Cookies BBQ or Serenity Beach food?

[princess22]

DBF and I went to the beach in the morning, so around 1:00 we were ready to go back (we aren't huge beach people). We ate a snack at Serenity Bay, then we went and ate at Cookies. I think Cookies had a bigger selection than serenity bay. We didn't have lobster at Serenity Bay when we went! They didn't even have the ribs they had over at Cookies. There were also more desserts at Cookies. I would say do both. Get a snack at Serenity Bay when it opens, then an hour or so later, head over to Cookies! Get the best of both worlds!!!!

 

[Doingitagain]

It is my understanding is that they have recently upgraded their grilling capabilities at Serenity Bay. I think they are getting a "feel" for what works. We were on the double dip, and the second day had a larger variety of grilled items. Also, they had "real" silverware (the first day was plastic and try cutting a T-bone with that!).

Cookies is much larger and probably does have more variety because of that, but I believe that Serenity Bay has higher quality, and is a more relaxing atmosphere.

 

[Doingitagain]

Let me also add that we only walked a few feet to a table, making it easier to go back for dessert, fruit, drinks, etc. At Cookies, we sometimes had to carry trays quite a distance to find a table.

 

[pppiglet]

Wow...the poll is really close. This will be a hard choice! We might just have to try both! I would prefer to just eat at one though. Thanks for all your input.

 

[BobandLee]

Serenity Bay.
It is more quiet.
Food is better....last cruise there was a fruit/salad bar along with steak/chicken/salmon. Yes, the soft serve was good also.
It is also close to the adult beach, so you can have lunch, then back to the beach.