UPDATED: 10 Night Southern Caribbean - Parts 1, 2 & 3

Amlee said:
Go Steve! :cheer2: Go Steve!


Wow, how funny that the cult members have to show up to support one another. Sorry I did not bow to the pressure to be part of your group. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I am certainly entitled to mine. There is no right or wrong, so there is no point trying to convince me you are right.
 
Disneynut1955 said:
Wow, how funny that the cult members have to show up to support one another. Sorry I did not bow to the pressure to be part of your group. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I am certainly entitled to mine. There is no right or wrong, so there is no point trying to convince me your are right.

CULT???? what are you talking about? That is very rude of you!!

You gave an opinion, I gave one back. No one here is trying to convince you of anything. Amlee is just agreeing to my Opinion and maybe she feels the same way.

How dare you metion a fellow Disboarder as a "Cult" memeber. Now you just are contradicting yourself.

Shame on you for that comment

Steve
 
Disneynut1955 said:
Wow, how funny that the cult members have to show up to support one another. Sorry I did not bow to the pressure to be part of your group. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I am certainly entitled to mine. There is no right or wrong, so there is no point trying to convince me your are right.


LMAO! Cult!? now that is funny. You voiced your opinion, Steve voiced his and I happen to agree with what he had to say. I didn't see the need in repeating what he said or pointed out. I made my point with a few words. Nobody was "pressured" to be apart of our group. Most of us enjoyed meeting and interacting with other people. Your right everyone is entitled to their own opinion, it doesn't have to match up to yours. Who's trying to convince you of anything? We didn't agree with some of the things you said. That is life in the public!
 

GoofyGuy777 said:
Please expain the "pressure", and what kind of group? :rotfl2:


Wow! I guess Steph sent the Concierge group out to pressure everyone to attend. I must have missed the showing at my lowly cat 6. Rats!! That's what I get for interacting with new and interesting people!
 
GoofyGuy777 said:
Seems like most the problems you had were with "Special" requests, than that of the "Average Joe".

I have to disagree. Please don't try to make this a class issue. Regardless of what category room you sail in, if a cast member tells you that they have noted a request and it is taken care of, you have every right to expect that to be the case. We are not guests staying at a friends house, but paying customers.

GoofyGuy777 said:
All the shows were very good! I agree there should have been more "Muppets" in the Muppets show, but it was good. I have to disagree, but The Art of Disney was a great show. We went back and watch the third showing of it (it looked liked many people liked it cause the third showing was 70% full with a standing ovation). I'm not going to get into it with you about the Hercules show.

You are certainly entitled to your opinion, and I am glad that you enjoyed the show. Why the need to try to change my opinion of what I experienced? I did not care for Muppets show one bit. I am always amused by those who feel that Disney can do no wrong.

GoofyGuy777 said:
I'm surprised with the number of things you have to complain about, that you have booked addtional Disney Cruises.

I have been on three Disney cruises this year alone. As you pointed out, each time is in a Concierge level room. I continue to spend vast sums on Disney for one simple reason, it is well worth it and I have a wonderful time.

GoofyGuy777 said:
Please do remember the problems that Dave's report would not apply to everyone. Do not let this report pre-judge the new shows and parties that Disney is testing. I think with was Disney was testing on this crusie, they did a great Job.

So if they are truly testing them, shouldn't Disney hear both your glowing acceptance of the show as well as my opinion that the Muppets show did not meet the high standard Disney is known for?

Your characterization of my trip report is not a true representation of what I wrote.

GoofyGuy777 said:
1) You didn't like the shows
2) You went happy with the themed nights
3) They only food you liked was Palo's
4) Price of bingo was too high
5) Music at the deck parties (Since the music was standard music you would hear at any party).

1) I loved the shows. I thought two of the much hyped additions were lacking. One was downright horrible. I am glad that you accept the Muppets as a "good show". In most circles this may be considered good. With Disney, they have set the bar so high, it did not meet expectations of anyone we talked with. The second show was not great, but good. It can be improved on.
2) I loved each and every theme night! Try reading the report again. Not once did I complain about any themed night.
3) I never said the only food I liked was Palo's. I clearly stated numerous times that the various food items were excellent. Once again, please read the report.
4) Price of Bingo was too high. This remark was somewhat sarcastic. Yes, I do feel that $70.00 for Bingo is way too high, however, I will be the first to admit that I was aware of the price and I chose to participate.
5) Yes, the music is repeated for every single deck party. In your eyes, this is acceptable? With the vast number of songs that exist, the same 5 or 6 songs repeated for each party is just fine with you?

Your argument seems very suspicious. My wife and I felt uneasy about the whole "group mentality" of this trip. We don't need to open our stateroom to others for tours and wine parties to feel "accepted". We do just fine on our own, thank you.

I certainly have no problems with anyone expressing their opinion about the cruise even if it is vastly different than mine. What I do find amusing is when someone elects to argue about my OPINION and yet you do not take the time to accurately quote what I wrote. What is even more astonishing, is the fact that others from your "group" feel the need to enter to forum with commentary like "Go Steve, Go Steve".
 
