We've stayed at all of the monorail resorts and WL. We tend to keep returning to CR for the room size end convenience. WL is wonderful, if it were directly on the monorail it would be absolutely perfect. The pool, to me is perfect. The slide comes out in a not so deep end that is great if your children are on the small size. You as a parnet don't feel so paranoid about letting them get in by themselves and you sit on the lounge chair instead of having to be right there when they come off the slide which is how I usually feel. GF is great, we haven't stayed there since they built the theme pool. Poly was okay, the rooms are as large as the CR but our stay was a bit too noisy for DH. We are staying at the Yacht Club next week, can't wait for the kids to try Stormalong Bay, the pool there. I don't think it's possible to go wrong with a deluxe hotel but I guess it depends on what your kids like. My girls have been happy at all of the hotels but even they siad that they didn't care that moch for the Poly, which surprised me. We weren't there for the holidays but I do know that WL goes all out with their decorations and also has a horse driven sleigh ride available. GF has lovely decorations too. Hope this helps..............