Was Jill Carroll Really Kidnapped?

[DawnCt1]

Sometimes though, a cigar is just a cigar.

I'm sorry but I have trouble thinking that a "cigar is just a cigar" since 'you know who'. Maybe we could use a "duck is a duck".

 

[momof2inPA]

All of those right wing nut jobs (especially the Christians) who said she faked her kidnapping, should be utterly ashamed, and the rest of you should quit listening to them.

 

[JennyMominRI]

If anyone can recall the video of her pleading for her life that they aired -- well, I don't think you can fake terror like that.

I agree..Those were horrible and heartbreaking to watch

 

[DawnCt1]

All of those right wing nut jobs (especially the Christians) who said she faked her kidnapping, should be utterly ashamed, and the rest of you should quit listening to them.

Oh yes, ESPECIALLY THE CHRISTIANS. It must be a "Christian Conspiracy".

 

[JennyMominRI]

Oh yes, ESPECIALLY THE CHRISTIANS. It must be a "Christian Conspiracy".

I knew it! But Jeez, I never thought you all would admit it!

 

[Jabber_Jaws]

All of those right wing nut jobs (especially the Christians) who said she faked her kidnapping, should be utterly ashamed, and the rest of you should quit listening to them.

I am not right wing, and also not a christan so strike 1. I never said she faked her kidnapping. I only want to know the whole story is before I decide. Wow she told her family about it, and they told the american public. SO what. If I told my family that momof2inPA gave my 1 million dollars, and they reported it to the news does that make it true? Nothing wrong with questioning something, before knowing the whole truth. Otherwise you are just blindly following.

I think you feel silly for writing it to begin with. When reading the articles, did you miss that she has spoken with her family?

I don't feel silly at all. As I said before it was a tongue in cheek comment. Another swing and a miss for you.

Please do me a favor and don't quit your day job to work for Silvia Brown. Your physic powers are just not there.

 

[gate_pourri]

All of those right wing nut jobs (especially the Christians) who said she faked her kidnapping, should be utterly ashamed, and the rest of you should quit listening to them.

Wow. All I can say is, Wow.

 

[Keli]

You know, I watched that interview she gave on CNN. They were announcing she was released, they were showing this interview where she repeated stated that she was never threatened and they never threatened to 'hit' her (somehow I think she was really worried about them cutting her head off or shooting her in the head, not hitting her...).

Anyway, NOT ONE TIME did I see CNN report that this interview was given to her captors, not an Iraq news team, and that SHE WAS STILL IN THEIR HANDS while it was given!

No wonder so many people were wondering about the legitimacy of her kidnapping! I believe that CNN did a disservice to America in the way they aired the whole thing. Surely they realized the implications here and should have made the situation much clearer. Really makes me feel CNN dropped the ball and they have lessened their credibility in my sight.

 

[ozarkmom]

Just saw Jill Carroll's plane landing and the news said she recanted what she said earlier that she did what she had to to get out of the country

 

[Lanshark]

All of those right wing nut jobs (especially the Christians) who said she faked her kidnapping, should be utterly ashamed, and the rest of you should quit listening to them.

Let's substitute Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus or any other religion in for Christians and everyone would be screaming at the top of their lungs.

The statement is extremely offensive.

What does someones religious affiliation have to do with this subject and why are Christians "right wing nut jobs"?

I do not believe there is a conspiracy. I am a Christian. I am a moderate. I wonder what bucket I belong in....