Clay and Reuben!! American IDOL!!!

[Poohbear123]

So far, these two are the BEST tonight! Don't forget to vote!!

 

[wvjules]

They're the best every night!!!!!!!!

 

[Poohbear123]

Bllaaahhhh! Not too good tonight!

 

[Poohbear123]

AAccckkk! BUT I like what Simon said about her replacing the "girl from the Dixie Chicks!" LOL! GOOD one Simon!

 

[CJK]

Yeah Clay & Reuben!!! I wish Canadians could vote!!!!

 

[Poohbear123]

I wish you all could too... GO CLAY! GO RUEBEN! And, WHEN did Josh becaome a COUNTRY SINGER??

 

[paras4ri]

I love both Clay and Reuben!!!

 

[Poohbear123]

Bllaaahhhh! Don't think she will be around next week...

 

[mouseclick1]

Clay and Reuben are my favorites! I think Trenyce (sp?) is also very good. I think the next to go will be a toss up between Carmen and Julia.

 

[Poohbear123]

You GO Girl!! What a transformation!!! She looked and sounded GREAT!

 

[WDW Poly Princess]

Wow! Tonight was one of the most interresting episodes!

My thoughts--

Corey- Man, he was really shaking at first! I thought he was ok, but not outstanding.

Ruben- Yay for picking a Disney song!!! His hand movement needs some work, but he sounded great! How many of those 205 shirts does he have?

Trenyse- She was definitly "on" tonight!

Clay- I had goosebumps when he was singing! He makes it look so effortless! And I cracked up at Simon's "I just love songs about mice!"

Kimberly C- You go, home girl I've heard her sound better, this wasn't her best night, but still good. She can really work a stage!

Josh- He sounded a lot like George Strait tonight!

Carmen- She still doesnt do much for me

Charles- He was really working the crowd, but I didnt think he was all that good

Ricky- Great voice and personality, and fun to watch! I just cant see myself driving in my car listening to him, though.

Julia- Thought she was just ok, I think she was kind of going for the sympathy votes with her whole "I dont have the confidence.." thing

Kimberly L- She was so much better than last week, and she looked stunning!

It was fun to see Kelly Clarkson again!

 

[LIDisneyFan]

Liked Trenyce and Clay, I don't get Simon's thing for Carmen (she always sounds like she's yodeling).

Kimberly Locke was so much better, Julia (DD's favorite) wil be history next week. Ricky's song annoyed me this week. Loved the 'theme park' comment about Kimerbly Cauldwell - when I thgouth about it, it was really 'spot on'.

 

[Kirby]

What was Rueben called? The Velveteen Teddybear? Well, how about Peter Pan for Clay? He has the look.

I still don't see what Simon saw in Carmen. I thought that some of the other girls on the Wild Card show had much better voices.

What did ya'll think of Kelly? I really didn't like her singing tonight. But then I don't like to listen to anyone who sounds like they are yelling to the music.

 

[aahmom1]

Clay and Trynece (sp) were so awesome tonight, she nailed that song. Rueben was great too. Julie will be gone next week, I really thought she sucked it up out there tonight.

 

[Shelly]

I'm voting for Clay all the way. He is just the nicest "for real" one there. Did you see the wild card episode, it was about over and everyone stood in the spotlight celibrating. Then there were the poor losers sitting on the couch. Clay was the only one to go over to them, everyone else followed after they noticed of course.
GO CLAY!

 

[CourtasanSatine]

I'm rooting for Clay as well,still looking for my female pick

 

[100%Disney]

It is Clay all the way, he is so great, and from NC. I like to see people win that aren't full of themself. Can't wait to see what he sings for Disco week. I think the bottom 3 should be Corey, Charles and Julia.

 

[disykat]

I also thought the bottom three should be Corey, Charles, and Julia. I'm not crazy about Carmen either (I also thought yodeling) but she was more interesting than the other three.

I thought Ruben showed more facial expression tonight - loved the Disney tune. Clay remains my favorite - I'd like to see him on Broadway etc. I really liked Ricky tonight too - perfect song for him. I missed Vanessa. I thought Josh blew it by going too country - he really poured on the nasal.

I didn't like Kelly's song. Not really due to her singing, I just don't like pained facial expressions while singing.

 

[Poohbear123]

has ALL the right parts in all the right places.....if you get my meaning. For 17 she SURE is Developed! No singing voice at all though. Kelly looked a little "fat" to me, and that MAKEUP!! Whoa, slow down girl!

 

[Liz]

Corey - not very good last night

Ruben - AWESOME

Trenyce - I have never been a fan of hers but last night her voice was undeniably wonderful!

Clay - AWESOME

Kimberly - I have not disliked her as much as some people but last night she didn't do very good. Gotta give her credit for not going off on Simon when asked if she wanted to respond to his comments.

Josh - AWESOME - I just love everything about him - his military background and what a great husband and father he seems to be. Why did Simon say he has to pick a style and stick with it? Why can't he do a variety of different kinds of music?

Carmen - sad to see her do so poorly. I hope she sticks around and gets another chance to prove herself. But she is so young and inexperienced.

Charles - doesn't do anything for me.

Ricky - good

Julia - BLAH! Hope she goes. Like one of the judges said she acts like she doesn't have any confidence in herself. I think almost going last week did that to her.

Kimberly - AWESOME!