Argh. The 20% off coupon can't be used for Disney Giftcards afterall. :(

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would just like to say...for me, personally...I was buying the gift cards anyway (I leave in 2 weeks for Disney) as well as groceries. I had no high expectations and was actually surprised that it worked. I was told by the cashier how lucky I was because I was getting 20% off my gift cards too without me even asking if it would work. I did not bully, push, demand, expect, whine, cry, feel entitled or put up any such fuss!!! It was given to me...without question. Am I to feel guilty because my local store allowed me to use this coupon???? Is it partially my fault if they stop giving the 5% off???? No, not at all. I think some of these negative comments are a little absurd, to be honest. People need to get off their high horse and stop whining and blaming others for losing a "perk" that has yet to even be taken away!!!! :confused3
 
I would just like to say...for me, personally...I was buying the gift cards anyway (I leave in 2 weeks for Disney) as well as groceries. I had no high expectations and was actually surprised that it worked. I was told by the cashier how lucky I was because I was getting 20% off my gift cards too without me even asking if it would work. I did not bully, push, demand, expect, whine, cry, feel entitled or put up any such fuss!!! It was given to me...without question. Am I to feel guilty because my local store allowed me to use this coupon???? Is it partially my fault if they stop giving the 5% off???? No, not at all. I think some of these negative comments are a little absurd, to be honest. People need to get off their high horse and stop whining and blaming others for losing a "perk" that has yet to even be taken away!!!! :confused3

And that is fine. My point is people who expect and demand the discount by an override. That's beating the system.

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards
 
Before I went to Target I read the coupon would not work, so I was disappointed but bought $2400 worth of cards using my pharmacy coupon and Red Card. So then I read on here that some people got the discount. So I went back to Target and the manager called guest services and they would not ok it. He wants to approve it but doesn't know how. He told me to get store numbers where the mangers were able to do it so if you got it please PM or post the store number. The thing :mad: that makes me the most upset is that I didnt get it and dozens of others did we all had same coupon and went on the same day
 
Has anyone demanded the discount? I am not sure. I read through this entire thread and it seems like the people who have gotten it have been perfectly polite and kind. And by most accounts the Target employees have been very happy for the customers. That was our case anyway.

I agree that some people are being very extreme and harsh. I think it probably has to do with the fact that some of those people did not get the discount. I would be upset too - but I knew going into it that it may or may not work. Just because it worked for some people doesn't mean that those people are horrible people who are costing employees their jobs and taking away other discounts in the future. Target knows about the discount. I guarantee you that when a customer comes in and buys thousand of dollars in ANYTHING, they notice. Do you think that last time you spent $4000 and got your 5 or 10% off that they didn't notice? When was the last time you ever spent that much in Target? I'm just saying. They are aware of the situation.

I'm so sorry to all of those people that did not get this discount. I just don't think it's okay to be super angry with those that did. Life is not fair sometimes.
 

And that is fine. My point is people who expect and demand the discount by an override. That's beating the system. Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards

I didn't expect or demand. I nicely asked and the manager said sure, let me take care of that for you. Is it fair to those who didn't get it? Hell no. But life isn't fair.

A Target employee friend told me this is Targets fault for. It being clear. She said they do this to themselves all the time. Didn't they learn last year after the $10 target card fiasco? She said no one will get fired over this...she laughed at me when I even suggested it (repeating what I have read here).
 
And here it goes......
Suzy got one, why didn't I?


Before I went to Target I read the coupon would not work, so I was disappointed but bought $2400 worth of cards using my pharmacy coupon and Red Card. So then I read on here that some people got the discount. So I went back to Target and the manager called guest services and they would not ok it. He wants to approve it but doesn't know how. He told me to get store numbers where the mangers were able to do it so if you got it please PM or post the store number. The thing :mad: that makes me the most upset is that I didnt get it and dozens of others did we all had same coupon and went on the same day
 
Has anyone demanded the discount? I am not sure. I read through this entire thread and it seems like the people who have gotten it have been perfectly polite and kind. And by most accounts the Target employees have been very happy for the customers. That was our case anyway.

