I'm a "day before" cold bath thawer. Never had a problem in over 25 years.
I don't pay attention to the brand -- just buy the lowest price and the size I'm looking for. We've never been disappointed.
Last year I tried the cheesecloth method for something different -- it was totally not worth the extra effort.
This year is the first year in 25+ years I'm not cooking. DH and I are taking his aunt to a local hotel's buffet. Costly (and weird not to be shopping and prepping), but I'm in the final 3 weeks of my PhD coursework and don't have the time/energy to deal with cooking on top of it all.