American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[MELSMICE]

Constantine is going to propose to Kellie????

So what has never happened on the show before??? Anyone care to venture a guess??? I will, I say there will be a tie and both will win tonight!!

I was thinking the same thing. Nothing would surprise me.

 

[Cindy B]

from www.mjsbigblog.com:

This ETonline article hints that there's a big surprise in store tonight:

"...Katharine revealed a few clues! "There's a big surprise that out of all the contestants only me and Taylor know about, so trust us it's pretty big, something that's never happened on the show!"

Nigel Lythgoe also hinted there's be some big surprises tonight on Ryan Seacrest's radio show this morning...



So what has never happened on the show before??? Anyone care to venture a guess??? I will, I say there will be a tie and both will win tonight!!

Welll according to TWOP and Mj's, both the #1 and 2 contestant will get signed by 19E for one year. Technically, they both won recording contracts. That is probably the big suprise.

I guess 19E wanted to do some CYA in case the voting was entirely too close.

 

[ckay87]

from www.mjsbigblog.com:

This ETonline article hints that there's a big surprise in store tonight:

"...Katharine revealed a few clues! "There's a big surprise that out of all the contestants only me and Taylor know about, so trust us it's pretty big, something that's never happened on the show!"

Nigel Lythgoe also hinted there's be some big surprises tonight on Ryan Seacrest's radio show this morning...



So what has never happened on the show before??? Anyone care to venture a guess??? I will, I say there will be a tie and both will win tonight!!

What do you want to do, give me a STROKE????

 

[Sandy22]

I'm going to LMAO if they declare a tie. Shouldn't that be statistically impossible?

 

[lillygator]

wow - wonder what it could be?

 

[lillygator]

there just can't be a tie!!

 

[damo]

Let's put together the clues. Only Taylor and Katharine know. Katharine wearing ugly tops. Permanent smirk on Taylor's face. Braxton/Hicks duet. Biggest surprise ever... never happened before on the show. Hmmmmmm.

 

[lbgraves]

OMG! I just read that blog & scrolled down thru the pictures from last night's show. When I saw the one of Taylor in his purplish jacket...it hit me what it reminded me of. WILLY WONKA!!! Now, I DO like Taylor....that jacket just needed to go back to where ever it came from.

 

[emmabelle]

Welll according to TWOP and Mj's, both the #1 and 2 contestant will get signed by 19E for one year. Technically, they both won recording contracts. That is probably the big suprise.

I agree.

 

[Zippa D Doodah]

Tonight's big surprise...

In a twist ripped straight from the Mission: Impossible movies, upon being declared the winner Taylor will rip off a latex mask and voice modulator, revealing that he is actually Chris.

 

[damo]

Tonight's big surprise...

In a twist ripped straight from the Mission: Impossible movies, upon being declared the winner Taylor will rip off a latex mask and voice modulator, revealing that he is actually Chris.

Haha Good One!!

 

[dturner]

Constantine is going to propose to Kellie????

 

[dturner]

Tonight's big surprise...

In a twist ripped straight from the Mission: Impossible movies, upon being declared the winner Taylor will rip off a latex mask and voice modulator, revealing that he is actually Chris.

That's a good one.

 

[Virgo10]

If it's a tie will the Electoral College get involved?

 

[dturner]

Maybe it is that they will give recording contract to both Katherine and Taylor.

I remember last year when both Carrie and Bo were on stage ready for the announcement they told both of them that they each would get a new car and they both looked surprised like they didn't know that...but why would they tell both Katherine and Taylor BEFORE the show tonight that they are both getting recording contracts..........I bet it's just another surprise performance by someone and nothing earth shattering at all.

 

[tarmand]

Estelle's final review:

http://groups.msn.com/EstellesAmericanIdolJoint/americanidol.msnw?action=get_message&mview=0&ID_Message=13578&LastModified=4675573904988906162

 

[kdibattista]

Does everyone know that American Idol is having a "Live from the Red Carpet" preshow at 7:30pm eastern

Is this being shown live on the west coast as well?

 

[jaimee1024]

I just got the Braxton/Hicks labor pain joke...took me a minute. I have a head cold. Pretty funny.

Them both getting contracts shouldn't be a big surprise since it has already been reported.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

watching live from the red carpet on american idol.com

Pretty cool.

They switch between video interviews with the top 12 and live from read carpet.

They did say Bo Derek is there.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

okay--I think they have interns running this web broadcast. Cool to get a scoop and see as everyone arrives--but the mics are not coming on when they should, camera work is shoddy--no one is ready for anything. It is very silly. I think they used the 2nd place production crew.