Would you spend $5 more for this Cinderella costume?

[JodiR]

The one on the left is the least expensive. The other is $5 to $6 more and is of a deluxe type. Velet bodice, silver satin puffs and sleeves. Which is more appealing and is it worth spending an extra $5 or more for it?

 

[Ilovemyprincesses]

I probably wouldn't because the cheaper one looks fine. If the cheaper one looked scratchy or plastic I would spend the extra money.

 

[kribit]

I personally like the one on the left. Looks more original (like the real Cinderella).

 

[belle&beast]

I actually like the colors on the less expensive dress- it looks more like Cinderella in the movie to me.

 

[minnie1928]

I like the one on the left too, looks more Cinderella-ish.

 

[luv2nascar]

my dd has the one on the left and it is a great dress. I like the colors and the look of the one on the left.

 

[kami2199]

My dd had the one on the left for the MNSSHP we attended about two years ago. It is really nice (assuming the same seller) and extremely comfortable. I like the way it looks a little better than the other one - more original. Save your money!

 

[MinnieGi]

I also like the one on the left. More of a traditional Cinderella dress.

 

[JodiR]

They are made by the same company. They are introducing a deluxe line of Cinderella, Belle, Snow White, Sleeping Beauty and adding Tinkerbell. I am a retailer and wanted to know if people would buy the new line or not. So maybe I should invest in the original ones instead.

 

[jjenniboo]

I like the one on the left as well. Looks more traditional.

 

[LadyyRedd]

Before I read what you wrote in the OP, I thought that the one on the left was the more expensive one. I like that one better. I don't like the gold coloring.

Kimya

 

[pixiepower1971]

I like the one on the left as well. DD9 just came through and I asked her(big Cinderella fan and has had MANY dresses over the years). Her IMMEDIATE answer was "the one on the left". When I asked her why she responded with "it looks more like Cinderella!"

 

[JodiR]

Thanks everyone. That helped alot!

 

[Mickey527]

My eyes immediately went for the one on the left. I also thought it looked more like Cinderella.
Then I scrolled down a bit and hid the girls faces, hair and the neckband and I liked the one on the right better. It appears to be better made, and a better quality fabric. I don't care for the color of the shiny fabric but I think it looks more white in the photo than it is.
I know in Cinderella's costume the bustle meets in the middle but on the one on the left it doesn't.
If I was buying it I think I would pay the $5 extra.

 

[It's A Happy Day]

Looking at the pictures I would choose the one on the right as it appears to be a better cloth (not as shiny so not as nylon/plasticky) but when I pick something like this I actually look UNDER the dress more than the outside. I have no problem spending another $5 for a dress that is not going to have itchy netting against my daughter therefor I am going to be hearing less complaining from her when she is wearing it. We also have a dress up trunk so I want something that will hold up to multiple wearings from more than 1 size kid as cousins and friends come over to play too. But I do think that generally population is going to be looking at that 1-2x wear and in those cases they are going to go as inexpensive as possible so from a sellers point I would probably invest in the lesser of the 2.

 

[donnajon]

I would actually pay $5 - $6 more for the one on the left! It looks a lot better.

 

[EMom]

I'd go for the more expensive one on the right. I like that it has a sheer overskirt layer. My DD would like the heavier, "sparkly" sleeves and bustle (?). The skirt also looks like heavier, more substantial fabric.

 

[TnTWalter]

I know I've seen it before on here but can't remember....these are less scratchy right? I'd like to get some for MNSSHP. Thanks...
Oh and they're both beautiful but the one on the right might be a bit too cumbersome for walking around IMHO.


Trish

 

[JodiR]

TNTWalter...sent you a PM. Thanks

 

[GoofyGolferGirl]

I like the one on the left better too!!