fill their resort rooms. I think in this economy they are having problems filling rooms.

Brunette

exactly, fd is nothing but a trick to get people to stay on property. I want to remind how, I think 2years ago, craziness with upgrades started, when people were sent emails that values were overbooked and offered moderates an dvc resorts just to free rooms. why, because people refused to pay more and while disney had enough rooms overall, they did not have enough affordable rooms.
i am regular august visitor and i never saw aruba builing, the one right across the bridge, the 1 of 2 most popular locations after preffered to be so empty. no i did not talk to anyone, but when you walk at 8am and see made beds when nobody cleaned yet, and again in afternoon and again at midnight , you know room is empty. i felt like i rented the whole floor,only few rooms had guests, the quietest stay ever, not a single running kid, that is not normal, esp.when parks are full. i bet all values were sold out as i could not get a single normal adr, it was fd time.
 
I can definitely say that Disney had empty rooms. I ended up booking only 3 weeks before our trip in early August since I kept trying to find a good deal for a few places. I really pushed it but there were plenty of options so I didn't worry too much. Even after I booked I kept on checking rooms including Disney just out of curiosity. I found that only a few deluxe resorts, one moderate (one of the Port Orleans places) and Pop Century were uniformly booked. I could definitely book a high priced deluxe or a moderate or the Allstars with no problem. Plus Disney had their signs stating "rooms available" out along the roads.

Tiger, you make a good point about there possibly not being enough to do onsite if Disney isn't careful. We love to go offsite even if we stay at an onsite resort but not everyone is like that plus I doubt that Disney wants that.
 
Tiger if you aren't getting comped rooms or food in vegas you don't know how to use the promos.My wife and I are low rollers ,trust me we gamble no more than what a 3 day ticket to disney would cost for our 3 day stays.We get offers for free stays at MGM resorts frequently.If you join the casinos clubs on joint accounts you get alot of freebies.I have stayed at the luxor several times for three nights for free and various other properties too.It reminds me so much of the contemporary inside it is almost scary.The food out there is also cheap too.I mean you can eat fast food and pay what you pay normally everywhere.A place out there that sold 9.00 dollar hotdogs like disney does would go out of business in a hurry.I live in PA so vegas is alot further than disney and I can go on three or four vegas trips for the price of one disney trip.Funny you mention alcohol in your post,but if you are a drinker which by the way I am a casual one at best,drinks are free if you gamble in vegas! My last trip to vegas cost me 450 in air fare 0 for room and less than 50 bucks a day for food for three people.Thats 200 a person for three days food included.I can't get a comparable room alone for that price at disney anymore!

Thanks for the info - there is nothing to get right about it. We don't gamble, so we went to Vegas to do the resorts, restaurants and shows, just like many people do with Disney. Since we don't gamble, we don't have access to the discounts that you mention. Like I said though, despite this, Vegas is still pretty reasonable everytime I see promos advertised.

Sounds like you are getting great deals, but again, the casinos are allowing you to have those great deals. They supplement the promos that Vegas gives out. Have watched several very good documentaries about the way Vegas works. The revenue that is generated from the casinos is astronomical and supplements all of the freebies, so that you keep coming back over and over again. I don't blame you for going back so often, if it's so cheap, but Disney will never be like that, nor do I want them to be.:thumbsup2

Again, I shouldn't have mentioned Vegas as I said in my last post, as it's a very different market there.

*
Hi! I wrote about this very subject on this thread back in the summer. They were offering Government/Military and AAA rates for $99.00 a day.

Personally, I "DO" think that Disney needs to either A. Cut their prices a bit, or B. Offer the buy 4 get 3 days free offer. As KELLYNY stated a lot of their hotels were wide open. I also think that is why they are offering Free Dining, to force people to fill their resort rooms. I think in this economy they are having problems filling rooms.

