Anybody get grief over only having one child? (Inspired by cats7494)

Originally posted by TinaCasa

What is really rude about people asking when you are going to have another one is they have no idea if the person they are asking has been trying unsuccessfully.

Exactly!!

My DS is 6 now and the op's question does come less these days but when it does come I say ....... OH, he's not an only child he has two siblings, they are in heaven.

that usually settles them down a bit and hopefully makes them think twice before asking someone else.
 
it is rude to question it
I am an only child not be choice
my mother had infertiility and lost one early on
I do think you lose something being and only
it's kinda like being the third wheel
my parents love me dearly and I was raised in a good and stable enviromentdde
I just wish I had been able to have a sibling
I did not want to have an only

after DD1 I had some fertility issues also
took 2 years to get pregnant and had a miscarriage
we tried for another 2 years with no luck
so when DD was 7 I finally resigned myself to the fact that she would be an only
well low and behold miracle baby DD#2 was born in 2003 when DD#1 was 8 years old

even though they are 9 and 1 years old they love each other so much I couldn't imagine them not having each other
I am so glad that I have them both
good luck
 
I think that no matter what your situation is, there will be someone that questions it. I get the shock when people hear all 3 of my kids were born within 33 months (esp when I had a 3 mo old, a 20 month old and a 3 yr old). Some people like close sibs. Some people cannot imagine having 2 "babies" at the same time. Others cannot imagine getting one child into school and choosing to start again. Everyone has their reasons, with a few surprises thrown in.

The questions don't really bother me as long as their out of curiosity and not rudeness. I don't mind explaing why I choose to have my children so close together and I'm genuinely interested in why people made their choices (be in having an only child or 6 kids or sibs widely spaced).

I just had a converstaion with a friend of mine about her family. Her oldest is adopted from China. Then she had 2 biological children. I had been interested for a while as to what brought on that decision. I didn't run right up and ask but after we developed a comfortable friendship..and with the children not around..I asked. Of course I told her that I understood if she didn't feel it was something she wanted to dsicuss. I have found, through my own experiences with my children, that if something is asked out of genuine caring, it is usually met with an open and eager response.

Jess
 
While I have two children (with a 3rd on its way) I am an only child. I get asked all the time, "Why didn't your parents want more?" And I'm sure my parents have been asked that question 1,000 times. It gets annoying. I had a fabulous childhood, lots of friends, my parents took good care of me yet did not spoil me rotten. The ONLY times I wish I had a brother or sister are these times in my adult life- I wish my kids had an aunt or uncle to play with, or cousins to grow up with....or that I could have a bro or sis to lean on when mom and dad pass on. But I never really wished for a bro or sis growing up. My DH has one brother and he has some learning disabilities and his wife is half baked....they have TRIPLETS (they're 5) so my kids do have cousins, but it is nothing less of frantic pandemonium when we visit with them.
 

While I have two children (with a 3rd on its way) I am an only child. I get asked all the time, "Why didn't your parents want more?" And I'm sure my parents have been asked that question 1,000 times. It gets annoying. I had a fabulous childhood, lots of friends, my parents took good care of me yet did not spoil me rotten. The ONLY times I wish I had a brother or sister are these times in my adult life- I wish my kids had an aunt or uncle to play with, or cousins to grow up with....or that I could have a bro or sis to lean on when mom and dad pass on. But I never really wished for a bro or sis growing up. My DH has one brother and he has some learning disabilities and his wife is half baked....they have TRIPLETS (they're 5) so my kids do have cousins, but it is nothing less of frantic pandemonium when we visit with them.

I must add that my dear dad says to people when they ask him about me being an only, "Well, we started out with perfection. How could we improve on that?" Awww....
 
No kids of my own yet, but I do want at least two, as I want my kids to have siblings. I think having sibs is an important part of growing up.

But I'd never judge anyone who chooses to have only one child! I don't think it makes them bad people by any means! Just because it's what I want doesn't mean it "works" for everyone else! If I did ask "are you having any more" to someone (and I only would if they were a close friend that I know wouldn't mind me asking), and they said "no", I'd just say "that's nice, you can concentrate all your love on him/her." I certainly wouldn't bug them about it!

Some people are just rude!
 
