This year I'm doing bead jewelry for my girlfriends. I'm pretty good at bracelets, I've done one pair of earrings, and I'm going to try a couple of necklaces too.
Last year I made some candy (mints and something else I can't remember at the moment) from a recipe I found in Rosie magazine, and they turned out quite well!
Also, this is cheating, but Sam's Club and Costco here sell a really great Pillsbury cookie dough. It's all mixed together, all you need to do is spoon it out onto a pan. People LOVED them. Also, Ghiradelli makes a great brownie mix, that went over really well too.
Last Christmas, we received a tupperware container with all the dry ingredients for cookies. All we need to do is add the liquid.
I have a friend who sells Tupperware, so I bought some from her and I'm going to make an assortment of baked goods and put them in Tupperware, and wrap it with cellophane.
For your caramel apple recipe, maybe you could try foodtv.com or allrecipes.com?