Exactly. Before they did the last refurb at VWL, there was a distinct feel to the rooms there, and I would be the first to admit that it was darker than many appreciated and tending to almost caricature in a few instances. Yet, that is
exactly why I fell in love with the Lodge, more especially, VWL. I can go to any number of hotels in any number of cities and find that clean, modern look--it's ubiquitous. When I go to Disney, yes, I do expect to be transported to a different experience. As
danikoski quoted above, Disney fosters certain perceptions; thus, one develops certain expectations to match. . .at least I do.
I would have loved to see a room more closely resembling the picture that, again,
danikoski shows above.
While I understand that style doesn't appeal to everyone, isn't that the whole point of the resorts, something different for everyone? With a few minor adjustments, the now widely-circulated picture of the CCVC studio could just as easily fit into the theming at BLT, or Poly, et. al. The larger point is that such a skewing toward modernity lessens the feeling of being immersed in Disney, especially now that my wife and I don't hit the parks as heavily anymore. I liked that Disney rooms were unique. Now, I see a certain sameness--though granted a nicely modern one--that makes me yawn.
A bigger question for me is, "why?" To my mind, the primary driver is an economic one. Theming takes money from the initial creativity, to the graphic layouts, to the architecture, and most heavily, the furnishings. To be unique means smaller quantities of hard and soft goods, specifically designated for a particular resort, and that generally means more cost. All of this isn't to say the argument that many who come to Disney would prefer more modern, sleek lines is off base. I suspect that it is true to some extent. Such an acknowledgement doesn't, however, reduce my feelings that Disney is increasingly taking less chances at being unique, which can only be seen as further admission to what we all know--the bottom line is what truly matters.