My 11 (almost 12)year old niece asked for a perfume making kit, a bath bomb making kit, an instant camera, and clothes from Justice. She also asked for some things for ice skating as she skates competitively, so if the girls are into sports or dance you could look for things like a new soccer ball, hair ties,etc. My other nieces who are 7,8,10 want those finger monkeys that are hard to find this year, craft kits, books, Shopkins, Barbies. It depends on the likes of the girl. My 7yo niece want nothing to do with Barbies and Shopkins while the 8 &9 yo love them.