Lots of great responses....families need to do what works best for them. When I was younger I wanted 4 children. But then I got married at 27...FINALLY convinced DH to have a child and had DS when I was 35. (We wanted to work and save $$ and buy a house and all that before we had a child...) After some secondary infertility problems I had DD at 39. ALMOST went for a third but these two keep me busy. DS is now 9 and recently diagnosed with Aspergers so that is a constant thing...DD is 5 and is a great help to her big brother. She just adores him and she actually makes him braver since he wants to do the things she does.

The family problem we have is that DH's brother and sister both only have one child - we are the only ones with two. When we all get together they don't always understand about the sibling rivalry and all that goes with that. And since their kids are young and onlies they aren't always good with the sharing - not knocking ALL onlies, just saying these cousins! :)

DD also doesn't get as much attention as her brother. With his special needs we have to take extra time with him. DD is smart and believes that any, even bad attention is something so she acts up...we are working on that..:rolleyes:

Jill
 
/
My WONDERFUL ONLY son is 22 now, and STILL get the --IS HE YOUR ONLY ONE???? Most times I just say YEP,,THE PERFECT "ONE"..but at other times I tell them,,, Well, I really have 5, he is the only one that survived (I miscarried 3 times and had a still born little girl, before my son came to us) ...THAT CAN REALLY SHUT THEM UP FAST,,,,may be a bit mean,,but hey,,whats it to them,,,if they REALLY want to know,,then ok NOW THEY KNOW,,,,
sometimes people have nothing better to do then judge others!!!!


Tink
 
I get asked constantly when DH and I are going to have our first baby and then reminded the clock is ticking. Ummmm....yeah, well, first, I had uterine cancer some years back and had a radical hysterectomy so not possible. I feel this is too personal for some vague aquaintance to even ask let alone me have to explain my very personal reasons for not having one. Then of course, adoption is brought up. At one time I desperately wanted children. I was crushed to find out I'd never be able to have them if I wanted to live. Now that I'm 40, we are just past that stage of wanting little ones. We have a good life and we can pick up on a moments notice to do whatever we want. Besides, we have his 17 yr old dd from his first marriage. I don't feel anymore like I've missed out on anything. And even if I did it's no ones business. Doncha HATE strangers who think they have a right to know all your personal business?
 
I have several thoughts.

I always wanted more than one child, so did DH. We had our two within 12 months, they are now 3 and 4. Sibling rivalry is a very difficult thing to deal with. Sometimes I spend more of my time with them refereeing their squabbles than playing with them and spending quality time with them. I wouldn't change it for the world, but I find myself wondering if I would be a better parent to only one child. I can definitely see why someone would really enjoy having only one child.

It's no one's business if you want to have no children or twenty. I don't think people mean to be rude when they ask about your plans. It is rude, but I think they are just trying to start a conversation. I have caught myself asking, before I had a lot of trouble conceiving, now I keep my mouth shut except with very close friends.

Truthfully, I have wondered why some people choose not to have children. Not that it is any of my business, mind you, and not that there is anything wrong with that. My father and mother were divorced several years ago and my father married a much younger woman (3 years older than me). My dad has had a vascectomy and has made it very clear that he doesn't want to have any children. She understands this completely and agrees, but I often wonder how she came to the decision that in order to spend the rest of her life with the person she loves, she would have to give up having children.

I guess we would have been in the same boat if I was not able to conceive. I felt a lot of guilt when we were trying that I would keep DH from becoming a father.

Sorry for my random thoughts and rambling. This is such an interesting subject.

Denae
 
Originally posted by mickeyboat

Truthfully, I have wondered why some people choose not to have children. Not that it is any of my business, mind you, and not that there is anything wrong with that. My father and mother were divorced several years ago and my father married a much younger woman (3 years older than me). My dad has had a vascectomy and has made it very clear that he doesn't want to have any children. She understands this completely and agrees, but I often wonder how she came to the decision that in order to spend the rest of her life with the person she loves, she would have to give up having children.

Denae

DH and I will be married 8 years in October. We will be together 10 years in January 05. :) We have not ruled out children entirely yet, but we have been leaing towards a child-free life. Some of our reasons are:

-DH's parents lost a child at 12-she was severely retarded. What a huge strain on them!
-My parents lost a baby at 1 month old from heart complications.
-There is no one I would feel comfortable leaving my children with if we died.
-Raising a child takes a lot of money and we would like to retire early.
-It is a crap shoot. We know some wonderful parents that have awful children.
-I feel it is THE biggest responsibility in the world and take it VERY seriously.
-The state of the world/environment today.
-I have a bad temper when pushed.
-I would not want to leave my children in day care but I would not want to be the only one raising them day to day. If we were millionares and could both work part time that would be ideal.
-Infant years (sleep deprevation, poopy diapers, screaming) and teen years (sleep deprevation, fights/arguments, driving, worry...)
-Loss of self and freedom.
-Outside influences can ruin them and all of your hard work (other children, tv, drugs, music..)