Okay now...agree....to disagree...

AND BACK TO THE TRIP REPORT!! I am enjoying it all....and I reserve the right to form my own opinion......

More report please :bitelip:

:grouphug:
 
tjeagle said:
Okay now...agree....to disagree...

AND BACK TO THE TRIP REPORT!! I am enjoying it all....and I reserve the right to form my own opinion......

More report please :bitelip:

:grouphug:

I agree... Maybe I am out of line expressing my opinion with the "cult" analogy. Should anyone want to discuss this issue further, feel free to email or send a private message.

Final portion of trip report coming up....
 
Amlee said:
Go Steve! :cheer2: Go Steve!

This type of immature behavior is just so lame. Grow up people - this is one man's trip report and frankly - (get ready - my opinion) are you ready? can you handle it?

EXCELLENT.

So if you want to post your own trip report fine - otherwise get a life and stop trying to get into some kind of "my opinion counts - versus your opionion" battle. Just take the good and the bad - and LET IT GOOOOOOOOO

Dave - Welcome home! AND THANKS!
 
TiggersPal said:
This type of immature behavior is just so lame. Grow up people - this is one man's trip report and frankly - (get ready - my opinion) are you ready? can you handle it?

EXCELLENT.

So if you want to post your own trip report fine - otherwise get a life and stop trying to get into some kind of "my opinion counts - versus your opionion" battle. Just take the good and the bad - and LET IT GOOOOOOOOO

Dave - Welcome home! AND THANKS!

Oh please! :rolleyes: You might want to go back and reread the above post, as it was the OP who couldn't handle people not agreeing with his opinion on things. It was the OP who started the name calling and insulting. So if you want to quote an imature quote or tell someone to grow up lets be fair all the way around here.
 
Oh let's also point out that the OP had no problem coming to the "Cult" thread and posting his " extra experiance". *cough* brag much!? *cough*
 
Amlee said:
Oh let's also point out that the OP had no problem coming to the "Cult" thread and posting his " extra experiance". *cough* brag much!? *cough*

Enough already... I agree, my comment and opinion on the group was out of line. I apologize. I am not adding to this thread with a back and forth discussion. Feel free to email me if you want to discuss this in private.
 
Steve, one final comment here. I once again disagree. You did not start an independent thread and post your own trip report, you came into one authored by me and told me I was wrong.

Even if I complain about everything on the cruise, my experience was unique to myself. How you can comment about what is in my head and my heart is beyond me. Your experiences are unique to you and I am glad that this trip was perfect for you. It would be great if you were to write your own trip report so people can view a different opinion.

GoofyGuy777 said:
Dude........
You are the only one who need needs to be "accepted" here. Nobody here posts how many times they are going to stay in a "suite" or "cat 2" in there sig.

Food for thought. Once again, I am not saying my way is right, but consider this... All over Disboards, it is an acceptable practice for someone to brag about scoring a "secret porthole room" or a complimentary "upgrade".

So why is it is not acceptable when someone brags about their high level stateroom. Why is this??? The difference is, I don't bash anyone who has bragging rights to scoring a great deal or a free upgrade. Why should you feel slighted when I discuss what I am proud of???

GoofyGuy777 said:
No one here was pressured to show off their Cat 1 room. Steph5 was kind of nice to host a party. We had a good time. WHY ARE YOU ON THE BOARDS? if you have a problem of being apart of any group? You contractdict yourself again

Funny, the person you cite above has exactly the same thing posted in her signature (copied below). As she opened up to the group and invited you in, her signature must not count in the above argument?!?!?

Stepht5 said:
Oct 2005 4nts GF SL/ 3nts Wonder Cat 3
Feb 2006 5nts GF SL/ 3nts Wonder Cat 3
Sept 2006 10nts Wonder Cat 1
26ds & 23dd Cat 8

With this I am done...Feel free to email me to discuss further.
 
SUNDAY - FINAL MORNING

We did not sleep at all. Our “dear friends” Kevin and Julia, despite several warnings, did not finish packing until 4:00 AM. We feel sorry for whoever had to deal with the bags (if you are reading this, my apologies for the delay).

Monica was first out of the cabin to her early appointment with Immigration. Once she had her “green card” back, she came back to the room just as room service arrived. We ordered way too much, but it always fun trying to get it all down. Once again, wheat toast saves the day!

We went downstairs to seek out Rodrigo. We wanted to say goodbye and he promised us he would find us at some point in the morning. Rodrigo was helping collect the various comment cards from everyone. We spent a few minutes chatting and he asked if we were leaving yet. We told him no, we still needed to get some photographs from Shutters.

Off to Shutters we went. We bought several stock photos showcasing the ports of call. Monica and I have our photos from each trip framed. No matter what souvenir we buy, the photos are the best reminders of the trip as they instantly bring about the memories of what fun you had.

We went back to the room and watched Kevin and Julia deal with 300 pounds of carry-on, or in this case, carry-off luggage. We said goodbye to our wonderful stateroom attendant (Negi). Let me say once more how amazing this guy was. We feel as though we made a true friend.

