Torn between Narcoosees & Citricos

[jonilovesdisney]

We went to Narcoosees last trip and really enjoyed it. We are going again in January and have Citricos booked to try something new, and so many people here say it is good.
I keep going back and forth about the right decision.
We're not really picky and we're up for trying new things, but we don't eat a lot of "fancy" food either.
Just to put it in context, we really like Cali Grill & Le Cellier, but didn't really like Jiko or Yachtsman.

Based on this info, should we try Citricos or go back to Narcoosees?

 

[madalex]

Try something new! I think Citricos is better than Narcoossees, but I am some stranger on the internet, so what difference does my opinion make? Try a new place and decide for yourself.

 

[BLTLDZ]

We personally enjoy the food more at Citricos, but it sounds more you like you prefer the atmosphere to the food? If that's the case , Citricos is more fancy than Narcoosee, I guess, in the sense that it is definitely "quieter".

 

[BCV23]

Try something new! I think Citricos is better than Narcoossees, but I am some stranger on the internet, so what difference does my opinion make? Try a new place and decide for yourself.

Love that advice!

MY DH and I love Citricos and personally prefer the menu to that of Narcoossee's. Our DD prefers Narcoossee's. DS2 and I dined at both a week and a half ago and Citricos was still the clear winner for me but I probably didn't order well this time at Narcoossee's.

 

[Uncleromulus]

You've been to Narcoossee's--so why not give Citrico's a try if the menu has any appeal?
We do Citrico's each and every trip these days.

 

[Pooh&OurHunny]

We have eaten at Narccoossee's and Citricos and love both. My husband does favor Narccoossee's more than Citricos and I love Citricos more. Both are good.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

I'd stick with Citricos, and find it more comparable to California Grill then Jiko. And I like it better then Narcoossees too.

 

[JimmyV]

I think that Citricos is better by a wide margin. Nothing wrong with Narcoosee's, but I find Citricos far more creative in both selection and preparation.

 

[MrsLS]

I like Citricos much better than Narcoossees. I've been to both a few times. I think the food & service are a lot better. I like Narcoossees too but Citricos is just better and I also love Cali Grill. I've only been to Jiko once and thought my app & entree was very good but my DHs app & entree weren't really that good.

 

[ChelleMouse]

We went to both on our last trip. Everyone in our party liked Narcoosees over Citricos. The meals were both delicious, we just enjoyed one more than the other. I don't think you would be disappointed with either.

 

[Goingon40]

I have done both and found Citricos atmosphere, service, and food to be much better than Narcoosees. Citricos atmosphere is a bit more upscale and was much quieter. Service was much more attentative at Citricos. For that matter, I personally enjoyed Citricos dining experience over California Grill and Jikos. Everyone has their own preference though.

 

[cbg1027]

I have been to both, and returned many times to Citricos because I think it is FAR better than Narcoossee's. Citricos is my favorite signature!

If you want to know more, I have reviews of Citricos in both the DR's linked in my signature.

 

[let'sgo]

DH still speaks of Narcoossee's and he loved the lobster there, but I think that Citricos was better. They are both great choices, I'd stay with the Citricos just for the variety.

 

[GailT]

i have eaten at both and love both, one not more then the other, I make sure I do both each time and another new favorite it CG, that is my Christmas Eve
I am sure no matter what you pick you'll enjoy. I do find the hotel resturant food is so much better, just my opinion

 

[Madhatter266]

We have had excellent experiences at both of these restaurants. It is difficult to choose just one - but I believe that I would lean towards Citricos.

 

[jonilovesdisney]

Thanks everyone for your feedback!
I think I'll stick with Citricos and try something new.
We're on deluxe dining, so it's not like I'll go hungry if I don't like it. I'll probably have just eaten! Ha! We did Deluxe last time and said we wouldn't do it again because it was too much food...but...we like to eat at table service and when I did the math it was just a better deal, so here we go again.

 

[MickeyNicki]

DH loves Cali Grill and Le Cellier but doesnt like Jiko or Yachtsman

He LOVED Citrico's, we had an amazing meal there last year so I added it in for our trip this time too and I ditched Flying Fish (which we love so much ) so we could finally try Narcoossee's

I would go with Citrico's (which gets much better reviews than Narcoossee's)