Just some of our reasons for holding off right now. We do like children a lot. I was a 3-6yr. old teacher (Montessori) and DH tutors and is great with kids.
 
I have one kid and don't plan on any others. I can afford to take one on vacations every year, I can afford college for one...if I had another that would limit what we were able to do in life.
 
It is so funny that this thread came up because we are starting to get this question again. DD is 4 and when she was 2 yo, we would get asked all the time :rolleyes: Then it tapered off, now she is getting closer to school age and people are starting up again.

The truth is, she has a sibling, a twin I lost at about 10 weeks. Then I spent the rest of the pg scared and sick. Do that again? No thanks. DD has 12 cousins who love her, spoil her and dote on her. She will have a great many opportunities in life because we can afford them fairly easily with only one child (I am already planning her first European trip in a couple of years).

Most of the time, I just smile vaguely or say, when you have achieved perfection, there's no need to try again! :p
 
Lindsey is a one and only and we wouldn't have it any other way. As long as I can remember, I've always said I wanted one little girl, I got what I wanted and will not test fate again. She is the light of my life and the best thing that ever happened to me but....I was sicker than a dog pregnant with her for 16 weeks straight, don't want to do the bottle and diaper thing again and don't want to have to take away from her to give to another. Call me selfish or whatever else but I usually say to the questioning person, why don't you have baby and pay for everything for me? That usually ends the conversation.
 
As an only child, I've often been asked, "don't you miss having any brothers or sisters?" and my reply is, how can I miss something I've never had:D

I gained a large family through marriage, all the aunts/uncles/inlaws/outlaws /SIL/BIL/nieces/nephews and what have you to keep me full of family for years to come.::yes::
 
Originally posted by Tigger&Tink
My WONDERFUL ONLY son is 22 now, and STILL get the --IS HE YOUR ONLY ONE???? Most times I just say YEP,,THE PERFECT "ONE"..but at other times I tell them,,, Well, I really have 5, he is the only one that survived (I miscarried 3 times and had a still born little girl, before my son came to us) ...THAT CAN REALLY SHUT THEM UP FAST,,,,may be a bit mean,,but hey,,whats it to them,,,if they REALLY want to know,,then ok NOW THEY KNOW,,,,

Personally, I would never bring up my miscarriage to make someone feel bad no matter how rude they were. I am sorry for your loss.
 
Originally posted by suzannews
Lindsey is a one and only and we wouldn't have it any other way. As long as I can remember, I've always said I wanted one little girl, I got what I wanted and will not test fate again. She is the light of my life and the best thing that ever happened to me but....I was sicker than a dog pregnant with her for 16 weeks straight, don't want to do the bottle and diaper thing again and don't want to have to take away from her to give to another. Call me selfish or whatever else but I usually say to the questioning person, why don't you have baby and pay for everything for me? That usually ends the conversation.

How spooky - I could have written this post myself! :eek:

My DH and I have been together for nearly 20 years - for the first 10 years or so, we said we didn't want kids but then at the age of 30 the old biological clock started ticking and we decided to 'go for it'! Sadly it wasn't going to be that easy - after 3 years of trying (we didn't WANT to see Dr's and things - we said if it happens it happens, if not then so be it!) I wanted to find out if there was something 'simple' wrong - I had other symptoms so was tested for Polycystic Ovary Syndrome - and found that I had a severe case. We decided to go to see a fertility specialist and the first appointment with him came through in November 1999 - we had to cancel this as we were in Florida! The next appointment came through for Dec 23rd - we cancelled this as it was just too close to Christmas and we didn't want to spend the time thinking about our infertility! The next appointment came through for the beginning of Feb (on a Wed) - the Friday before, I found the taste of Coffee REALLY horrid and my co-worker said 'you're not pregnant are you?'

