I've never stayed at Boardwalk, so can't really give it a fair judgement. I have stayed at OKW several times and love it. It is very convenient to be able to pull right up to your building at OKW....esp. when checking in and checking out! I will say that every time we've stayed there we've taken full advantage of the bus system. No matter where we go on property we use Disney Transport 99% of the time. We do drive to DTD. We do drive to the water parks. But that's pretty much it.
Having stayed at the Beach Club, I do like the ability to be able to walk to Epcot and/or take the Friendship boats. That's part of my love for VWL---you can boat to the Magic Kingdom.

Boating is always a fun option and something we don't get to do at home. "Hey kids, throw on your life vests, we're boating to Kroger!!!"
That is really part of the beauty of DVC....there are resorts for everyone's tastes and prefences. I know there are some who would NEVER stay at VWL (who don't like it even though they've never stayed there) I say that's great.....b/c then there is less to interfere with ME making reservations! But really, we stay lots of places depending on the time of year or if we are taking guests. We LOVE VWL all the time but ESPECIALLY if we're going in the fall/winter or we're taking guests. We love OKW if it's a spring vacation b/c the atmosphere literally launches us into "summer mode." We love BCV if our vacation is going to be a "swim vacation." And we were really blown away at Saratoga Spring's amenities the last time we were down.
Speaking of....Amanda, why not stay at SSR??