Ok so here's an idea....
You know how in high school gyms they have retractable stadium seating benches that come out from the wall? Maybe some day Disney will spend the money to come up with a stadium seating system that comes out from the ground. I'm sure it would cost a pretty penny, I'm not sure if they even have that anywhere or if it's even possible (danger of malfunction or something) but it's worth a look into if the show is as good as people say. That way the view would be unobstructed during the day and then during WOC everyone would have a good or decent view (you would still have to worry about that 6'7 guy sitting in front of your kid.)
That type of idea was debated around here a lot in 2010 when WOC first opened and it became clear that Disney dropped the ball on the WOC viewing area design. Once you get there and walk around Paradise Gardens (the WOC viewing area) during the day you will see how much of a challenge that would be. It is not like the F! theater at DHS which is off to the side. The WOC viewing area is right smack in the center of PP.
What you are suggesting is sort of like trying to build some kind of stadium seating or retractable viewing structure at the entrance to say TomorrowLand at MK or in front of the Mickey wizard hat stage area at DHS. Could it be done? Yes. Would it be an eyesore and damage the feeling of openness at the parks? Yes for sure.
Any type of vertical structure at PP to see WOC could improve the view of the show - but make the feeling of entering PP and seeing the lagoon, CA Screamin coaster, Mickey's Fun Wheel, all feel limited and blocked. Even if the structure was retractable it would still have to be employed several hours a night for the show. And during that time anyone entering PP would see the back of a structure and not the lagoon waters and all the rides lit up and inviting.
As I said, once you are there you will see what I mean. And, as I said, all of these ideas were debated in 2010 at length because so many people were so disappointed with WOC. And it got a bit of a bad rap because people said the show was not very good. The fact is that the show is brilliant. The best Disney show ever IMO.
If you can see it from the right location. Otherwise I agree the show is not all that good.
A bad view at WOC - of which 50-80% of the spots are bad depending on your height - is like watching Star Wars or Avatar from the front row of the movie theater off to the far end of the row. You just can't see the screen and your enjoyment of the movie is impaired no matter how good the movie is.
What you probably do not know is that the current viewing area was designed to hold 9,000 guests per show. That is about what the F! viewing area holds at DL. However, once they built it and got people in there they realized they could only hold 4,000 and not 9,000. That put a huge strain on each show because demand was so much higher than supply.
So WOC has a checkered past. Disney designed a fabulous show with a poor viewing area. They are supposed to be good at this kind of thing but they messed up on this one.
My two cents! Heck, my two hundred cents!