Brunette

Thanks for reminding me of that, as I forgot. Those rates are not applicable to many people, as that is a specialized rate, so for a regular person like me, we have to compare the rates that are showing, and they seem to be cheaper than Disney Deluxes for the most part, depending upon the time of travel, and what promos Disney is running at the time. We've gotten Disney Deluxes as cheap as $150/night during the summer season a few years back.

exactly, fd is nothing but a trick to get people to stay on property. I want to remind how, I think 2years ago, craziness with upgrades started, when people were sent emails that values were overbooked and offered moderates an dvc resorts just to free rooms. why, because people refused to pay more and while disney had enough rooms overall, they did not have enough affordable rooms.
i am regular august visitor and i never saw aruba builing, the one right across the bridge, the 1 of 2 most popular locations after preffered to be so empty. no i did not talk to anyone, but when you walk at 8am and see made beds when nobody cleaned yet, and again in afternoon and again at midnight , you know room is empty. i felt like i rented the whole floor,only few rooms had guests, the quietest stay ever, not a single running kid, that is not normal, esp.when parks are full. i bet all values were sold out as i could not get a single normal adr, it was fd time.

You make a valid point, that the Values book up first for the FD promo, and so moderates may not be as busy. That's good for you as less people to worry about!

I can definitely say that Disney had empty rooms. I ended up booking only 3 weeks before our trip in early August since I kept trying to find a good deal for a few places. I really pushed it but there were plenty of options so I didn't worry too much. Even after I booked I kept on checking rooms including Disney just out of curiosity. I found that only a few deluxe resorts, one moderate (one of the Port Orleans places) and Pop Century were uniformly booked. I could definitely book a high priced deluxe or a moderate or the Allstars with no problem. Plus Disney had their signs stating "rooms available" out along the roads.

Tiger, you make a good point about there possibly not being enough to do onsite if Disney isn't careful. We love to go offsite even if we stay at an onsite resort but not everyone is like that plus I doubt that Disney wants that.

I think Disney needs to really watch how many more resorts they are building, with the parks currently the way they are. Downtown Disney is already a disaster - unruly people, including many kids, smoking all over the place and stores that you can't get into, as it's a free activity, so tons of people crowd over there. The Boardwalk at night is also packed - good luck getting into any of those restaurants last minute.

And we know that the parks are taking a hit during peak seasons too, which is why monorails break down, and attractions are down. Too much load capacity means the infrastructure can't handle it.

This is also why we are seeing maintenance issues at the parks and resorts too. So many guests means more cleaning and maintenance, yet Disney has understaffed in these areas.

I am of the belief that Disney does not need to be affordable for all, they on the other hand, disagree as they keep offering discount/promos to get guests to the parks. Travel is a luxury, and not a necessity; therefore, with so many discounts offered throughout the year, although it's good for the bottom line, it's not good for those of us who are stuck trying to navigate through the parks. I can only go during peak seasons, and it's still very busy, resorts are full, as are restaurants, and cash registers are ringing up sales like crazy.

I worry that too many guests with not enough staffing and a lack of activities, will continue to cause Disney issues. Looking forward to the MK expansion, but not sure what to make of Avatar, as I have no interest in that movie, but if it allows for crowds to spread out, I'm all for it!

If 55 million people visit next year due to these new activities, is Disney going to staff accordingly? I am glad that they have a variety of rooms at differnent price points, as it spreads out guests. If Disney was all Value Resorts and DVC, we would be in big trouble as I'm sure occupancy rates would be much higher. They are already pretty much at 100% for DVC, so that would be a huge influx on the parks, especially if Disney offered promos throughout the year.

If you currently look at how many rooms are on property, with several more resorts on tap for the near future, that is a lot of rooms to fill. There are many of us who believe they have too many rooms, and therefore, they have to offer discounts to fill them, which costs us all. They are struggling to fill rooms during certain periods for various reasons, as we've all been discussing.

There is so much that goes into the travel game, so I can only imagine how difficult it must be to make sense of it all at times. But I will agree that Disney's profit margins are ridiculously high, and that may have to change if they can't fill all of those rooms. And, I would hate for the rest of us to have to supplement that either...

Tiger
 
Thanks for the info - there is nothing to get right about it. We don't gamble, so we went to Vegas to do the resorts, restaurants and shows, just like many people do with Disney. Since we don't gamble, we don't have access to the discounts that you mention. Like I said though, despite this, Vegas is still pretty reasonable everytime I see promos advertised.

