I began my day at the SSR spa. My wife had bought me a massage for our anniversary. It was awesome.
In light of the direction that this thread has been taking, I looked at the entire experience through the "Does this make SSR a great destination?" lens. The first thing that hit me was that I was one of three people at the entire spa. The place was built to handle many more people, but as was the case the last time I was there, it wasn't running at full capacity. Plus, considering you can go to the spa whether you are staying at SSR or not, there is no way to tell whether the other two people (a mother and daughter) were SSR guests or not. The last time I was there, I was staying at POR. I bring this up because my two trips to the SSR spa suggest that it isn't a HUGE selling point for the majority of the people who stay at the resort. Unlike the pools and restaurants, it is used by a small percentage of the guests. In other words, although it sounds great in the sales pitch, odds are that most people are looking for something different in a Disney hotel.
After the trip to the spa, we went over to Downtown Disney, as my sons wanted to spend more of their money on souvenirs. We started at the TRex Cafe, where they made their own stuffed dinos. We then stopped in a few other stores. The thing that struck me was some of the conversations about why Disney was closing things like the comedy club and the Adventurers Club. As I looked around and saw places like Planet Hollywood and the House of Blues, I wondered why they weren't closed if Disney truly felt that the "family" friendliness of Downtown Disney was suffering. There is no lack of places down there where people can drink and get rowdy. I haven't been to either enough to consider myself an expert, but I think more local hooligans would be likely to frequent Planet Hollywood than the Adventurers Club. Hopefully some more entertainment options will open in the future...Another thought I had was that perhaps Disney should consider opening a theater at Downtown Disney for traveling versions of their Broadway shows. That would not only draw more people to the area, but it would also be a neat draw to SSR among the
DVC community. A BCV/BWV person has little incentive to stay at SSR now since they already have restaurants nearby (on the boardwalk and in Epcot), but more theater and other entertainment options might do the trick......Last but not least, and this might be a bit corny, but perhaps Disney should have Downtown Disney go CRAZY for the opening of a new movie. They could have the AMC show the new movie on every screen the first night and have all of the stores run specials and basically CELEBRATE the new Disney movie. Perhaps a star or two of the movie could come out, media, etc.
After that, we went driving around. Our primary goal was to simply see what was beyond the gates of Disney. We drove a bit towards Sea World. We had a cheap $33 (for the whole family) meal at the Olive Garden and then realized how much cheaper it is to eat off Disney property. We had a meal fit for a king for the price that we'd spend at a cheap Disney counter service.
We then came home and used some bleach to clean out the bathroom jacuzzi. I had read horror stories of black gunk coming out when it was first run, but ours must have been well loved in the past. No problems. My kids wanted to try it out, so they splashed around in there for a while.
Then it was off for our first dip in the main pool. It was very nice. I would say that it is comparable to every other DVC pool that I have visited aside from Stormalong Bay at BCV. If you have seen the Wilderness Lodge pool, it is basically the same concept. When you add that pool to the quiet one by the Grandstand, you have a winning combination.
If there is one thing that I have learned in my DVC experience, it is to better use my kitchen. I have spent WAY too much on Disney food this week. In fact, in our first experience using the Tables in Wonderland card, I am not quite sure if it was a better deal than the meal plan. We simply didn't use it well and didn't plan things the best that we could plan them. Next time, we'll buy more food for the villa, and if we have a car we will eat off property more often. During a long vacation, I quickly tire of Disney food.
The more I think about SSR, the more I think that the original idea for the place was a winner. When compared to everything else that Disney had to offer, a quiet, quaint, condo style resort bordering the golf course and Downtown Disney sounded like a great idea. The person who conceptualized it was a genius for recognizing that there are people whose idea of a Disney vacation is more than theme parks, children everywhere you look, and bustling hallways. The person was a genius for realizing that some people want to get away from it all, play a round a golf, and drive their car right up to their room at the end of the day.
BUT....whoever thought that there were THOUSANDS of people who wanted that experience was way, way off the mark. As I stare out across the SSR compound, I can't believe that Disney thought that this sprawling complex would attract this many devoted followers. At the end of the day, this is Disney, and only a small group of guests are looking for what SSR currently has to offer. If you are a park nut (most people), you want to be close to the parks. If you are a theming nut, you want to be totally immersed in a them. If you are an action junkie, you want a lot of things to do, as well as some hustle and bustle, surrounding you at all times. And if you are a parent, you want things that will make your kids say "Let's come back here next time!!!!!"........My kids won't be saying that.
Fixing SSR and making it more palatable to the masses will be difficult. Yes, they can add amenities to make it more appealing, but I think it will always suffer from the fact that it is too big. Even if you LOAD up the Carriage House area with things to do, the people out on the periphery will feel slighted. Part of me things that they should divide the resort in two and create two separate resorts, each with its own feature pool and lobby/restaurant area. As an SSR owner, I definitely want to keep the conversation going. I'm in this for the long haul, and I have faith that Disney has been noting the dissatisfaction among guests and is planning some type of upgrade for the future.