Hi everyone,
We also missed out on getting reservations for a party of 4 on Friday, September 26. We actually had called the day before (Sunday) for a reservation for a party of 10 on Thursday, September 25 and got it

, but my family of four is unsure if we will be able to change our flight schedule to arrive at WDW a day early in order to use the Thursday CRT thus we were hoping to secure the CRT for Friday in the event we can't. At least I was able to get in on Thursday for my sister's family.
Anyways, it was interesting to get different results because we did the exact same thing and used everyone's suggestions here on the board. We started calling at around 3:55 am (West Coast here), listened carefully to the recorded message and immediately hung up and redialed if it was the "Closed" recorded message ("Thank you for calling Disney Dining. Our office is closed."). Played this game until 4:00 or 4:01, then finally got the "Open" message ("Thank you for calling the Disney Reservation Center."). Immediately hit "1" and was put on hold with music. The first day we called, I was on hold from about 4:01 to 4:03. I let the CM give his introduction and then promptly said, "Good Morning, Party of 10, Cinderella's Breakfast, Anytime." He came back to say, "9:10", me "Great!", him "Got it!". Then he proceeded to get all my other information.
This morning, the "open" message still didn't get switched on until about 4:00 or 4:01, immediately hit "1" and was put on hold. The CM didn't pick up until about 4:07! I knew my chances of getting anything were slim. Said the same thing as before (except Party of 4 this time) and she came back and said, "I'm sorry, party of 4 for Cinderella's Breakfast is sold out for September 26."
Anyways, I will note that it seemed when we were calling this morning (Monday), the phone lines were taking longer to get through (I was using our cordless and my husband was using the cell phone) and I had at least three redial attempts when the office was still closed where I received "dead air." We didn't have this at all when we were calling on Sunday. So I wonder if that is any indication that the phone lines were just that more busy on a weekday?
So, since Friday, September 26 was our first full day at WDW, I'll continue to get up a little before 4:00 and start calling for everyday of our trip in hopes to get one, but if someone got in today for Friday, September 26 and has a reservation for a party of 4 they are going to cancel, I would love to hear from you! We aren't picky and would take anytime!
Good luck to everyone else trying as well.
Take care,
Amy