My wife does not read to DIS, she spends very little time on the computer, so it's pretty easy for me to spill all here. it's helped a lot in fact, because I can't talk about it at home!
And DD really likes LwtL too...so I know she'll like the restaurant. We just have never been able to squeeze it in with trying all the WS restaurants, which we still haven't tried them all. But, I decided to give this a go instead of Chef Mickey's, which we did last trip, and while enjoyed find the food a bit so-so...
You've NEVER ridden JC? For shame! About JC - If you have never ridden it, I wouldn't recommend after dark for the first ride ever...it's a different experience, but it's not better. The key to a good JC experience is a good skipper...one who really sells the awful awful jokes, and as passengers, being able to enjoy the awful, awful jokes. Some skippers don't even do a lot of the jokes. (There are more jokes in the routine than can be told in one ride, so multiple rides with different skippers can provide vastly different experiences.) A bad skipper makes the rides very boring...the ride itself is sort of lame as an adult, but with the right skipper we find it so much fun. But again, you need to be in the mood for bad puns and other groan-inducing jokes. (A non-spoilery sample joke sometimes said while passing the savannah area: "The rocks you are seeing are sandstone, but some people take it for granite." Yep...that bad. But if sold right and you take it the right way, it can be a blast.
At night, the ride is very dark...you really can't see a lot of the animitronics very well. Because of this, you can see the sites in the temple (the indoor portion) much better because your night vision is adjusted. We did it once before, but we had a terrible skipper, so I'd like to try it again with hopefully slightly better luck. But I would say that if you ride it once during the day and decide to try again, check it out at night. (FP is a good idea for this ride, as the line is one of the slowest moving in MK! Because DD likes the ride so much, we have probably spent more time in line for JC than any other ride at WDW - partly because we almost never wait in lines, but often do at JC because we need to ride it at least twice!)