I am actually a
castaway club gold member but all of my cruises were 2005 and before. I haven't cruised in 11 years! That's what happens when you have a child and then get a divorce I guess. I have never been on any of the newer ships (I keep wanting to call them boats, I live on an island and we live and die by the ferry and we always refer to that as a "boat" so it is hard shift for me to make).
The NY itinerary is appealing to me because it is mostly sea days and that is what i like about a cruise. Not sure I am so into all of the shore excursions with my kiddo. I have a hold on the 8 day cruise that includes the day at WDW (included in cost), CC and nassau. having been to the other caribbean locations they do not really interest me all that much as far as going with my kiddo. Europe is a different story but a $13k cruise is completely out of reach for me. I'm not sure I can swing this one and it is $3,600! (I definitely can but have been doing expensive disney trips every 2 years, not eveyr year)
But I think the options i'd look at would be a few days at WDW and then a few days on a cruise (so a 3 or 4 day) but the 8 day out of NY seems like a good alternative to that. only one day at disney instead of 3 but it really would be a more cruise focused vacation, which would be nice for a change. Whenever I cruised before my favorite days were the sea days, just so relaxing. But I don't need a $650 bill right now