Oh my gosh was ours budget LOL. We were very young (19 and 20), and just starting out mind you. We planned to spend four days in Orlando and three in Tampa, but we made NO RESERVATIONS before we went. In August. In Orlando. You get the point LOL. I was embarrassed to type that! We laugh about it now of course, but I remember the first night of our honeymoon, I'm sitting in the car crying while my husband is frantically going from hotel to hotel trying to find a vacancy in Orlando (near Universal, none the less). I had just about given up when we found a nice, brand new Extended-Stay hotel. It was so new the carpets had been shampooed that day because they just opened! We were a few blocks from Universal, and had a great time walking to Universal at our leisure. We also spent one day at Epcot (had to have some Disney in the mix!

). We liked the hotel so much that we asked the front desk to find us one for our Tampa stay, and we made reservations before we got there this time.

When we got to Tampa, we went to Busch Gardens, watched some movies, and then... nothing. There isn't a lot to do in Tampa IMO, and it's not my favorite city. So we left a day early to go home and took the loss for the room out of boredom lol. I look back on this, eight years later, and realize how very young and dumb we were! I would never DREAM of going on a long vacation without reservations. Granted there are the spur-of-the-moment overnight stays, but a honeymoon...
The good thing was, we received almost $2000 in gifts from our wedding, which paid for the wedding AND the honeymoon. Two broke kids ended up with some wonderful memories and a lot of laughs, and I suppose that is all that matters

.
As for the other questions- my favorite tropical destination is
Castaway Cay! I LOVE DISNEY CRUISING. I can't even justify going on another line at this time. I have been to several islands in the Caribbean now, and I like the Bahamas best. They are close to me in Florida, and Paradise Island looks just like South Florida, so I feel at home. I love the Caribbean, and one day (when I win the lotto) I may like to get a boat to live on and just cruise along the azure waters. If anyone hasn't gone there yet, please do, it is the most zen-like experience I've had in my life. To be at sea is to loose yourself, your worries, and to put everything in perspective. You feel very small out there.
The best trip I've ever taken is a tie between one of the 4-day Disney cruises I've been on and our week-long first anniversary stay at the Wilderness Lodge (apparently by our first anniversary we had learned our lesson!). Both are very different, so it is impossible to compare them. But to have the best weather, the best experiences, best fun- they are both huge highlights of my life.