We have 2 favorites.
I am about to call Cro when I finish this post to get a room at POR (Dixie Landings) for one night. It was the last place that we stayed before joining
DVC, and Dh and I still miss it. Strolling the grounds was very romantic.
Disney is trying to lure us back to our first love, the Contemporary. Dh and I stayed off property on our honeymoon, but returned to stay at the Contemporary 2 years later and again for our 10th wedding anniversary. Since we went to the Top of the World on our Honeymoon, I think we will always consider the Contemporary our quasi-honeymoon hotel.
On that 10th anniversary trip in 2002, we were introduced to our DVC love, which of course is the Boardwalk. We strolled around the lake, listen to a saxophone quartet while on the verandah, and played putt putt.
My Disney life would now be complete with a DVC at POR. No, I would not consider DVC for any of the other moderates, nor would I want it to be downscale. I love the resort, and would love to have my DVC amenities there. I would be pretty happy if I could just stay for fewer points.