I have two boys, 4 1/2 and almost 6

Big constant loves around our house is anything to do with trucks, cars, or balls.
And yes, ANYTHING TS3. They have buzz and woody already, but are asking for Jessie (I ordered her already, need to find either Bullseye or Zurg for the other one)
They're also both asking for pillow pets every time we go to the store, so I picked up a couple of those (wanted to get them early in case there was any issue keeping them in stock)
They're getting Mater, Toy Story 3, How to Train your Dragon, and Fantasia in their stockings.
Um... what else... Legos! I almost forgot the legos. We have a huge
lego collection already though so they're not getting more

Another big hit is just plain wooden blocks. The things they can build with those! Army men are another big hit. I picked up a huge bucket full at a yardsale over the summer and am always stepping on them...
My oldest also love his CD player in his room (yes, I could get him an mp3 player, but the CD player is cheaper and we have a big ole stack of CDs I can just burn them whenever I feel like)
And if all that isn't enough, a puppy? Mine love theirs
Really I think like the other poster said they're still pretty easy to buy for at this age. Almost any toy is fun!
