Anyone live in Manhattan? Can't imagine never driving anywhere in town!

If you read my OP again, you see I asked if it was just nearby small grocery stores (which now I know are called bodegas) or if you had large store downtown. My experience with small neighborhood grocers has been to just find the basics as there is not room for all the selections a large grocer has. I just wondered without a car if you wanted to get a week's worth of groceries, how you went about it. You are right in thinking I know nothing about the city because I do not. That is why I was asking the question. I too appreciate all of you that have given me insight into your lifestyle. Like one other poster suggested, my only images are what I have seen on TV. I certainly did not intend to start a debate on whether life in NYC was any better or worse than anywhere else.

Now, that all being said, can we move on to suggestions as where to stay for a visit that would be easy access to Rockefeller Plaza and experience all the touristy things. I know there are lots of hotels there, but wondered if there is one that is the best selection over others. Any info is appreciated.
 
Now, that all being said, can we move on to suggestions as where to stay for a visit that would be easy access to Rockefeller Plaza and experience all the touristy things. I know there are lots of hotels there, but wondered if there is one that is the best selection over others. Any info is appreciated.

I'd love to have that information too. Another poster said that her vacation in NYC cost 4 times more than the same amount of time at WDW :eek: :scared1:

That makes me think that I may never get to go there, even for a week :guilty:

ETA: one more (probably very stupid) question. Are there any hotels from which you could get to see the Thanksgiving Macy's parade from a window inside the hotel?
 
A Bodega is a store. You won't see them in tourist areas, but they are on almost every corner of many(not all) residential areas.

bodega3.jpg



bodega-paul-small.jpg

It's interesting - we have those here (okay, 8 miles from NYC), and we call them coffee shops (but they are exactly the same).
 
I moved from DC to NYC and it's much easier to get around in NY. In my area, I have 2 grocery stores within 1-2 blocks of my apartment (a big Gristedes and a Dagostinos), fresh direct just dropped off a big load of heavier things the other day with free delivery, many bodegas nearby, and bf and I even went to the Kmart by Astor place to get some random odds and ends. In DC, I had to walk 8 blocks to the nearest grocery store. I do miss driving to target, but things really are convenient here.
 

I lived in NYC for 5 years and loved it. I felt like I lived in a huge mall. I did not need a car at all and mostly walked or took the subway.

I now live just outside of the city in NJ. Moved here for work. It is a lot easier to have a car living here, but many people in the neighborhood don't have one.
 
I heard Matt Lauer say last night on Leno that nobody drives in New York City. I was thinking about it and can't imagine life dependent on cabs & buses all the time. I guess I may have the wrong image in my mind, but is there no large grocery store nearby? I mean if you discover you are out of something and want to go to the grocery, do you have to get a cab and is there just small nearby neighborhood stores? Wow, life without a drive to Walmart at least once a week would be strange!

You have no idea what you are missing. First of all the great thing about not having a Walmart?? Unique and individual items. Not the same crap from China that every one in America has.

I was born and raised in upper Manhattan. We have wonderful stores that actually have fresh items from all around the globe. Do I need a 50 gallon drum of ketchup for $7.99. No thank you. give me my wonderful Italian food market with home made pasta, my jewish Deli that make a rye sandwich to die for. Give me my soul food market on the corner. Give me my local bodega where people actually talk to you, and the line is not 20 deep.
You mean you actually like spending your entire Saturday at Walmart because the place is packed with people and it takes you 40 minutes to get through the line?

I moved out of the city and hate it. I hate going to the mall where every store is exactly alike. I mean really, how many gaps do you really need. In south Jersey in order to get Milk, you have to get in your car and drive. Gimme a break. I hate that Pizza hut is considered "authentic" pizza or the definition of fine dining is Olive garden.
 
that is why I asked. Sounds great, but I also like the rural life. Guess the best of both worlds would be retired and staying a few months here, a few months in NYC and a few months at Disney!!

If you have read my previous post, can you recommend a nice hotel?
 
that is why I asked. Sounds great, but I also like the rural life. Guess the best of both worlds would be retired and staying a few months here, a few months in NYC and a few months at Disney!!

If you have read my previous post, can you recommend a nice hotel?

I like the Belvedere Hotel. It's not one of the big hotels but that's what I like about it. It's on West 48th street, which means it's within walking distance of times square and very very easy to get a cab uptown or down.

http://belvederehotelnyc.com/

While NYC in the winter is very pretty, my favorite time is in the late spring and summer. Lots of free things to do then.