We went down to the third floor and most of the ship was empty at this point. We found Rodrigo who came out and hand us one final little gift. The tipping policy for the Concierge is somewhat unknown (at least to me). We had to force him to take a gratuity. We had a wonderful little talk and said our goodbyes. Rodrigo said we would attempt to extend his contract by one week in order to be there for our next trip on the Wonder (he is scheduled to go home on Jan. 7th, the day we board). That would be a pleasure.

We walked off the ship where we were met by Captain Henry and his assistant Robyn who shook our hands and wished us a safe journey home.

The rest of the trip home was a nightmare and I will spare everyone the details of the tight connecting flight and missing luggage.

In the end a few points I would like to touch base on:

1) When sitting in our room one day, we had a lengthy conversation with both Rodrigo and Claire (the Concierge group) about guest expectations. I made it clear that I considered us to be “difficult guests”. The conversation that followed was enlightening. Rodrigo told us that we were his favorite kind of guests. The reason is that we come on board and politely ask for what we want. We lay out our expectations from the minute we board. He said the “difficult or bad guests” are those who come on board, never say a word or ask for anything and then go home sad and/or disappointed.

Rodrigo said it is Disney policy to never tell a guest “no”. That you should first try to accommodate any request and then inform the guest if it is possible or not. They even have a special assistant on board at a special telephone number to assist cast members with fulfilling guest requests. Both Claire said that their job is to try and exceed guests expectations, not just merely meet them or come close. What a great attitude and what a fine group of people. We wish him well and hope to see him (although he will be in a different role) next time we cruise.

2) Our wait staff…Eric, Romy, Deniz (Roy in Palo). These people could not have provided a better experience. We thank them for everything. It is very sad to come home and not have that level of service. Lunch today at Capital Grille was sad. I could only pick out one entrée and they handed me a bill at the end of the meal! These guys spoil you and we hope that others are as lucky as we are to have them on their dining rotation.

3) Entertainment - The vast majority of entertainment at Disney is wonderful. I still am not fond of the Muppets nor do I think that you will ever see it return its current state. So many of their shows are perfect, that this one seemed slapped together. I stand by my opinion and we will see if Disney feels this warrants a return to the stage at any point in the future.

The rest of the shows (Welcome Aboard, Farewell, Susan Egan) were amazing. I hope these become semi-permanent fixtures on future cruises.

4) Ports of Call - Each port of call was well chosen and I would not be surprised to see this become an itinerary that pops up several times per year. The length of the cruise was great and we appreciate the special effort that went into making sure the guests experienced a great time.

What can I say….Some people read my trip report and see nothing but negative. I so greatly enjoy my Disney cruises that we are already looking forward to the next on in January. I am certainly not a “glass half full” kind of guy so don’t read too much into my sarcasm. Yes, there are a few things that can be improved upon (in my opinion). When you are this close to perfection, I feel that they should know what few items need fixing. We have enjoyed taking couples with us each time who have never sailed on Disney. Each couple at the end the cruise then swears they will only sail Disney for future cruises. To me, that speaks for itself.

We brought home plenty of souvenirs and have each navigator and menu. We would be pleased to answer any questions and would be happy to send scans of any of the paper items we received.

In the end, this is only one man’s opinion. I am certainly not trying to change the opinion of anyone else. I, always enjoy reading what others have to say about certain experiences and then going into an activity prepared. Sometimes I share the same opinion and sometimes I don’t, but it helps to know a little information in advance. That is all this trip report is about. Don’t love or hate the people at DCL because of what I write. Thanks for taking the time to read!
 
Still wading through your TR here...but I see you said you put on your Imagineering jacket...are you an Disney Imagineer?
 
lillygator said:
Still wading through your TR here...but I see you said you put on your Imagineering jacket...are you an Disney Imagineer?


No I am not. To be honest, I don't have that type of creativity in me. Imagineers are far more talented than I. My working relationship with Disney (a long and complicated story) takes me to various places outside of the parks several times per year and I most recently landed at Imagineering in Glendale.
 
Thanks for the trip report. I really enjoyed it, loved that you gave such detail, and appreciated your honest opinions! :)
 
I am dreaming of a 10-day cruise next, perhaps in 2008 (I hope!). We just completed a Western 7-night and it just wasn't enough. I really appreciate all the details of the ports of call and excursions. They sound fantastic!

I remember Rodrigo from our first DCL trip in Feb 2005. He was very, very nice. He refused our tip. Now I wish we had pressed it!
 
tinknsnow said:
I am dreaming of a 10-day cruise next, perhaps in 2008 (I hope!). We just completed a Western 7-night and it just wasn't enough. I really appreciate all the details of the ports of call and excursions. They sound fantastic!

I remember Rodrigo from our first DCL trip in Feb 2005. He was very, very nice. He refused our tip. Now I wish we had pressed it!

I hope you get the chance to get one. I got the impression that they would be done more often. I have no inside knowledge of this, but just a feeling I got from various conversations.

As for Rodrigo, we had to press a great deal, even more than the standard three times. What a great guy!
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!

















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom