My DD is convinced it’s because people are getting tested less. She gave examples of people she knows who tested positive and then others in the household came down with it but did not test because they figure that’s what it is. But I’m pretty sure that was already happening and I can’t see it accounting for such a huge drop. I think she’s afraid to get her hopes up that we could possibly be turning the corner. I know I get that way, it’s kind of hard not to sometimes.
That has been happening all along, though, and early on when tests were hard to come by was even being encouraged. There has been some decline in testing, probably because there's somewhat less demand for it when the virus is less prevalent in an area and people are therefore less concerned about exposure, but the positivity rate is falling as well. That points to a genuine decline in cases, because if people simply aren't seeking out testing unless they're symptomatic or seeking medical care, the number of tests run would be lower but the percentage of them coming back positive would be higher. When both measures - cases and positivity rate - decline together, that's genuinely good news.
I was watching national news last night, it was probably NBC but im not positive, and the vaccine report actually annoyed me. Nothing they said was factually incorrect but it wasn’t really the full story either. They were emphasizing you could still get COVID after vaccinated (no mentioning that it’s rare and likely non-severe), that you will still spread it (this is a possibility, but not proven yes or not yet). They were talking about life after vaccination and whether grandparents could finally hug their grandkids, and that didn’t even get a yes answer. Still no socializing and reservations about in person dining and the gym. Basically, you’re vaccinated and nothing really changes for you. Now I’m not saying that you should rip your mask off and immediately host a raging party, but for gods sake, hug your grandkids. Go out to dinner (especially if restrictions still have capacity low).
My husband who hasn’t really been keeping up with this stuff turned and looked at me and asked why on earth he should bother with the vaccine. Great. That’s just the kind of news we need. Let’s convince people the vaccine isn’t going to change anything so that we never come close to getting enough to get it. I was frustrated.
My husband has had the same reaction to the coverage. It feels like in the effort to discourage people from prematurely abandoning precautions, the media and the experts on the media circuit are taking a position that is basically designed to squash all hope whatsoever. And I think that's a serious mistake. Not only does fear-based motivation lose some of its effectiveness over time (so-called pandemic fatigue), presenting a situation as hopeless is not the way to get human beings to make good choices with the long view in mind. It seems likely to discourage vaccine uptake - because really, what's the point if it changes nothing? - and, paradoxically, make people less cooperative with masking and distancing and other mitigation efforts because they're more likely to start thinking in terms of "new normal" rather than the last months of a short-term collective effort to control spread.
If that were the case you'd see a rise (or at least not a drop) in the percentage positive. Since both case rate and percentage positive are dropping, you can have a good feeling that the drop is real.
I think it's a combination of things -
Certainly it's a huge fall from the holiday bump. (Laws may not have changed significantly, but the number of people travelling in November and December was staggering compared to the previous 8 months. It was risky behavior and we all paid the price.) Also, as people saw the huge bump in January, at least around me, people started laying low again. People seem to be taking precautions more seriously again compared to the late summer/fall.
I'm sure some of it is part of the natural rise and fall of a virus, too.
Finally, of course, vaccines! they're getting out there, and getting (mostly) to the most vulberable.
It's like the perfect storm of good news, for a change. Let's just hope we keep heading in the right direction!
I'm still not all that sold on the pivotal effect of the holidays. At best, it appears to be a regional effect and I generally don't think there's that much difference in how people as a group behave from place to place. I think the natural seasonality of a virus and of virus-vulnerable behavioral changes (like staying indoors for everything) has had a much bigger impact.
My state peaked in mid November. I know quite a few people who cancelled or scaled down Thanksgiving, but also quite a few who didn't. Almost no one cancelled Christmas. Every mass at our parish was full (to the capacity limit currently in place, which is far from the usual standing-room-only). But we didn't get the "surge on top of a surge" that all the experts were predicting. In fact, other than a sharp dip over the few days around Christmas (that coincides with a sharp short-term drop in the number of tests done) and rebound when testing levels went back to normal the next week, the trend has been consistently downward since just before Thanksgiving.
And as far as travel goes, TSA volume numbers show air travel is still significantly reduced from normal but Jan & Feb (so far) are showing much busier than any month from Apr through Oct. October brought the first million-passenger day of the pandemic; February has had 3 so far and we're only halfway through the month. On whole, people just aren't hunkering down the way they were early on in the pandemic.