American Idol Season 9

[Kirby]

I didn't get to tune in until 8:00 last night and haven't read through all the posts. So, how did Siobhan do last night? Did she scream towards the end again?

 

[happygirl]

What was DiDi thing last night. Ryan acted like it was some HUGE deal. I was readiing on the other thread who is dating who?

After tonight Lee is my favortie!!! Go Lee

 

[happygirl]

I didn't get to tune in until 8:00 last night and haven't read through all the posts. So, how did Siobhan do last night? Did she scream towards the end again?

It was horrible, Worse then usual. I thought

 

[FINFAN]

Hi all...watched the recording, I had hopes...Robin, spot on for Casey!
I liked in this order:
Lee
Casey ( but more becasue I love that song than his rendition)
Crystal

felt bad for DiDi as I think she did not want to take advantage of her situation and Ryan was just bulldozing for the sympathy vote. I give her honorable mention for trying to keep it about the singing and for doing the best "I am so ti**ed off at you right now Ryan" face ever.

Don't get the Big Mike thing, Katie...just because you can do the head move does NOT make you Aretha, Aaron...the voice and face just do not match,
Soibhan...the judges are calling the *note* a scream...time to try someting new, Andrew, forgot you were still on the show,Didi...see above, but what was the connection of the outfit and the song? Odd, just Odd. Can we just cut to the top 3 tonight?

 

[mandy200587]

Alex Lambert Update:

http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/03/31/alex-lambert-if-i-can-dream-american-idol/

 

[krcit]

I'm not stirring anything, I've waited long enough to say this because I thought it would change somewhat but it's the same bashing week after week. It's getting pretty old.

Allrighty then.....buh bye!!

 

[ckay87]

This thread has turned into a "Bash young people who are trying to do something with their lives." Great job folks!

Aaahhhh hahahah, that's a funny one!! I just got finished cruising through your Kate Goselin thread. Now THAT topic, my friend, is getting old.

You do know that the very premise of AI is performing in a judged competition? They're not doing charity work here or doing US any favors.

If they suck, they're gonna hear about it. I'm pretty sure they've seen AI before. Haven't you?

 

[FINFAN]

Alex Lambert Update:

http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/03/31/alex-lambert-if-i-can-dream-american-idol/

Thanx Mandy...good for Alex, and to Simon for casting him ( or whatever, getting him on another one of his shows) He looks more confident with the new 'do...I hope this works out for him.

 

[FINFAN]

Alex Lambert Update:

http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/03/31/alex-lambert-if-i-can-dream-american-idol/

Thanx Mandy...good to know he is on his way...love the new look, he should do well!

 

[mandy200587]

Just got word, Danny Gokey is doing LP field during CMA Fest one night. Carrie's already scheduled to play at LP.

 

[lillygator]

This thread has turned into a "Bash young people who are trying to do something with their lives." Great job folks!

It's the same thing in here every friggin week.. and it's the same feeling, "I didn't like it", "that was awful", "OMG she looks terrible in that," "where do these people come from."

Try to evaluate the singers against each other, not in absolute sense.

It is bashing when 10 people sing, and people criticize every single performance. Try to have some sense of musical skill. If Simon liked a performance, I don't get how everyone on this thread can say it was awful.

They offer constructive criticism when necessary. They don't tell every singer that they were just flat out horrible.

I realize you don't have to all like the same thing but what's happened on this thread is just the opposite. Everyone seems to hate every single performance and that is boring!!

I'm not stirring anything, I've waited long enough to say this because I thought it would change somewhat but it's the same bashing week after week. It's getting pretty old.

I have 10 posts because I'm a new member but I've been reading the boards for some time now.

A few people have liked a FEW performance but the great majority on here bash every single performance.

this season is horrible. I do like Lee, Casey and Crystal. Hope Didi goes tonight.

 

[Robinrs]

Alex Lambert Update:

http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/03/31/alex-lambert-if-i-can-dream-american-idol/

Wow! He looks aDORable!! I would've loved seeing what the stylists could've done for him but his new makeover works!

 

[luvmy3]

Wow this thread has gotten more entertaining than watching AI

The only one worth watching was Usher. I found it ironic when Simon mentioned Star Search because I remember Usher when he was a contestant. (maybe Simon knew that). They might as well just end the show now and name Crystal the next AI, she is so out of everyone elses league.

 

[Robinrs]

Wow this thread has gotten more entertaining than watching AI

The only one worth watching was Usher. I found it ironic when Simon mentioned Star Search because I remember Usher when he was a contestant. (maybe Simon knew that). They might as well just end the show now and name Crystal the next AI, she is so out of everyone elses league.

This is how I'll always remember him!

 

[StephyDee]

I put my votes in last night, and now I'm ready for someone other than Lee, Crystal, Casey or Big Mike to go home (but I won't be horribly shocked if Tim gets to stay)...he's got that cute thing going for him...why on earth did he have to be so adorable?....that little jerk.

 

[TruBlu]

PLEASE tell me Usher is performing tonight! Just not his new song. I'm not a fan of that one.

 

[TruBlu]

Wow! He looks aDORable!! I would've loved seeing what the stylists could've done for him but his new makeover works!

I agree. But - did he really need a stylist to tell him to loose the mullet?

 

[Cat0727]

double post.

 

[Cat0727]

This is how I'll always remember him!

He is so adorable there!

 

[DarthKTrava]

Yay! They did!