American Idol Season 9

[LiLIrishChick63]

Ugh I know. I wanted him to belt out the "I KNOW!", and when it just went like a flatline, I felt cheated out. I wanted a belt, dangit!

i know me too!! i feel like going on youtube to see it done right!!

Caked on makeup looked really bad in HIGH SCHOOL. In the 80s....

 

[StephyDee]

I think we all have our faves, I understand why you like him. I just wish I had a clear favorite but I don't find ANYONE sig-worthy this year....

Well, I feel like these past few years on Idol have (for me) made up for the lack of awesomeness on the show when I watched it. I never watched Season 1, although I wish I did. The first time I actually really liked a contestant was Daughtry in Season 5. but then no one else AT ALL until David Cook in Season 7, and then Kris and Adam in Season 8. From Season 7-on, I have found someone I've liked enough to buy music from consistently. While I like Daughtry, I only have a few songs from him. I'm not a huge fan, but an in-between fan, if that makes sense.

 

[Robinrs]

I only liked Casey with SHOCK Big Mike coming in third behind Crystal.

 

[Pig Pen]

I am very late...I was finishing up Dexter season 4 on the free showtime preview (which was pretty awesome)...so now I am fast forwarding thru the DVR...not listening to Usher nor the judges.

I will let the smileys do my talking:

Siobahn -

Casey -

Mike -

Didi -

Tim -

Andrew -

pizza thrower in the Visa commercial -

Katie -

Lee - (WOW)

GLEE is coming back -

Crystal -

Aaron -

RANKINGS

1. Lee
2. Casey
3. Crystal
4. Mike
5. Katie
6. Andrew
7. Aaron
8. Tim
9. Didi
10. Siobahn

 

[Robinrs]

I am very late...I was finishing up Dexter season 4 on the free showtime preview (which was pretty awesome)...so now I am fast forwarding thru the DVR...not listening to Usher nor the judges.

I will let the smileys do my talking:

Siobahn -

Casey -

Mike -

Didi -

Tim -

Andrew -

pizza thrower in the Visa commercial -

Katie -

Lee - (WOW)

GLEE is coming back -

Crystal -

Aaron -

RANKINGS

1. Lee
2. Casey
3. Crystal
4. Mike
5. Katie
6. Andrew
7. Aaron
8. Tim
9. Didi
10. Siobahn

 

[StephyDee]

My top 3 picks: Lee, Crystal, and....hmmm, I think I'll stick with Casey.

And whataya know? I'm 3/3 in my song choice predictions. They all did pretty well, and I liked them.

Let's hope for an awesome results show tomorrow night! If not, then we'll be here to sulk in our despair....with cookies and cupcakes.

 

[StephyDee]

I am very late...I was finishing up Dexter season 4 on the free showtime preview (which was pretty awesome)...so now I am fast forwarding thru the DVR...not listening to Usher nor the judges.

I will let the smileys do my talking:

Siobahn -

Casey -

Mike -

Didi -

Tim -

Andrew -

pizza thrower in the Visa commercial -

Katie -

Lee - (WOW)

GLEE is coming back -

Crystal -

Aaron -

RANKINGS

1. Lee
2. Casey
3. Crystal
4. Mike
5. Katie
6. Andrew
7. Aaron
8. Tim
9. Didi
10. Siobahn

Good observation, my friend. Let's hope the rankings you have are close enough to/dead on with the real results.

 

[Pig Pen]

.
what is this song? i've never heard it. it sounds like the backround singers are singing more than she is......

You must be a baby! Midnight Train to Georgia brings me back to my middle school years!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

pizza thrower in the Visa commercial -

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

You must be a baby! Midnight Train to Georgia brings me back to my middle school years!

tbh once she got to the chorus i realized the song. but i think it came out a bit before middle school, for me lol!!!

 

[Cogswel_Cogs]

I love that guy, I am supprised he hasn't shown up on a cooking show or something.

 

[charming23]

So I was at my Grandma's tonight watching and here is what I thought.

Sibohan- Yikes! That was all over the place. I did not care for it at all.

Casey- I liked the song and thought it fit his voice. I would like to see him do something with out the guitar to show more versatility.

Mike- I liked it. I liked that he used the guitar this week but I wanted more from him.

Didi- What can I say about Didi, I liked the dress. Everything else not so much.

Tim- I hope he goes this week. He is not improving as much as some of the others.

Andrew- A million times better than last week. I was a little worried when he picked Chris Brown but it turned out very nice.

Katie- It might be just me but I did not like it. She tried to look all angry and mean but it came off as if she had just smelled someone pass gas.

Lee- Nuff said

Crystal- I liked it, not as much as last week's but I liked that she took the chance.

Aaron- After Kris' version last season I was not impressed with this. I liked it but it was forgettable.

 

[TwinsinCA]

Just skipped ahead to watch Lee. Not a fan of the song at all, but he did what he could with it. I love that man's voice.

 

[TwinsinCA]

Final two:


Lee

Crystal

I hope it comes down to these two as well.

 

[ColoradoBuffaloMom]

I may be in the minority but I liked Katie tonight. I haven't been a Crystal fan but she won me over tonight. Didi has got to go. Her constant crying reminds me of Brooke from a few seasons ago only I like Brooke

Tomorrow night could be interesting.

 

[DisneyGirl421]

I'm usually a big Idol fan, but this season has just been blahhh for me. There's really no stand-out. By this time last season, I was already a hardcore Kris fan. But s9? No one yet. I can't even remember names-to-faces really.

To me, tonight's top was Lee, and bottom was Didi.

And Aaron ruined Ain't No Sunshine for me. I immediately had to go and listen to Kris's version during the commerical, lol. Kris owns that song.

 

[TruBlu]

Hope they win!!!!

Yay! They did!

 

[WaltDisney1]

This thread has turned into a "Bash young people who are trying to do something with their lives." Great job folks!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

This thread has turned into a "Bash young people who are trying to do something with their lives." Great job folks!

because bashing must now=having an opinion.....

 

[charming23]

This thread has turned into a "Bash young people who are trying to do something with their lives." Great job folks!

I do not think anyone is "bashing" anyone. We all give our opinions on what works and what does not. Afterall we are the ones who vote.