MyLittlePony123 said:
In a surprise twist the other woman emailed me and we exchanged several messages back and forth. She helped me understand the meaning behind a few of their messages but I was not born yesterday and though I do tend to believe her I know there is still much more to the story that I don't know. DH isn't speaking to me now and I have no clue if he knows that she and I communicated with each other.
Maybe I'm being a cynic, but I have to believe that not only does he know that you and the other woman communicated, but he probably encouraged her to make contact in the first place, so that she could provide "innocent" explanations for everything
This way he can:
1. make it seem like you are overreacting, causing you to second-guess your instincts.
2. avoid telling you more lies himself (and digging himself a deeper hole).
3. appear to be the victim ("I am so hurt that you would question me, that I'm not speaking to you") and put
you on the defensive, so you will feel the need placate him.
I hope for your sake that this is all a misunderstanding, but I'm a believer that where there's smoke, there's
usually fire.
The most troubling thing I've read from you so far is that he actually had T.O.W. in your apartment (to, ahem, watch scary movies). This would be unacceptable to me, since it was done without your knowledge.
Again, I realize that none of us know the entire situation, and I would encourage you to not make any hasty decisions based on the opinions of strangers (including my own). Instead, use this forum as a sounding board - to vent and to explore options that you may not have thought of on your own.

I'm so very sorry you're going through this...you sound like a caring, devoted, and attentive wife. It so sucks when life is unfair.