The people using the fair card are the ones who have now moved into the group that can get FP+ sooner, like for example those who dont like ropedrop. They think it is fair bc they moved into the group who can now get the coveted FP+. But they forget about the people you mention bc they dont care about them. There is a limited capcity, someone is going to be shut out. Not everyone can ride TSMM through the FP line. They dont want fair which is what the old system was, they just want their FP+.
Frankly for us they were not...they stunk and we almost decided to never go back. But we did after research and bc we had a 4 yrold. We loved FP- and how it helped tour the park, I would never stand in a 2 hour Splash line like I did prior to FP-.
If WDW only wants the new once in a lifetime customer, than why are they building all the DVC rooms