Go and expore!!
 
Balducci's. I miss food shopping there. Everything is so delicious there.
I had heard that they closed (since now when I go in I am not food shopping;)!) but then I heard that they were still open. Anyone?
 
I checked the website and the Belvedere looks really nice and the rate is great for when we are thinking of going. I had looked at the Rockefeller Center Hotel, but this is less.
 
I lived in Manhattan for 4 years and I loved it. I work in Manhattan, and I wish I still lived there. I'm in Brooklyn now, and I like it, but don't love it. I can't afford Manhattan anymore, and with a family, I need a lot of space. My DH hates Manhattan, and would never move there.
 
I like the Belvedere Hotel. It's not one of the big hotels but that's what I like about it. It's on West 48th street, which means it's within walking distance of times square and very very easy to get a cab uptown or down.

http://belvederehotelnyc.com/

This hotel is fabulous, it's where we stayed the last time we were in the city! :thumbsup2


Someone posted mention of school(s) in the city. Oddly enough, from our window of this hotel, I'd watch kids walk to the school across the street. I wondered if it was a private school, public, what the grade levels were, etc.

I envied those kids, knowing their school atmosphere was a heck of a lot more exciting than the school I attended!
 
We will be the classic tourist with our sign at the Today show and wondered how far a walk it would be?
 
I live in Queens, and I don't have a car and haven't driven since college. I'm sure this is going to sound Third World, but this is how I grocery shop.

Heavy Items (kitty litter mostly) -- FreshDirect. You order on the internet and they deliver. Their prices are high, but they are very efficient with deliveries. You can select a 2 hour time frame and they are very prompt. Also, Peapod just started delivering in my neighborhood. They are a little cheaper. Kitty Litter is my luxury item, I refuse to drag home 14 pound bags by myself.

As for groceries, I have a rolling tote bag and I take the bus to Stop and Shop. It's about a 1/2 hour ride, and I can usually make it home before my frozen stuff defrosts. The smaller grocery stores in my neighborhood are overpriced, so I'd rather make the trip to Stop and Shop. I save alot of money. Also, Trader Joe's is along the same bus route.

I admit, I am too cheap to use taxis, so I rely on the bus. I use taxis for big items or pay for delivery. All in all, it is still cheaper than owning a car, paying for parking, insurance and then having the car "dinged" by other drivers. I live off of Queens Boulevard, aka the Boulevard of Death (yep, that's what they call it).

Sometimes it's a pain, but I've lived in NYC for 25 years, so I've gotten used to it.
 
BC, not sure how many people you are traveling with, but Hotwire and Priceline have good deals on 4 star hotels in Manhattan.
Hotwire has Midtown Central and that's where you'll find the rock.
I just put in random dates and found 4*'s going for $219, regularly $350.
You can't go wrong choosing a 3.5-4 star hotel in any of those Manhattan areas.
 
OP, I live near NYC. You couldn't pay DH or I to drive in NYC! Even riding in a cab is a little scary, lol! With buses and the subway, you really don't need a car in NYC. Or the ridiculous amount of $ it costs to store it. I personally couldn't imagine NOT going to the grocery store or any kind of shopping and not loading up the trunk. I mean, how do you shop for a large family if you have to carry all the bags on the subway, up the stairs, around the block and to your walk up apartment? :scared1: But, that's just me. As someone else noted, nobody has room for Costco stuff. I personally love my "Costco Closet", lol. In NYC, there is a store on every block, so I imagine buying groceries in small amounts is quite convenient. NYC really is one in a million. :thumbsup2
 
I appreciate the info.

The more I hear about the City, the more I want to go. It sounds like a great place. Maybe I would save money if I didn't have anywhere to put all the stuff I bring home! Not to mention, I could not carry all the bags I get at one time from the grocery in addition to stops at Walmart, Kohl's and the mall on a subway.

I live near the Intracoastal Waterway here in North Carolina, but worked many years downtown in our city. From what I hear, that is as close as I imagine the lifestyle there in NYC is. There is constant bus service downtown and corner stores just as you all describe.
 
We will be the classic tourist with our sign at the Today show and wondered how far a walk it would be?

Everything is very close to the Belvedere!
Rockefeller Center/Plaza, Broadway, Madison Ave,. high end stores(there's shopping everywhere) were within several blocks of the hotel.