I agree that some people are being very extreme and harsh. I think it probably has to do with the fact that some of those people did not get the discount. I would be upset too - but I knew going into it that it may or may not work. Just because it worked for some people doesn't mean that those people are horrible people who are costing employees their jobs and taking away other discounts in the future. Target knows about the discount. I guarantee you that when a customer comes in and buys thousand of dollars in ANYTHING, they notice. Do you think that last time you spent $4000 and got your 5 or 10% off that they didn't notice? When was the last time you ever spent that much in Target? I'm just saying. They are aware of the situation.

I'm so sorry to all of those people that did not get this discount. I just don't think it's okay to be super angry with those that did. Life is not fair sometimes.

Very well said!:)
 
I agree. It is the fact that Red Card and Rx Rewards both discount them, plus the fact that they call out iTunes but no others (as iTunes are normally included in Red Card and Rx) that has led to the confusion. Many, myself included, purchased on Friday specifically for this 20% with the assumption that the Disney cards would be eligible. We were wrong. Am I upset? A little. Mainly because I was on the Fantasy at the time, paid the 75¢ a minute (10 minutes) and the main item I wanted on Black Friday (an other Apple TV) was unavailable. So a few things add up to my "disappointment" though, to be honest, I partly expected it not to work, but the specific exclusion of iTunes is the biggest culprit in the confusion. If iTunes gift cards are gift cards the same as Disney, then iTunes did not need to be specifically called out.
You took a chance and this time you lost.

The pharma5 and REDCard5 discounts do not specifically exclude gift cards, like this coupon did. The pharma5 and REDCard5 specifically exclude "Target gift cards, Target eGiftCards, Target Mobile Gift Cards or Target prepaid cards, Target Commercial Interiors® purchases, previous purchases, Target credit account payments, Target Debit Card™ cash back and cash advances on the Target® Visa® Credit Card, some partner businesses including Target Clinic® services and Target Optical® eye exams, or where otherwise prohibited by law.

Nowhere in their wording do they exclude gift cards.

OTOH, the 20%-off coupon distributed on Black Friday specifically excludes gift cards and a number of other purchases. Their wording is not the same as the rules applying to pharma5 discounts or REDCard5 discounts.

It would have been awesome if this did work for Disney GCs and other GCs that Target codes as "entertainment cards" for accounting purposes. I bought a $75 Target GC online on Friday just so that I could take advantage of the deal if it did work out. But I'm not getting upset that it's a no-go. And I won't try to badger, wheedle, cajole, threaten, whine or create a scene in order to get someone to override the restrictions on the coupon.

People really need to let it go and move on.
 
No, they are labeled Entertainment cards. People didn't just randomly think this up. I took this photo at Target this morning.
The irony is that the tag on the shelf means nothing. The product itself clearly says "GIFT CARD" on it. It doesn't matter what is coded in their system or how they choose to word their barcode/price sticker on the shelf, which is usually done for stocking purposes mainly. You can't get away from the word "GIFT CARD" in that picture on the product ...just because things "worked in the past".

eta: if you want to be really picky, the Disney GC pictured says GIFT CARD on it no fewer than 17 times...LOL.
 
Totally agree that people should not badger, yell or demand anything. If you tried it and it was not successful, definitely move on.

I think I'm just a little disturbed by the amount of people who are extremely angry with the people who did get it.
 
I'm not angry with the ones who did, I am just diappointed in the ones who expect it, and ate trying to twist the wording for thier benefit.
 
Totally agree that people should not badger, yell or demand anything. If you tried it and it was not successful, definitely move on. I think I'm just a little disturbed by the amount of people who are extremely angry with the people who did get it.

Not angry, disappointed. Many of us here discussed the real possibility that Target would end all future discounts from the Red Card and Pharmacy coupon. Many also discussed the repercussions these managers will face after being pressured to give the discount.

These few DISers ignored these two factors. I would never force the issue to save a couple of hundred on a vacation I feel very fortunate to plan. Not at the expense of thousands of future purchases of Disney gift cards, let alone at the expense of someone's job!
 