Sounds like you are getting great deals, but again, the casinos are allowing you to have those great deals. They supplement the promos that Vegas gives out. Have watched several very good documentaries about the way Vegas works. The revenue that is generated from the casinos is astronomical and supplements all of the freebies, so that you keep coming back over and over again. I don't blame you for going back so often, if it's so cheap, but Disney will never be like that, nor do I want them to be.:thumbsup2

Again, I shouldn't have mentioned Vegas as I said in my last post, as it's a very different market there.



Thanks for reminding me of that, as I forgot. Those rates are not applicable to many people, as that is a specialized rate, so for a regular person like me, we have to compare the rates that are showing, and they seem to be cheaper than Disney Deluxes for the most part, depending upon the time of travel, and what promos Disney is running at the time. We've gotten Disney Deluxes as cheap as $150/night during the summer season a few years back.


Tiger

*
Hi Tiger-

Sure those rates are available to many people. For AAA all you need to do is spend approximately $75.00 if not less for the card and receive all kinds of benefits including the $99.00 stay at this resort. They also offer discounts at Disney too. As far as Government and Military those discounts may be not prevalent to other people but the AAA discount is.
 
*
Hi Tiger-

Sure those rates are available to many people. For AAA all you need to do is spend approximately $75.00 if not less for the card and receive all kinds of benefits including the $99.00 stay at this resort. They also offer discounts at Disney too. As far as Government and Military those discounts may be not prevalent to other people but the AAA discount is.

Not even that. Go any day on expedia and you will find deal after deal or just low prices. I am looking at week of November 20th. GF average is $435 with 3 nights above $500. Waldorf Astoria is $179 with 10 % discount, Ritz $260 without discounts, huge difference in both price and service.
 
exactly, fd is nothing but a trick to get people to stay on property. I want to remind how, I think 2years ago, craziness with upgrades started, when people were sent emails that values were overbooked and offered moderates an dvc resorts just to free rooms. why, because people refused to pay more and while disney had enough rooms overall, they did not have enough affordable rooms.
i am regular august visitor and i never saw aruba builing, the one right across the bridge, the 1 of 2 most popular locations after preffered to be so empty. no i did not talk to anyone, but when you walk at 8am and see made beds when nobody cleaned yet, and again in afternoon and again at midnight , you know room is empty. i felt like i rented the whole floor,only few rooms had guests, the quietest stay ever, not a single running kid, that is not normal, esp.when parks are full. i bet all values were sold out as i could not get a single normal adr, it was fd time.

Kelly you are absolutely right about free dining.It fills values but not near as many deluxes.Unfortunately I think for the majority of people the prices on these(deluxes) are now a fantasy.Heck they raise the rack rates on these things every year and this year the biggest discount I could find was a 35% not the usual 40% on these rooms.When rack rate on these babies is already almost 400 dollars or higher(standard view) I really don't know how much further they can take these rack rates.I will never ever ever pay 300 a night for a room,it could be on mars and I wouldn't pay it.Lets face something else the moderates aren't worth 200 a night either.The reason they get the primo bucks on the deluxes is location,ain't gonna happen on the moderates IMO.I really think disney best get creative in other ways cause they are very near the top in pricing rooms!
 
When Brunette first posted this thread, some angry Diser made a competing "Do you think Disney has gone UP HILL" thread to "fight the negativity."

It's funny how that thread vanished... and this one is still going strong.
 
When Brunette first posted this thread, some angry Diser made a competing "Do you think Disney has gone UP HILL" thread to "fight the negativity."

It's funny how that thread vanished... and this one is still going strong.

*
Hey there NYTIMES! :)

Yes, very ironic. The thing is, though, this is an unbiased thread. We all love Disney and we do see the value on some things Disney. There are plenty of great things to do and see. We just try to "guide" the user on various things that are currently happening within the WORLD. So, in essence it's just not negative, it's very positive too.

Thanks for posting this. Haven't seen you in a while. Hope you are doing GREAT!

