I have to agree with the OP. I am at the 180 day mark today. I had to call the group dining line to get our party of 23 ressies for dinner before the Christmas Party. This is the only meal we will all be together. I tried to get Crystal Palace for dinner at 5:30. I was told I had to take the first seating for dinner which is 3pm! HUH? Large groups are forced to take the first seating for the meal you are interested in. We wanted dinner and since dinner starts at 3pm that day at CP we would have to settle.
That is just way too early for dinner so I asked about Chef Mickey's for 5:30. Nope. Dinner starts at 5pm there. That is the only time I was offered at CM. We took it because it was close enough.
I think if I am that organized to be calling 180 days out and they have 23 seats at the time I request then I should get it just like everyone else. We won't all be at the same table but in the same area which is all we really want. Not sure what the big deal is. Why should I have to eat dinner at 3pm just because we are a group of 23? Big deal. She didn't even know if there were openings at 5:30. You are not allowed to be booked. Sucks if you ask me.
Thank goodness we aren't eating as a large group any other day. We would be eating breakfast at 5am for Pete's sake!