But why go the step farther and ask for a manager when indeed you know for a fact they are gift cards and it clearly says it on the card itself?

My point people are trying to beat they system. There is really no denying it.

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards

I don't know if I see anyone trying to beat the system in this thread. I see people who questioned it b/c of the redcard and then were told, you know what you are right. I think you are allowed to question/clarify if you weren't sure. Then some read here they were told by the manager of their store that CS said to do it, so people then went in and asked. Things like this happen all the time in retail. The people who work at the store are not properly trained and in fact are wrong sometimes. You certainly have a right to question. Now scream, yell, pout, cry well I think that is a little extreme, but honestly I see a lot of people doing those things here about people asking or geItting the discount. It cuts both ways.

I don't have a coupon and like I said wouldn't expect to even get the 5% discount and do not use that either. I am just posting my observation and I think the only ones pouting are the ones mad that people got the discount. I mean seriously...accusing people for being at fault for someone now not being able to put food on their families table...:laughing:
 
Totally agree that people should not badger, yell or demand anything. If you tried it and it was not successful, definitely move on.

I think I'm just a little disturbed by the amount of people who are extremely angry with the people who did get it.

Badgering agree! Asking, I do not .. Ask away.. from sales 101.. you will lose nearly 100% of sales you did not ask for.. same theory here. You do not ask .. you will get no.. you ask you may get a yes.


I asked, not mean, just someone else was able to purchase these as an entertainment card, is this possible to use this coupon?
 
I would just like to say...for me, personally...I was buying the gift cards anyway (I leave in 2 weeks for Disney) as well as groceries. I had no high expectations and was actually surprised that it worked. I was told by the cashier how lucky I was because I was getting 20% off my gift cards too without me even asking if it would work. I did not bully, push, demand, expect, whine, cry, feel entitled or put up any such fuss!!! It was given to me...without question. Am I to feel guilty because my local store allowed me to use this coupon???? Is it partially my fault if they stop giving the 5% off???? No, not at all. I think some of these negative comments are a little absurd, to be honest. People need to get off their high horse and stop whining and blaming others for losing a "perk" that has yet to even be taken away!!!! :confused3

And that is wonderful! Others went in prepared to fight for their 20%, no matter what. I'm not whining or complaining. I am just trying to get people to understand that their actions (the ones who pushed the issue) affect more than just themselves. More likely than not, they live every day of their lives never even giving a second thought to how anything they do might affect anyone else.

Has anyone demanded the discount? I am not sure. I read through this entire thread and it seems like the people who have gotten it have been perfectly polite and kind. And by most accounts the Target employees have been very happy for the customers. That was our case anyway.

I've read on this thread and several others that people knew going into it that it probably wouldn't work, but they went directly to CS to do whatever it took to get the discount.

I agree that some people are being very extreme and harsh. I think it probably has to do with the fact that some of those people did not get the discount. I would be upset too - but I knew going into it that it may or may not work. Just because it worked for some people doesn't mean that those people are horrible people who are costing employees their jobs and taking away other discounts in the future. Target knows about the discount. I guarantee you that when a customer comes in and buys thousand of dollars in ANYTHING, they notice. Do you think that last time you spent $4000 and got your 5 or 10% off that they didn't notice? When was the last time you ever spent that much in Target? I'm just saying. They are aware of the situation.

I'm so sorry to all of those people that did not get this discount. I just don't think it's okay to be super angry with those that did. Life is not fair sometimes.

Don't feel sorry for me. I didn't get the discount, didn't attempt to get the discount, nor even left the house all weekend. I have no use for a discount on Disney GCs right now. That is not the reason I vented. I will admit that I was a little harsh in my vent, but I am just so tired of adults with entitlement issues, I may have snapped a little. So for that I'm sorry. But please be aware that stores can and will fire someone for overriding a discount. It happens all the time. Sadly, an employee will override a discount to keep from getting a customer complaint, but sign their own pink slip in the process.

