Which SC port is most appealing?

[littleaussie]

I'm looking at the Southern Caribbean cruises for 2018. I've been to most of the ports listed but each cruise week stops at a new island I haven't been to and I'm not sure which one appeals the most. I've done some searching on other boards and it looks like one is least appealing maybe but don't know about the other 2.

The new ports are:
Martinique
Bonaire
Curacao

Prices are all comparable for each week so that's not an issue. Neither is taking one week vacation over another week in January. So it really boils down to those 3 islands.

I've heard Martinique is probably the least appealing but does anyone have experience at any of those 3?

I'm traveling with my parents, my 2 teen daughters and my 2 year old son but port excursions can either be one big family or we can leave the toddler with my parents so that doesn't matter either.

TIA!

 

[Birdie dog]

I've been to all three and done land vacations to two. (Martinique and Bonaire).

Martinique would be my least favorite. Prices are in Euro and I've not met the friendliest people. The beautiful beaches are a ferry ride away (not a deal breaker but Fort de France is an ugly city).

I love Bonaire but there is little to nothing to do. Very little sand beaches. One traffic light.

Curacao would be the best of the three for non scuba divers. I'd head over to near Lion's Dive and have a few drinks on a beautiful beach.