I'm not scared easily, blood and gore doesn't frighten me at all, I'm more freaked out my psychological thrillers and the chase aspect of scary movies.
The first scary movie I ever say was Return of the Living Dead, the 80's version of it . It scared the daylights out of me, I was 7 years old. I bought it on dvd not too long ago and watching it now is pretty hilarious. I can't believe I was scared by it.
Nightmare on Elm Street 1 - the best one, the scene with Johnny Depp in bed is still sickening to me maybe it's because I love him so much lol The thought of falling alseep and being killed was pretty unsettling for me as a kid.
When a Stranger Calls - the only movie that made me so scared I turned on every light in my house. I went around the house with a hockey stick opening all closets, looking under all beds, etc. before I could go to sleep that night.