I'm not angry with the ones who did, I am just diappointed in the ones who expect it, and ate trying to twist the wording for thier benefit.

This. I still fully expect that Target will immediately change their inventory system to reflect all "entertainment" cards as GCs. Just to save them from this hassle and profit loss in the future.

Totally agree that people should not badger, yell or demand anything. If you tried it and it was not successful, definitely move on.

I think I'm just a little disturbed by the amount of people who are extremely angry with the people who did get it.

I agree most definitely with your first paragraph. However, I'm not angry with the people who got the discount because they got it. I'm angry with the ones who demonstrated that good old entitlement mindset and wore down the management until they got the discount.

Not angry, disappointed. Many of us here discussed the real possibility that Target would end all future discounts from the Red Card and Pharmacy coupon. Many also discussed the repercussions these managers will face after being pressured to give the discount.

These few DISers ignored these two factors. I would never force the issue to save a couple of hundred on a vacation I feel very fortunate to plan. Not at the expense of thousands of future purchases of Disney gift cards, let alone at the expense of someone's job!

This! Again, this is what I'm saying.

Ok, here's the thing. If you just plopped your couple of Disney GCs on the belt with your robes and CDs and whatnot and then you got 20% on all of it immediately and automatically due to whatever powers that be, fine. I'm tickled for you, I truly am. Was I willing to go out this weekend and deal with traffic and crowds to get a future 20% discount - NO. If I had been willing to and I got the magical 20% discount, would I have tried to use it to buy $5000 worth of Disney GCs? No, because that action alone would have thrown up a red flag. Upon entering the store, I would have politely asked someone in CS before I started shopping if it would have worked. If they said yes, then I probably would have run with that. If they had said no, then I would have wished them a good day and proceeded to buy whatever else I needed and been done with it. I would not have started the semantics argument about gift cards vs. entertainment cards or insisted that someone call corporate and tie up at least one CS and one manager for and hour or more (from reports on various threads) on one of the busier days of the year. The simple fact that Target corporate put an automated message on their phone system to directly address that Disney GCs are not to be included under the discount should maybe give you an idea how they are wanting to handle this. But people still continued to press the issue.

People cannot take NO for NO. They take NO for maybe. Or they don't think that the NO could possibly apply to them, it only applies to other people. This is a problem. And I'm not just talking about today at Target with this discount. I see plenty of people acting like this every day of the year. And they are 10 times worse when they are actually at Disney World (or any vacation destination), they're the ones running their stroller over your feet, or pushing you out of the way to see a parade.

I'm not jealous, I'm disappointed in humanity. And the humanity in question is raising a whole new generation of entitled brats. That makes me sad.
 
I don't think that anyone is trying to twist wording. People are trying to get target to stick to the wording they have used for years. Also, people are angry that target used false advertising to get them into the store on black friday to spend money.

Look at the original black friday ad that target ran. It advertises, come into the store on black friday and spend $75 and receive a 20% coupon to use on ANY single purchase. No mention of any exclusions was placed in the ad
.
Target has not in the past classified those cards as gift cards in promotions. For years, they have excluded gift cards and allowed what target classifies as "entertainment cards". Yes they are gift cards for the company that they are issued for, but not to target, for target only target gift cards are gift cards. If for the last 5+ years target had included those cards when it has used the phrase "gift card" then I agree that they shouldn't be excluded, but Target chose to separate them into another category, so long time target shoppers, familiar with target practices put them in another category as well.

Target also knows they don't classify them as gift cards, otherwise why would they also specifically exclude iTunes entertainment cards. IF they wanted to exclude all gift cards, those should also be covered in the blanket language "gift card", no need to mention them specifically.

Why has it become so wrong to expect good customer service? At best target's ad was misleading, but seems to be a deliberate deception to induce shoppers in on a busy shopping day when there were so many better options on places to shop. Why shouldn't shoppers spending their hard earned money expect honesty and consistent language and practices from a multi-billion $ retailer. Surely they have the resources to know what the classify as a gift card and when.
Those of us who expect Target to honor their ad are not idiots, we know the cards are Disney Giftcards, sold on a rack labeled Gift Cards. But we also know that the ad said come in spend money and you will get a certificate for 20% off one purchase, that for 5 years Target has not included Disney Gift Cards when it has used No gift Card. And that practice has not changed as they have at least two other active promotions that use that language and that they honor the disney cards with.
 