Brunette
 
Kelly you are absolutely right about free dining.It fills values but not near as many deluxes.Unfortunately I think for the majority of people the prices on these(deluxes) are now a fantasy.Heck they raise the rack rates on these things every year and this year the biggest discount I could find was a 35% not the usual 40% on these rooms.When rack rate on these babies is already almost 400 dollars or higher(standard view) I really don't know how much further they can take these rack rates.I will never ever ever pay 300 a night for a room,it could be on mars and I wouldn't pay it.Lets face something else the moderates aren't worth 200 a night either.The reason they get the primo bucks on the deluxes is location,ain't gonna happen on the moderates IMO.I really think disney best get creative in other ways cause they are very near the top in pricing rooms!

This may come as a shock, but I actually agree with this post. Personally, I am with you in that I would not pay the prices asked, but yet these resorts still get quite a few bookings each night. :confused3 When I tried to add a night on to our BLT stay last June, many of the lower categories of the Delxue resorts were sold out. Sure, I could still get a room with a water or theme park view or even CL, but if I was hesitant to pay $300, I was definitely not going to pay $500+. We ended up off-site at the Vistana for a couple of nights. Even the family suites (which are horrible IMO compared to DVC) often go for more than $200 per night and they are harder to find discounts.

I have read many posts from those who say that FD is the only way they can afford Disney. They stay in the Values during value season with FD. They claim that there is no off-site resort that is less expensive unless you pack your own food. Not sure how valid their claims are as we never do FD as we generally cannot go during those times of year.


When Brunette first posted this thread, some angry Diser made a competing "Do you think Disney has gone UP HILL" thread to "fight the negativity."

It's funny how that thread vanished... and this one is still going strong.

The top 25 posters on this thread have generated over 72% of the posts. The DIS is such a tiny fraction of those who visit WDW and to say that a miniscule 25 people keeping a thread alive by debating this topic is representative of the larger population is unrealistic.

Plus, I'm not sure how ironic it really is. The only way to keep a thread alive is to have those who want to debate or if there is a true disagreement. That is why negative threads stay alive and positive threads die quickly IMHO. ;)

At least Brunette adds that Disney has done many positive things over the years in addition to the cutbacks and price increases. I respect that and wish more posters were like her. We can respectfully disagree on whether the positives outweigh the negatives or vice versa. These threads are mildly entertaining, but I doubt if they change too many minds. JMTC
 
*
Hi Tiger-

Sure those rates are available to many people. For AAA all you need to do is spend approximately $75.00 if not less for the card and receive all kinds of benefits including the $99.00 stay at this resort. They also offer discounts at Disney too. As far as Government and Military those discounts may be not prevalent to other people but the AAA discount is.

Sorry, I was just talking about the military rates. You sure got a steal!

Not even that. Go any day on expedia and you will find deal after deal or just low prices. I am looking at week of November 20th. GF average is $435 with 3 nights above $500. Waldorf Astoria is $179 with 10 % discount, Ritz $260 without discounts, huge difference in both price and service.

That is a good rate for the Waldorf too, and it is very deluxe, as you pointed out. But again, Disney is competing with no one, whereas the offsite hotels have to compete with Disney. There are people who will only stay onsite, and they pay whatever price is listed - we've met many of these guests. But nowadays, there are a zillion rooms in Orlando, so more rooms to fill, means more aggressive promos for offsite hotels as they compete with onsite and private homes too. It is amazing to me just how many rooms are available in Orlando, so really, there seems to be a price point for everyone, which is great! It is good for the consumer to be able to get good deals!

Kelly you are absolutely right about free dining.It fills values but not near as many deluxes.Unfortunately I think for the majority of people the prices on these(deluxes) are now a fantasy.Heck they raise the rack rates on these things every year and this year the biggest discount I could find was a 35% not the usual 40% on these rooms.When rack rate on these babies is already almost 400 dollars or higher(standard view) I really don't know how much further they can take these rack rates.I will never ever ever pay 300 a night for a room,it could be on mars and I wouldn't pay it.Lets face something else the moderates aren't worth 200 a night either.The reason they get the primo bucks on the deluxes is location,ain't gonna happen on the moderates IMO.I really think disney best get creative in other ways cause they are very near the top in pricing rooms!

