We loved the themes of All Star movies, staying there in Feb, 2011 for our first disney vacation with the kids
Biggest problem was at check in. Wife booked the Toy Story wing (we stayed at AS Movies specifically for the Toy Story theme as our boys were huge into them at the time) and she went in to check us in as I waited in the car with the boys. She came after and I could see in her something was really wrong. I got out of the car and met her halfway and she broke down in tears. They did not have our toy story room but instead "upgraded" to the dalmation wing. Well, that is not what we wanted so I went in myself, calm, cool and collected but fully ready to get a little loud and angry if necessary. Wife had put so much effort into planning and I was not about to have our disney experience turn sour that quickly. Luckily, I did not have to get loud or ask for management cause explaining the situation and that I needed it resolved, they somehow found a room available. Daddy saved the day. I was proud of myself.
The room is small and we felt crowded but the experience was great. The pool was fine and the dining area was good enough, though we spent little time there during our 5 night stay.
The only other problem was that on last day of housekeeping (we were checking out the next day), they somehow scooped up our 5 year old's little lamb that he had slept with since he was an infant. We made sure each day we fished it out of bed so it would not get scooped up if they changed sheets. It seemed like they "knew about it" since each day when we got back they had put on the bed pillow sitting up to sort of welcome him back. Well we got back late the last night and kids were out cold. In the morning, as we packed and got ready to check out, we turned that room inside out. There was no sign of it anywhere. DS5 was already freaking out ("lambie pie" sat with him whole drive down and he was looking for it to sit with him) and it became uncomfortable quick. Wife and I assumed housekeeping had scooped it up and that maybe we didn't ensure it was not in sheets previous morning. I went to front desk but there was nothing they could do then as it would be in transit to the laundering facility. I filled out a form and returned to the car. Having to go back out to the car without it in my hand and tell him they didn't have her was about the most heartbreaking thing I ever had to do. So I drove away with all of us in tears. I called pretty much every day to check the status for a month or 2 but lambie pie never turned up.
Other than the issue in the beginning and end, we enjoyed our stay and are considering and All Star sports this time. Currently have the AoA Cars suite booked for Feb 2013 but if it not a
free dining week, we will likely split stays and stay at AS Sports for part of the trip to cut costs.