My friend is a manager at Target. I asked her about this, and she gave some information.
There is a possibility of the transactions that were wrongly discounted being voided when reviewed by headquarters. This means they will deactivate the value of the giftcards, and refund the money.
The managers overriding will be flagged, and loss prevention will likely interview them. Certain amount of overriding can lead to internal investigations, and possibly having them being fired or punished.
It also effects ALL the employees, because they will have to cut hours to make up for the loss of profits.
 
I don't think that anyone is trying to twist wording. People are trying to get target to stick to the wording they have used for years. Also, people are angry that target used false advertising to get them into the store on black friday to spend money. Look at the original black friday ad that target ran. It advertises, come into the store on black friday and spend $75 and receive a 20% coupon to use on ANY single purchase. No mention of any exclusions was placed in the ad . Target has not in the past classified those cards as gift cards in promotions. For years, they have excluded gift cards and allowed what target classifies as "entertainment cards". Yes they are gift cards for the company that they are issued for, but not to target, for target only target gift cards are gift cards. If for the last 5+ years target had included those cards when it has used the phrase "gift card" then I agree that they shouldn't be excluded, but Target chose to separate them into another category, so long time target shoppers, familiar with target practices put them in another category as well. Target also knows they don't classify them as gift cards, otherwise why would they also specifically exclude iTunes entertainment cards. IF they wanted to exclude all gift cards, those should also be covered in the blanket language "gift card", no need to mention them specifically. Why has it become so wrong to expect good customer service? At best target's ad was misleading, but seems to be a deliberate deception to induce shoppers in on a busy shopping day when there were so many better options on places to shop. Why shouldn't shoppers spending their hard earned money expect honesty and consistent language and practices from a multi-billion $ retailer. Surely they have the resources to know what the classify as a gift card and when. Those of us who expect Target to honor their ad are not idiots, we know the cards are Disney Giftcards, sold on a rack labeled Gift Cards. But we also know that the ad said come in spend money and you will get a certificate for 20% off one purchase, that for 5 years Target has not included Disney Gift Cards when it has used No gift Card. And that practice has not changed as they have at least two other active promotions that use that language and that they honor the disney cards with.
What are the two active promotions that use that language and still include Disney GCs?
 
(I tried quoting with mightytexplorers said but it would not do it for some reason! So just pretend that I am agreeing with what they said)

I agree with this. How many people out there actually know that Target classifies their Disney cards/iTunes cards (and whatever else) as Entertainment Cards? I only knew because of these boards. Not a whole lot of people out there know that or even understand it. We understand the language because we analyze, scrutinize and decipher the wording on these boards. I don't think it's unfair to use those same terms in asking for the discount at all.

Again - if someone out there is going crazy and demanding the discount, screaming and yelling, causing a scene&clearly that is inappropriate. In our case, my husband did what one of the PP's said they would do if they had even thought about trying&he asked before he even picked up the cards. All he said was, "I know these cards are entertainment cards and that we've been able to use our red card on these purchases in the past. Will this coupon also apply to them? I just want to make sure I have it verified before I get what I need." The manager responded that it would absolutely work and that the cashier just needed to call him over when he was ready. That was it.

I don't know if people have been going crazy at all. And I think there are definitely people out there who feel entitled to things. I see it all of the time. I just don't know if that's the case in this instance. I think people were hoping the discount would work and for some, it did. I certainly do not feel entitled to anything. I work my booty off for what I have.

Anyway, I can see both sides - my entire point EVER was that I'm not entirely sure that there have been massive scenes caused, or that people will be fired or discounts taken away. It hasn't even been 24 hours and some people are acting like the world has ended because some people were successful getting the discount.

Not harping on anyone, just giving my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.











Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE







New Posts





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top