You have summed up my feelings very well. Great post. This is exactly how I feel. Everyone is walking on egg shells and the ones who didn't were banned. Things HAVE settled a bit but handing out tags like Halloween candy also isn't going to fill the void.
Well in a lot of cases the people banned weren't told why, no warnings, no points, nothing. People keep citing the poster who was banned WHILE they were on vacation. What did they do when they weren't even using their computer???
I want an explanation because Alex promised me one. He came here and started a thread saying that they would explain things. Frankly, without that thread I wouldn't have had any clue that any drama was happening. That thread implied that the missing posters were involved in some kind of legal action by The Dis. That was very worrisome to me. Now WMKathy has since clarified those statements but when you hear (from Alex) that now banned posters are being contacted by the Dis corporate lawyers and no one can tell you why, it tends to get people a bit worked up.
I'd also like the webmasters to speak out because this isn't the 1st time I've seen this happen here. People have been banned en mass before and it always seems to reek of cronyism. The teachers pets are safe while committing the same infractions the rebels were banned for.
I hold no ill will toward the WMs or Alex or Pete - I've never gotten any points or warnings. But like others I'm just sad and frustrated. The Dis is one of my favorite places and right now the fun has been sucked out of this place. I have every confidence that things will stabilize but I also don't think the events of the last week should be swept under the rug.