I disagree that moderates aren't worth $200.00. We've stayed in older Hampton Inns and paid $150/night, and paid $300/night for Great Wolf Lodge, so why wouldn't a Disney hotel be worth that as it's onsite, free transportation and free parking? We happen to think that Port Orleans is in a great location actually, and it's a very charming resort. I would say that $200/night for moderate is pretty much our limit though, but I don't proclaim to assume that this is the same for everyone.

Also, just because you think the prices of Deluxes are high, it doesn't mean it's a fantasy for many people at all. We know lots of people who gladly pay those rack rates. We are DVC, which means we stay at Deluxe hotels that share with DVC, such as: BLT, Boardwalk, Beach Club, AK and Wilderness, and we meet tons of people who paid rack rates for rooms. Heck, we've met people who pay $700/night rack rate for our DVC 1 bed villas. :scared1:

We don't think it's worth it to pay Deluxe rates either, which is why we purchased DVC :thumbsup2, but there are many who actually do pay as Deluxes are still very occupied during peak seasons like Christmas or Summer. But you bring up a good point - what is the limit?

The DIS is a small representation of the larger population who visit Disney. Since Disney doesn't release specific occupancy rates per resort, nor room category, it would be interesting to see what the numbers are?

Despite the fact that you and several others on here think that Disney rooms are sitting empty most of the time, that's not true. There are rooms that are sitting empty some of the time, but at 82% year round occupancy (if indeed this number is correct), that means most rooms are filled on a consistent basis throughout the year. Of course, it balances out with slower seasons and then during peak seasons where most rooms are all filled up. At this point though, people are still staying at those resorts, as I can attest to this - are they using discounts, rack, FD promos, etc.?

It will be interesting to see what happens when Art of Animation opens? Will Disney be able to fill those rooms, and get occupancy rates up, or, with more rooms, will their occupancy go down across the board as there are too many rooms to fill? I think the Values are going to take a hit, just like when Pop opened, so it will be interesting to see what happens. I think with the MK expansion and the new resort, it's going to draw in some extra guests.

This may come as a shock, but I actually agree with this post. Personally, I am with you in that I would not pay the prices asked, but yet these resorts still get quite a few bookings each night. :confused3 When I tried to add a night on to our BLT stay last June, many of the lower categories of the Delxue resorts were sold out. Sure, I could still get a room with a water or theme park view or even CL, but if I was hesitant to pay $300, I was definitely not going to pay $500+. We ended up off-site at the Vistana for a couple of nights. Even the family suites (which are horrible IMO compared to DVC) often go for more than $200 per night and they are harder to find discounts.

I have read many posts from those who say that FD is the only way they can afford Disney. They stay in the Values during value season with FD. They claim that there is no off-site resort that is less expensive unless you pack your own food. Not sure how valid their claims are as we never do FD as we generally cannot go during those times of year.

The top 25 posters on this thread have generated over 72% of the posts. The DIS is such a tiny fraction of those who visit WDW and to say that a miniscule 25 people keeping a thread alive by debating this topic is representative of the larger population is unrealistic.

Plus, I'm not sure how ironic it really is. The only way to keep a thread alive is to have those who want to debate or if there is a true disagreement. That is why negative threads stay alive and positive threads die quickly IMHO. ;)

At least Brunette adds that Disney has done many positive things over the years in addition to the cutbacks and price increases. I respect that and wish more posters were like her. We can respectfully disagree on whether the positives outweigh the negatives or vice versa. These threads are mildly entertaining, but I doubt if they change too many minds. JMTC

I don't know that we are necessarily interested in changing people's minds. Just debating about our favourite place!

It continues to be an interesting and informative discussion, IMHO.

Tiger :)
 
The top 25 posters on this thread have generated over 72% of the posts. The DIS is such a tiny fraction of those who visit WDW and to say that a miniscule 25 people keeping a thread alive by debating this topic is representative of the larger population is unrealistic.

