We are on the founders list and didn't buy due to the high minimum buy in. I did a little figuring out.
We only travel during the peak season every 2-3 years as we have three kids in school.
We find the one bedrooms for our family of five too small for trips so we get a 2 bedroom. It really matters when we take 10+day trips to WDW.
We do go for more than a few days to DL as the flight costs are 2500.00 to LAX and up to 3500.00 to MCO for our family of five and that is with a seat sale. It will always be a week at DL. We also do So-Cal while there.
We have found we do not use the kitchen (as much as we thought we would) as it is a holiday and we really enjoy letting someone else do the cooking.
It really is about balance and what matters to us personally.
It will cost us 76 points a night to stay s-th and 135 points a night to stay f&s in a 2 bedroom at the GCV.
It will cost us approx (based on the 2009 DL chart) 51 points a night to stay concierge at the DLH and 83 points a night for f&s.
We enjoy the amenities on concierge and are willing to give up some space to compensate for that. We did concierge at Christmas at AKV and loved it!!! We have discovered we spend more time enjoying the hotel and its amenities than the room itself.
We have been to DL many many times and only ever stayed onsite once at the GC.....GO HOJO WOOT!
Here is our take on it. We live 60 miles from Banff National Park. Every hotel around here is themed exactly the same as the GC. We bought at AKV because the african savannahs are far and few between up here in Alberta
When we go to Disney. We want Disney themeing. We are nostalgic old school Disney and love the themeing and the atmosphere of the DL hotel. It is the same reason we love DL over WDW.
The points for GCV only seem high if you are not going to make full use of the Villa. You also have to remember you are getting a whole lot more for your points in a Villa compared to a room at GC. For us since our trips are spaced so far apart we would rather stay concierge at DLH and get that Disney magic there instead. Everybody uses their DVC membership based on their own personal needs and wants.
At the GCV they are in line with supply and demand and you get what you pay for IMO.