We walked to The Plaza(my next stay will be here ;)), then crossed the street for a carriage ride through Central Park.

It was cold the last time we went to the city but we dressed appropriately. I wore a long, wool coat, scarf, gloves and fur ear muffs.

There is opportunity to warm up often throughout the day. Popping into stores, restaurants, coffee shops, museums, etc., will afford you plenty of warmth when needed.

Make sure to go into St. Patrick's Cathedral, it's breathtaking!
 
And then there is the flip side. I lived in NYC for quite a few years after college, and I absolutely LOVED my time there. I think it is the best, most exciting city and the entire world, and I am so grateful for the time I spent there. I also think New Yorkers are the BEST. Seriously, I loved living there. However, I used to get some very interesting questions about what it was like growing up and living in Louisiana. No, I did not have alligators in my backyard. Yes, we have regular mail delivery. Yes, most people (children) there do know how to read. Yes, these were answers to questions I was asked.

Oh, but you forgot one: "What's it like going everywhere in a boat?" For some reason, many New Yorkers I met when I spent time there as a kid and young adult had a persistant belief that all of Louisiana was swampland -- they didn't think that we had roads or cars. I think that they were picturing a rural sort of Venice :confused3

I grew up in S. Louisiana and regularly spent time in NYC until I finished college, because 3 of my mother's siblings lived there -- mostly in Queens, in the Ditmars area of Astoria. I used to go and stay with them over school vacations. My aunts were private-duty nurses who worked the upper West Side, so I got to experience a really fascinating split in terms of the way that the city works. (And yes, I know that to locals, only Manhattan really counts as "the City.") I haven't spent a lot of time there in recent years because I no longer have family there; that generation have all passed away now.

My aunts' apartment in Ditmars was a second-story walkup in a building that had 20 apartments; five floors with 4 flats on each one. It had a nice-sized backyard, actually, and the younger children in the building often played there, as it was courtyard-shaped, and their parents could watch them from the inside-facing windows. There was also room to play on the roof, which had a parapet about waist-high. I used to babysit sometimes when I was in town, though as I got older I often was reduced to pantomime when I did it -- that neighborhood was Irish in the old days, then Greek, but in the 80's had begun to be increasingly hispanic and asian, so the kids or their parents often were not yet fluent in English. My aunts had a one-bedroom with a good-sized bathroom, a large walk-in closet, and a large living room. Their kitchen was simply one side of the living room -- it lived behind a panel of folding doors. They shared the space easily because it was rare for both of them to be home overnight at the same time.

My uncle lived down the block on the same street. He and his wife lived in a three-story row house with a small backyard that had a single-car garage on the alley. He had a car, and used to do grocery or hardware runs in the LI suburbs once every couple of weeks, because he was a cheap sort, and had room in the basement to store bulk packages. However, the neighborhood did have a full-size supermarket, which I believe has now been sold and has become a large Asian grocer. My uncle's house had a full basement and three bedrooms. His wife's nephews had kids my age, so I knew all about their schools and met their friends. Very normal bunch for the most part, but they were the ones who always assumed that I lived in a swamp. I still got those same bizarre questions about Louisiana from their friends when we were in our twenties, when the girl closest to my age was a student at Hunter.

Because of the work that they did, my aunts also sometimes had live-in accomodations in the homes of their clients; their VERY wealthy clients. I would go and visit sometimes to have coffee during the day if one of them was living in -- it made a convenient pitstop location when I was hanging out in Manhattan. Many times those "apartments" consisted of two full floors of a large apartment building, with a separate entrance for the staff quarters. It wasn't unheard of for the family to occupy well over 3000 sq. feet, which was MUCH larger than my house in Louisiana. There was very often a large terrace somewhere on the premises, and if it faced in the proper direction it might even have had grass. (Naturally, I only got to peek at the family quarters if I was helping out with changing a bed or something, or serving at a party -- the aunts used to get me those gigs if I was in town over the holidays.)

While most New Yorkers don't own cars, many of them do know how to drive, and often will rent cars if they need them for a day or two. Renting when you need one is a much more cost-effective way to deal with a car in a major city.
 
I grew up in Queens and went to HS in Manhattan. I did not have a drivers license until I was 25 and moved to MA to live with my now DH. I miss NYC a lot and Boston/NH but hate the winters. I would be a snow bird in a heartbeat if we had the money! The subway is wonderful!!!
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top Bottom