We like both equally quite honestly. They are similar but different. The Rose and Crown is always a larger cut of fish, Yorkshire reminds me of the sizes you'd find at Long John Silvers or Captain D's. Not by taste, but smaller, easy to eat with fingers. I believe they use a different fish, but not certain, for each. But flavor wise, we've found very little difference in them. We usually go with Rose and Crown because we generally dislike scouting our own table and serving ourselves, when we have a choice.