American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[SRUAlmn]

Is anyone else really familiar with that Christina Aguilara song like I am? I have a burnt CD that I made and that song is on it and I sing along in my car to it all the time so I know every pitch change, every run, every lyric, etc... I know they are supposed to put their own flair into the song, but I did not think she sounded very good at all. I was really surprised at the judge's compliments. Anyone else?


ETA: I must've been typing when everyone else was posting saying the same thing about Katherine. I bet when Simon watches the show back on TV he will disagree with what he just said.

 

[Sandy22]

So far the only performance I've enjoyed has been from Taylor. And I think his new hair cut takes about 10 years off him.

 

[MeanLaureen]

We are 1/2 way through and I don't want to vote for ANYONE tonight

*GASP*! What happened to the Chris love???

 

[palmtreegirl]

Man, everyone's really bad this week, I don't even feel like writing out reviews.

I really miss Kevin!

 

[Poohbear123]

Go Bucky!

 

[kdibattista]

OMG... I'm soooooo loving Bucky . I love this song!!!!

 

[bicker]

Hmmm... that was a little something different from Katherine. It was also just okay. Hmmm. Hmph.

So Simon says it was the best tonight? Hmmm.... I suppose, but again, that's not saying very much.

 

[Nancy]

Bucky actually had a few good moments...not really liking anyone tonight

 

[Poohbear123]

Bucky NEEDS to sing Country!

 

[palmtreegirl]

Whoo Hooo Go Bucky!!!!

 

[Shugardrawers]

*GASP*! What happened to the Chris love???

Not feeling the Chris love tonight. Probably because that's just not my style of music. Now, Bucky, I'm feeling the love for I don't care what Simon says. Does anyone else think Bucky got his teeth capped? They look a lot straighter and whiter tonight

 

[Poohbear123]

Paris.....not bad, trying to sound more hip but I don't know.....used to her singing blues,

 

[bicker]

Bucky's performance wasn't better than a kareoke performance. Pretty easy to sing. Not impressed.

 

[Sandy22]

Paris certainly "worked it out!" She's quite the little chameleon!

 

[MeanLaureen]

O..M..G. What all those people that are saying that Lisa is forgettable every week.. DH Matt just asked who was left and said, Oh Elliott. I said "And Lisa". Oops. Apparently she went first and I already forgot I saw her.

 

[Nancy]

Paris...that was the best I've seen her since this started. I loved her energy..but I didn't like the hey, hey's and yeahs and whoos during the song. (Never heard Beyonce's version are those in there?)

 

[MeanLaureen]

Not feeling the Chris love tonight. Probably because that's just not my style of music. Now, Bucky, I'm feeling the love for I don't care what Simon says. Does anyone else think Bucky got his teeth capped? They look a lot straighter and whiter tonight

I'm with you. Usually I like Chris but tonight it just sounded like scream scream scream what if scream scream scream what if to me. Guess I'm not a Creed fan - wait, I do like some of their other stuff.. just not a fan of this song then.

 

[bicker]

Paris was pretty good, if you like that kind of music.

 

[palmtreegirl]

What this show needs tonight is Kevin doing Part-time lover!

 

[J.Cooper]

I'm with you Nancy - Katharine sounded a bit off on some of the notes to me. We must be seeing a different show than everyone else

Tonight sucks! I agree with you & Nancy, I don't think Katherine did all that great. She sounded off .

Kellie- not herself. BAD song choice, she can do better
Lisa- BAD song choice. Voice not strong enough for that song.
Ace- Very karoke. He'd be better at modeling or acting?
Mandisa- Strong voice. Wrong song for A.I
Bucky- (kind of boring, he played it safe)
My boyfriend Chris- Agree with Randy, I've seen better from him. Still pretty good!
Taylor- nothing to jump about
Katherine- Didn't like. Seen her do better.
Paris-