Cookies BBQ or Serenity Beach food?

[pppiglet]

We will be going as 3 adults and would like to know which you all prefer to eat at since we will probably never be able to go again and would like a great meal for our Castaway Cay day!

 

[pppiglet]

Thanks for voting....especially the cruisers who have been more than once!

 

[imomtojd]

We will be going as 3 adults and would like to know which you all prefer to eat at since we will probably never be able to go again and would like a great meal for our Castaway Cay day!

We ate at the adult area a few weeks ago and wished we had eaten at Cookies. It had many more choices.

Lisa

 

[lmok]

I think our meal at Cookies was almost my favorite of the whole cruise. We just got back from June 2006. We will be going again in March 2007. EVERYTHING was good.

 

[perdidobay]

I have never eaten at Cookies, so I do not have a say on the food there. After 8 cruises and always eating at the Adult beach, I can say for sure I will always eat at Serenity Beach for one reason..... the serenity! I am very happy with the offerings there, even if there is not as many choices.
To eat in quiet surroundings or loud ones is the choice I am making.

 

[alexcturner]

The last time we went to Serenity Beach, we had lobster. It was great. (Not lobster burgers, the lobster tails.) Also, they had cookies and cream ice cream too.

 

[misterflibble]

We ate at Serenity Bay and were not overly impressed with the food selection. The peace and quiet of the beach was nice though
After reading some good reviews of Cookies we'll be trying there on our upcoming trip.

 

[barbmouse]

Cookies was awesome. There were tons of choices!! The fresh fruit was so tasty. The kids loved the cc cookie dough ice cream.

 

[kaykels]

Try A Little At Both.

 

[we4blairs]

I don't recall Cookies being all that great. It was just typical bbq menu - burgers, pastas, etc.

We had our kids with us so it was perfect being close to our beach. If it were just DH and I though I would probably try the other...

of course, just to be back on CC, I'd eat the sand!

 

[AhoyCaptainMickey]

cookies for me...

 

[MAGICAL EVENTS]

I don't recall Cookies being all that great. It was just typical bbq menu - burgers, pastas, etc.

We had our kids with us so it was perfect being close to our beach. If it were just DH and I though I would probably try the other...

of course, just to be back on CC, I'd eat the sand!

I agree that I was not that impressed, it's been okay though, bbq is one of our favs.

 

[RCBA]

Just off the double dip, had Cookies the 1st day and Serenity the 2nd day...my vote is definately Serenity!

 

[woody73]

Just off the double dip, had Cookies the 1st day and Serenity the 2nd day...my vote is definately Serenity!

Charla, Why? What did you like?

 

[MrsJobba1]

Serenity bay does not have as much choice as cookies ( after 7 days of cruise food I dont mind this)

But it is really peaceful and quiet, no cues

 

[RCBA]

Charla, Why? What did you like?

The pasta, the chicken, the fruit & desserts! Surf and Turf was also avail.
Not to mention it is quiet


MrsJobba1 - we had more meat choices and a better selection of fruits and dessert on our trip at Serenity vs Cookies.

 

[Kimmielee]

we had more meat choices and a better selection of fruits and dessert on our trip at Serenity vs Cookies.

I found the same to be true... unless I missed something at Cookies!

 

[MrsJobba1]

The pasta, the chicken, the fruit & desserts! Surf and Turf was also avail.
Not to mention it is quiet


MrsJobba1 - we had more meat choices and a better selection of fruits and dessert on our trip at Serenity vs Cookies.

Sorry, I have only ever eaten @ serenity bay, but from the messages posted on the dis I thought there was ususally a bigger selection @ cookies

 

[SideshowBob]

SSB done maybe 5 each, and would probably vote (if just looking at food) for Serenity. At least the times I have been, had a few more choices on grill (as far as salmon or such) at Serenity. I think that the overall spread of food much greater at Cookies, but a bit higher quality at Serenity.

 

[klineyqueen]

We ate at both. We did Serenity Bay before we had children and it was awesome because it was just adults. The last cruise we did Cookies because we had a son with us and the selection was better.

We will be doing cookies from now on because we will always have our kids with us at CC.

Honestly, you can't go wrong with either choice.