Everyone in my family loves Tigger tails sold back at Pooh Corner. Though not at a candy store, Churros are a must for me.
Dark chocolate covered pineapple spears! Also the peanut brittle. For that matter, any candy that is being made fresh that day (check Candy Corner in DL, Trolley Treats in DCA, and Marceline's in DtD). Caramel corn in DCA. DH's absolute favorite is the chocolate covered English Toffee, especially when it is made fresh.
I wanted to add onto the OP's question and ask where is the best place to find these treats, especially in DCA? I'm familiar with almost all the treats people have listed and where to find them in DL but not DCA. Is Trolley Treats the best place to find goodies in DCA? What other spots in DCA have good treats?
Can't wait to indulge in some of these goodies again on our trip in August.
Where do you get the toffee?
As theluckyrabbit said, the toffee can be found at multiple locations, but make sure you buy the ones that are handmade at DLR. The current stickers say "Made Fresh with Magic". Many of the candy locations also sell pre-packaged toffee that is not the same as the hand-made one from DLR. So just make sure you get a package of the handmade one!Where do you get the toffee?