Plus, I'm not sure how ironic it really is. The only way to keep a thread alive is to have those who want to debate or if there is a true disagreement. That is why negative threads stay alive and positive threads die quickly IMHO. ;)

At least Brunette adds that Disney has done many positive things over the years in addition to the cutbacks and price increases. I respect that and wish more posters were like her. We can respectfully disagree on whether the positives outweigh the negatives or vice versa. These threads are mildly entertaining, but I doubt if they change too many minds. JMTC

Never said the thread represented any portion of Disney visitors. I didn't even call it ironic. It's an observation.

Nice job diminishing the comments of those 25 people, however. I didn't realize people needed a public mandate to discuss these things. ;)
 
*
Hey there NYTIMES! :)

Yes, very ironic. The thing is, though, this is an unbiased thread. We all love Disney and we do see the value on some things Disney. There are plenty of great things to do and see. We just try to "guide" the user on various things that are currently happening within the WORLD. So, in essence it's just not negative, it's very positive too.

Thanks for posting this. Haven't seen you in a while. Hope you are doing GREAT!

Brunette

Constructive criticism is an important part of the experience and I always learn more from the negative experiences than the positive ones. That's why I value these threads.

I look on them the way I do a restaurant review on the restaurants board. Some match my experience, others don't -- but they all help inform my own expectations as well as alert me to things I should watch for.
 
I disagree that moderates aren't worth $200.00. We've stayed in older Hampton Inns and paid $150/night, and paid $300/night for Great Wolf Lodge, so why wouldn't a Disney hotel be worth that as it's onsite, free transportation and free parking? We happen to think that Port Orleans is in a great location actually, and it's a very charming resort. I would say that $200/night for moderate is pretty much our limit though, but I don't proclaim to assume that this is the same for everyone.

Also, just because you think the prices of Deluxes are high, it doesn't mean it's a fantasy for many people at all. We know lots of people who gladly pay those rack rates. We are DVC, which means we stay at Deluxe hotels that share with DVC, such as: BLT, Boardwalk, Beach Club, AK and Wilderness, and we meet tons of people who paid rack rates for rooms. Heck, we've met people who pay $700/night rack rate for our DVC 1 bed villas. :scared1: At this point though, people are still staying at those resorts, as I can attest to this - are they using discounts, rack, FD promos, etc.?


It continues to be an interesting and informative discussion, IMHO.

Tiger :)

Tiger I saw a survey on this very site not long ago dealing with price you are willing to pay to stay at disney.The overwhelming majority had it at under 200 bucks.Now I know this website is small percentage of disney people but I did find that interesting.My opinion is this, I can stay much cheaper than 200 a night offsite and get alot nicer room if I can only get moderate for that price.That price by the way is what I used to pay for deluxe(with a pin) in off season less than a decade ago.Now I speak from a lower middle to low income level and the average family salary in my neck of the woods is a little over 40K a year(right about on my number).So in my neck of the woods 300 dollar a night rooms are either really stupid or a fantasy to anyone with economic bugetary sense IMO.I know there are wealthy people in the world who will drop a ton of cabbage with out much thought ,but I truly think they are the minority not the other way around.IMO once you pass that 250 level you exclude alot of the population,and now deluxes are well above that with moderates fast closing the gap.Heck I was shocked when I saw what some of the values cost at other non value times of the year.Hey I truly love disney,but I can see the end for families at my income level coming quick.The combination of raises disney has had tests even the saviest of shoppers. Oh well if that happens I guess I can still look at my old photos fondly! :thumbsup2 As always a pleasure talking wih you. :goodvibes Flicx
 
When Brunette first posted this thread, some angry Diser made a competing "Do you think Disney has gone UP HILL" thread to "fight the negativity."

It's funny how that thread vanished... and this one is still going strong.
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?

:earsboy:
 
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?

DING DING DING DING!!! That is true of most any public forum. Those being negative will come back again and again to argue. Those not being negative will make their point and move on.
 
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?

:earsboy:

Yes. Because people on both sides of any debate on the Dis are so well known for calling it quits.
 
