I have never understood why you have to tip someone for doing their job. If you request extra service, then okay, but when all they do is the minimum I just don't get it. I wish restaurants would pay a decent wage and do away with tips.
When we were in Jamaica (a cruise stop) everybody wanted tipped and they came right out and asked. I know they are really poor but I still resented the fact that I was expected to tip them when they really did not do anything extra to earn it. I think a lot of people felt that way, and we just gave them a tip because we felt like we had to. We gave our cabin stewart extra because he did a great job, I never had to fill the ice bucket, and they clean your room twice a day. Of course when you go on a cruise you know what you are expected to tip, and they just charge it to you, but you can adjust it according to the service you receive.
Does anyone know if the mousekeepers at the luxury hotels make more than the ones at the value resorts?