I checked my calendar to find I was 5 days late! Did the test and BINGO! WE went to see the specialist anyway who was great throughout the pregnancy! During my pregnancy I had several 'bleeds' and severe sciatica - as well as absolute TERROR that I would lose the baby and never have another chance! When my DD was born in Sept 2000 I was SOOOO relieved that she was finally here and safe - as well as surprised as I 'thought' she was a boy all through the pregnancy!!!!! :eek:

Back to OP - I've told this story because it illustrates how irritating and potetially infuriating it is to be asked when I'm having another! Or even worse - as happened outside my DD(4)'s nursery school the other day - to be told its's 'awful' to only have one! :mad: I refuse to explain myself to strangers (except those on the DIS of course! ;) ) and always say - "All I ever wanted was a little angel - now I've got her, why on earth would I want another!!!!!"

Just one more point - my DD has three cousins - my sister's daughter is 14 and they absolutly adore one another DNeice is an only child too and she calls Gemma her little sister! MY DSIL's kids are 7 and 9 (one of each) - they too get on great with Gem but can't even bear to be in the same ROOM as one another!!!! look at them and think - thank goodness I've only go the one - it would drive my nuts to have to put up with the squabbling and fighting all the time - it's bad enough when I babysit!!!!!! :rolleyes:
 
I used to, but now that my son is an older teen I no longer do.

I had a difficult pregnancy, and didn't want to go through it again, plus with my sons disabilities, I had my hands full with one, thank you.

Now I'm kind of glad. I'm in my early 40's and am a semi-empty nester. I don't have many years of college tuition ahead of me. I was able to give my son a lot of things both time-wise and financially that I wouldn't have been able to do if I had more children.

Anne
 
People ask me/us all the time and DS is only 12 mos. old! They were asking way before that though too.

Heck, even before we got married, both our parents wanted us to have a baby. Since we were married over 3 years once we had DS - everyone kept saying to us or people around us, how we were not having kids. Huh?:confused: Why, if you don't have a baby right away after getting married, does that mean you won't have kids at all? Some people! We would jokingly tell people we didn't want kids, we like going to Disney too much, etc. We knew all along we'd do it, eventually.

That said, I'd be happy with just DS. DH wants another though. :rolleyes: I had a very diffcult pregnancy & delivery with DS and don't want to go through that EVER again. That said, IF I had another, it's a definate c-section for me which would make life much easier. So, having another is still up in the air right now. I don't think we get questioned so much by family about another baby since they were there and saw first-hand exactly what all I went through last year. :eek: But, friends and acquaintances ask alot about a sibling for DS. :rolleyes:

People can be so incredibly rude sometimes! I would never have the nerve to ask a co-worker or someone not in my immediate family such personal questions.
 
Originally posted by mickeyboat

Truthfully, I have wondered why some people choose not to have children. Not that it is any of my business, mind you, and not that there is anything wrong with that. My father and mother were divorced several years ago and my father married a much younger woman (3 years older than me). My dad has had a vascectomy and has made it very clear that he doesn't want to have any children. She understands this completely and agrees, but I often wonder how she came to the decision that in order to spend the rest of her life with the person she loves, she would have to give up having children.

Denae

I am the same way with my BF. (We have no plans on getting married ;that opens up another bunch of nosy, obnoxious questions from people too, whom I usually respond to by saying we are not religious, don't want to be legally bound to each other, I've already been through an ugly divorce).

I would like to have a child, but he refuses and so I know it's either him or have a kid with someone else.

I don't want to be with someone else. So that pretty much means, no children for me.

And no, he will not change his mind about this ever and has made it quite clear to me that as happy as he is with me, if I decide I want a child, he leaves the picture and I will have to find someone else to have the child with. He is 32.

His primary reason is money and he does not want to alter his lifestyle at all for a child. He has actually said, it's not even the young kids, he loves babies and small children but he knows he would not have the tolerance and patience to deal with a teenager.

We BOTH love other peoples kids. I HATE IT when people assume that because we are not having kids that we must hate kids. That is the farthest thing from the truth. We oooh and ahh at every cute baby we see, we spend lots of time with our neices and nephews.

MY primary reason for not having children is money. I don't have the finances now to raise a child to my standards. If I had a child now, we would be living a very tight life, unable to have nice things or travel and we would be getting by on the bare minimums.

That is just not how I want to raise a child. Perhaps it is because of my upbringing that I have high standards for how I'd want my kids to live. I grew up in affluence, I was lucky enough to have wealthy parents who gave us everything.

But I am not my parents.

I know you don't HAVE to have a lot of money to have a happy child, but I do not want to raise a child in poverty. I know wealthy people can suddenly have something come up and lose all their money , but that is different than knowingly having a child that you KNOW will go without a lot because you don't make enough.
 

PixFuture Display Ad Tag




New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top