But it's also the same dozen or so people posting over and over and over again, restating the same points y'all were making on page one. Perhaps the UP HILL people have just made their point and have now moved on to go plan their next trips?

:earsboy:

DING DING DING DING!!! That is true of most any public forum. Those being negative will come back again and again to argue. Those not being negative will make their point and move on.

Are you both serious? Just because we are still discussing, does not mean we are being negative and can't move on. On the contrary, if there are still things to discuss, why not continue to discuss them in a friendly and informative manner? I am very far from a negative person, but I love to discuss, especially when it's about Disney.

And sorry, people move on because they get easily bored and move on to other things. :thumbsup2 Many people on the DIS seem to have short attention spans, as so many of them don't even read through the thread before posting in it. :rotfl2:


Tiger I saw a survey on this very site not long ago dealing with price you are willing to pay to stay at disney.The overwhelming majority had it at under 200 bucks.Now I know this website is small percentage of disney people but I did find that interesting.My opinion is this, I can stay much cheaper than 200 a night offsite and get alot nicer room if I can only get moderate for that price.That price by the way is what I used to pay for deluxe(with a pin) in off season less than a decade ago.Now I speak from a lower middle to low income level and the average family salary in my neck of the woods is a little over 40K a year(right about on my number).So in my neck of the woods 300 dollar a night rooms are either really stupid or a fantasy to anyone with economic bugetary sense IMO.I know there are wealthy people in the world who will drop a ton of cabbage with out much thought ,but I truly think they are the minority not the other way around.IMO once you pass that 250 level you exclude alot of the population,and now deluxes are well above that with moderates fast closing the gap.Heck I was shocked when I saw what some of the values cost at other non value times of the year.Hey I truly love disney,but I can see the end for families at my income level coming quick.The combination of raises disney has had tests even the saviest of shoppers. Oh well if that happens I guess I can still look at my old photos fondly! :thumbsup2 As always a pleasure talking wih you. :goodvibes Flicx

That would be so cool to see a survey like that, but to be fair, it would need to be completed by all different demographics in order to be truly valid.

In regards to the nightly rate, I think it's essential to reference it in regards to yearly income or travel budget. $40,000 as family income is low, so I would not expect any of them to be staying in $300/night deluxe hotel rooms, as that would eat up whatever travel budget they had. I honestly can't imagine that a family income of $40,000 would really be travelling to Disney unless they were locals or within driving distance like Georgia, since the tickets alone for a family would eat up an entire budget. Honestly, if our family income was $40,000, we wouldn't be going on any vacations at all, especially not Disney.

Of course everyone sets their budgets differently, but vacationing is a luxury, and we treat it as such, but we have a fairly high income level, and we wouldn't pay $400/night either as we can stay at other wonderful resorts for much less money.

It gets tricky when discussing incomes, but I don't think Disney needs to be affordable for all income levels at all, as it's a vacation destination, and not a necessity. But they seem to be going in that direction with year long discounts/promos, but with a family income of only $40,000/year, they would need to have very low rack rates, and drastically lower tickets and food. So, I honestly don't think that is the income level they are aiming for. Please don't think I'm saying lower income people can't travel there, but in looking at budget alone, I wouldn't even have a travel budget at that level, so my family wouldn't be going to Disney, even if they gave us free rooms, as it would still cost transportation, tickets and food.

So, are other guests supplementing for the various promos, and does that make Disney go downhill in terms of maintenance and food?

Thanks for the discussion, Tiger :surfweb:
 
DING DING DING DING!!! That is true of most any public forum. Those being negative will come back again and again to argue. Those not being negative will make their point and move on.

Wow, Really? Thanks for the positive input on being negative or wait is it the negative input on being negative? Now I'm confused.:confused3Either way this thread is like the energizer bunny it just keeps going and going!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
















GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE


Our Dreams Unlimited Travel Agents will assist you in booking the perfect Disney getaway, all at no extra cost to you. Get the most out of your vacation by letting us assist you with dining and park reservations, provide expert advice, answer any questions, and continuously search for discounts to ensure you get the best deal possible.

CLICK HERE




facebook twitter
Top