...Saying that, when I read that someone in the third round (I've never made to the second in three years), has gone just a handful of times, and only in the past two years, I'm confused. ... As someone who has stayed at 15 of the resorts, eaten at probably, most of the restaurants/counter service, I'm just confused.
Thanks for feeling free to voice your opinion and concern. I'm sure you aren't alone in your point of view. It is interesting and healthy to know what others are thinking / feeling.
I personally agree with several others who replied to your post with support for a Panel with a variety of backgrounds.
It is definitely helpful to have
some panelist that have significant experience (e.g., 50+ trips, stayed at all resorts, eaten at most restaurants), but that is just part of the equation.
Before I was on the panel, I had been to WDW fewer than 10 times. I gained most of my WDW knowledge planning a family trip about a year before I made it on the panel. I'd like to think that my more recent experience of going through a very detailed (OK, obsessive
) process of preparing gave me a different perspective from some others.
For me, I only needed about three trips to become a helpful WDW planner:
Trip 1: Didn't plan. Long lines, and didn't experience much
Trip 2: Hyper-planned. Tried to see and do everything, and was exhausted at the end of the trip
Trip 3: Found the right balance for our family and had a great experience
During my year on the panel I tried to help people learn from my recent experiences, so they might actually have a "trip 3" on their first trip.
Could I answer all of the questions about every resort and restaurant? No. But I was able to answer other very important questions from first time planners trying to prepare as best as possible for their "once in a lifetime" trip. My hope is that some of the families we helped had a great time, experienced some magic and have since decided that once is not enough.
It's also worth mentioning that "WDW experience" is probably only part of the equation. I think it also helps to be professional, write well, show empathy for others, get along in a group, etc. etc. Also seems that more recently they are looking for some folks with social media experience.
I doubt my words will change your mind, but I do sincerely thank you for prompting this healthy discussion, and giving me reason to share my perspective on the issue.
- Bret
p.s. Good luck to everyone waiting for the final 2010 Moms Panel decision today (at least I HOPE it's today!!!)
She climbed into Mommy & Daddy's bed, located my beloved Figment from my 1984 trip, snuggled up and fell asleep. Most likely, she is having Disney Dreams like her Mommy will tonight
But DH bought me a new one 2 years ago 
good luck to everyone today
.
